{"evaluation_details":[{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":122,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}","patch_id":"d2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:26.046406","total_time_seconds":11.867,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":121,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:25.665854","total_time_seconds":11.867,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":120,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to address the specific context of distraction while driving.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\nR1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:25.268071","total_time_seconds":11.867,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":119,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that emergency services are called when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:24.451028","total_time_seconds":30.268,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":118,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:28.728786","total_time_seconds":33.408,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":117,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:28.369057","total_time_seconds":33.408,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":116,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:28.016061","total_time_seconds":33.408,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":115,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, emergency services are called.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:27.608783","total_time_seconds":33.408,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":114,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R3 onto R21 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\n\tR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\n\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:10.353946","total_time_seconds":8.63,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":113,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event HumanOnFloor is specialized into HumanOnFloorWithHazard to ensure that emergency services are called only when there is a hazard present.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:09.996801","total_time_seconds":8.63,"use_case":"ALMI","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":112,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_decompose_R21","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:11.046277","total_time_seconds":56.987,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":111,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R21","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:10.664024","total_time_seconds":56.987,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":110,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R21","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:10.292963","total_time_seconds":56.987,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":109,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a security evaluation indicates a data breach risk at a high level, the controller is informed, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nR_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:09.936423","total_time_seconds":56.987,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":108,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\nR7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:47.309274","total_time_seconds":5.586,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":107,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when rights are requested and data compliance is confirmed, the subject is informed, addressing the missing normative behavior identified in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:46.929736","total_time_seconds":5.586,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":106,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\nR3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:07.987823","total_time_seconds":11.495,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":105,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\nR3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:07.667159","total_time_seconds":11.495,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":104,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a DPAUpdate occurs without specific controller authorization, consent is obtained from the controller.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:07.274557","total_time_seconds":11.495,"use_case":"DPA","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":103,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that communicates the robot's operational status.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\nevent InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \nR4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:30.976692","total_time_seconds":6.285,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":102,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure the inform action is contextually relevant.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \nR4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:29.982106","total_time_seconds":6.285,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":101,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R4 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_remove_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:37.890280","total_time_seconds":8.24,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":100,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that notifies the human of the robot's operational status.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:37.554189","total_time_seconds":8.24,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":99,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure that the inform action is contextually relevant when humans are nearby.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:37.246078","total_time_seconds":8.24,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":98,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:48.469988","total_time_seconds":6.579,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":97,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:48.142207","total_time_seconds":6.579,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":96,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:47.809997","total_time_seconds":6.579,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":95,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the identified concern of safety in proximity.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:47.477604","total_time_seconds":6.579,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":94,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:57:59.592143","total_time_seconds":4.015,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":93,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission","patch_id":"d_decompose_R6","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \nR6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R6","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:56:00.339638","total_time_seconds":4.818,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":92,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:56:00.007467","total_time_seconds":4.818,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":91,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R7","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:34.626486","total_time_seconds":6.338,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":90,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R7","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:34.301749","total_time_seconds":6.338,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":89,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:33.952355","total_time_seconds":6.338,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":88,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:33.612675","total_time_seconds":6.338,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":87,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:38.631998","total_time_seconds":6.519,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":86,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:38.314625","total_time_seconds":6.519,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":85,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:37.970075","total_time_seconds":6.519,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":84,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while the robot is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:37.645297","total_time_seconds":6.519,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":83,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:30.635084","total_time_seconds":6.379,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":82,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:30.320945","total_time_seconds":6.379,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":81,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:29.994031","total_time_seconds":6.379,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":80,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:29.647424","total_time_seconds":6.379,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":79,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:56.459339","total_time_seconds":10.988,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":78,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:56.122856","total_time_seconds":10.988,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":77,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:55.786740","total_time_seconds":10.988,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":76,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while it is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:55.459686","total_time_seconds":10.988,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":75,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule13_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\nRule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule13_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:45.840284","total_time_seconds":5.553,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":74,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that sensors cannot be removed without caregiver consent, addressing the concern raised when a user wants to remove sensors.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nr_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:45.491691","total_time_seconds":5.553,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":73,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when data is collected and it is needed for training, the data is anonymized to protect user privacy.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nr_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:19.132478","total_time_seconds":4.908,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":72,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule15","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:18.763180","total_time_seconds":4.908,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":71,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\nRule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:07.911847","total_time_seconds":6.811,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":70,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\nRule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:07.549388","total_time_seconds":6.811,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":69,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the patient's discomfort exceeds moderate levels while tracking vitals, a caregiver is called to address the situation.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:07.202069","total_time_seconds":6.811,"use_case":"BSN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":68,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R2_1 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"d_remove_R2_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:39.552854","total_time_seconds":6.3,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":67,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to monitor user attention, enhancing the response to ensure alertness.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nevent MonitorUserAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:39.227364","total_time_seconds":6.3,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":66,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to ensure metrics tracking is contextually relevant.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:38.903401","total_time_seconds":6.3,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":65,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R2 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"d_remove_R2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:49.919567","total_time_seconds":28.196,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":64,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad measure fullAttentionNeeded is refined into a more specific measure userAttentionLevel to better distinguish the context of user attention while driving.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nmeasure userAttentionLevel:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:49.607681","total_time_seconds":28.196,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":63,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to distinguish when alertness is particularly necessary.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:49.287485","total_time_seconds":28.196,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":62,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action EnsureAlertness is refined into a more specific action EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to better express the intended behavior in the context of driving.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:48.987569","total_time_seconds":28.196,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":61,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R1_1 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"d_remove_R1_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:40.154645","total_time_seconds":6.023,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":60,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to track driver attention, enhancing the system's ability to monitor alertness effectively.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent TrackDriverAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:39.822701","total_time_seconds":6.023,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":59,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to clarify the context in which metrics should be tracked.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:39.497215","total_time_seconds":6.023,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":58,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}","patch_id":"d2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:04.397259","total_time_seconds":4.79,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":57,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:04.060725","total_time_seconds":4.79,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":56,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event TrackMetrics is specialized into TrackMetricsWithLowAttention to better capture the context of low attention levels.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:03.717023","total_time_seconds":4.79,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":55,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule10","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:58.529128","total_time_seconds":7.637,"use_case":"DressAssist","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":54,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule10","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:58.153694","total_time_seconds":7.637,"use_case":"DressAssist","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":53,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule10","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:57.791325","total_time_seconds":7.637,"use_case":"DressAssist","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":52,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the user says stop and the risk level is below moderate, the robot stops its actions, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop\n \t unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nr_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:57.459700","total_time_seconds":7.637,"use_case":"DressAssist","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":51,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability CollectPatientData is refined into a more specific capability CollectPatientDataWithContext to better express the intended behavior in the context of relevant data.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nevent CollectPatientDataWithContext\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:05.958605","total_time_seconds":89.728,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":50,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The general data relevance measure is refined into a patient-specific data relevance measure to ensure the collection of only necessary patient data.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nmeasure patientDataRelevant:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:05.608858","total_time_seconds":89.728,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":49,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event ExaminingPatient is specialized into ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData to ensure data collection is contextually appropriate.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nevent ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:05.263809","total_time_seconds":89.728,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":48,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a patient is being examined and exhibits aggressive behavior, the system refers to a human examiner for safety.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:07.888305","total_time_seconds":30.3,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":47,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent calling support when meeting a user without training data representation, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:07.467584","total_time_seconds":29.623,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":46,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if the patient is not comfortable or if age and consent considerations are not met, a human examiner is referred to handle the situation appropriately.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:07.916262","total_time_seconds":30.291,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":45,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops the session only when the user has provided consent to end the session.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:05.148174","total_time_seconds":29.422,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":44,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to handle the situation where a user requests information but it is not available or disclosure is not permitted, ensuring appropriate actions are taken.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:54.665935","total_time_seconds":102.589,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":43,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\n\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\nRule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:15.980263","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":42,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:15.629261","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":41,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","patch_id":"d2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\n\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:15.310195","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":40,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:14.985781","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":39,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event MeetingUser is specialized into MeetingUserWithChild to distinguish the context of examining a child patient.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:14.603689","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":38,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R23 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"d_remove_R23","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:42.936591","total_time_seconds":32.805,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":37,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly states the reason for not recording, which is the lack of consent.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:42.584960","total_time_seconds":32.805,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":36,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithNoConsent to clarify the context in which recording people is not allowed.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent SystemReadyWithNoConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:42.233022","total_time_seconds":32.805,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":35,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the defeater of R23 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.","operation":"defeater_propagation","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"d_propagate_R23","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:41.883518","total_time_seconds":32.805,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":34,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R22 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_remove_R22","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":0,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:26.840785","total_time_seconds":28.591,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":33,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly requires user consent to avoid redundancy in the rules.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:26.491617","total_time_seconds":28.591,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":32,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithUserConsent to ensure that recording people only occurs when user consent is explicitly obtained.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent SystemReadyWithUserConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:26.155745","total_time_seconds":28.591,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":31,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the defeater of R22 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.","operation":"defeater_propagation","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_propagate_R22","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:25.817827","total_time_seconds":28.591,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":30,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the car is driving and consent from people is not obtained, the system records the people present.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:21.889844","total_time_seconds":40.4,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":29,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"d_decompose_R_new","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:21.522813","total_time_seconds":40.4,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":28,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they have not confirmed their readiness to drive, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:21:39.783689","total_time_seconds":40.717,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":27,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that people are recorded when the car is driving and consent has not been obtained, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:29.249439","total_time_seconds":21.422,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":26,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they are not ready to drive when the system is ready, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:28.996533","total_time_seconds":39.946,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":25,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, ensuring user awareness before driving.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:55.169912","total_time_seconds":40.909,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":24,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent changing the current driving state when the system is ready but the action is not legal.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:58.527428","total_time_seconds":21.409,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":23,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_decompose_R17","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:03.295725","total_time_seconds":43.505,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":22,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R17","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:02.946167","total_time_seconds":43.505,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":21,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R17","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:02.583302","total_time_seconds":43.505,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":20,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, specifically when the door is not closed and the seatbelt is not on.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:02.204689","total_time_seconds":43.505,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":19,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event DeployDrone is specialized into DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages to ensure the inform action is only triggered in the context of critical damages.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:41.779669","total_time_seconds":69.089,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":1,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":18,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action InformKeeper is refined into a more specific action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage to clarify the response to drone damage.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g3","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:41.474383","total_time_seconds":69.089,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":17,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad measure 'damages' is refined into a more specific measure 'structuralDamages' to better distinguish the context of the rule.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nmeasure {structuralDamages}:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:41.158805","total_time_seconds":69.089,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":16,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if a compliance check fails, the system will not ensure compliance, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:50.992833","total_time_seconds":22.518,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":15,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the carbon footprint is high during drone deployment, the keeper is informed to address potential environmental concerns.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:51.467696","total_time_seconds":20.503,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":14,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:30.599701","total_time_seconds":23.552,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":13,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:30.259203","total_time_seconds":23.552,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":12,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:29.920534","total_time_seconds":23.552,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":11,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent deploying the drone when the flight condition is dangerous during the preparation phase.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:29.625801","total_time_seconds":23.552,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":10,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_decompose_R14_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:26.533036","total_time_seconds":23.116,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":9,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the drone is deployed and the battery is low, it must not ground the drone within 5 minutes, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nR15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":1,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":0,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:26.181590","total_time_seconds":23.116,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":8,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R14_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:25.817537","total_time_seconds":23.116,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":7,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R14_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:25.479388","total_time_seconds":23.116,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":6,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:51.568892","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":5,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:51.201900","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":4,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:50.834169","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":1,"defeaters_added":0,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":3,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event PreparingDrone is specialized into PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty to clarify the context in which the drone deployment is restricted.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"g1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","requires_social_scientist_review":1,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:50.477126","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":2,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d2","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:50.098547","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1},{"actions_refined":0,"attempts":5,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":0,"defeaters_added":1,"expert_match":0,"expert_similarity":0.0,"id":1,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R7_1 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","philosopher_comments":"","philosopher_decision":"","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}","requires_social_scientist_review":0,"review_timestamp":"","rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":1,"source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:49.723102","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified":1}],"evaluation_summary":[{"actions_refined":2,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":3.12331579860888,"avg_total_time":34.98984246504934,"avg_validation_time":31.052473469784385,"capabilities_refined":2,"conditions_refined":7,"defeaters_added":1,"rules_added":9,"rules_deleted":2,"rules_modified":10,"social_review_needed":11,"total_records":19,"use_case":"AutoCAR","verified_patches":19},{"actions_refined":0,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":2.885111093521118,"avg_total_time":30.4005552927653,"avg_validation_time":26.54077853096856,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":5,"defeaters_added":1,"rules_added":6,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":6,"social_review_needed":3,"total_records":9,"use_case":"DPA","verified_patches":9},{"actions_refined":2,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":2.842035710811615,"avg_total_time":7.076892801693508,"avg_validation_time":3.048142801438059,"capabilities_refined":2,"conditions_refined":13,"defeaters_added":5,"rules_added":13,"rules_deleted":1,"rules_modified":20,"social_review_needed":11,"total_records":28,"use_case":"CSICobot","verified_patches":28},{"actions_refined":1,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":3.169153873737042,"avg_total_time":87.85684365492601,"avg_validation_time":83.5508483006404,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":5,"defeaters_added":2,"rules_added":5,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":8,"social_review_needed":9,"total_records":13,"use_case":"DAISY","verified_patches":13},{"actions_refined":1,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":3.0620000111429313,"avg_total_time":26.135262639899004,"avg_validation_time":21.865473646866647,"capabilities_refined":1,"conditions_refined":9,"defeaters_added":5,"rules_added":6,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":15,"social_review_needed":8,"total_records":19,"use_case":"ASPEN","verified_patches":19},{"actions_refined":0,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":1.960285748754229,"avg_total_time":5.9078570774623325,"avg_validation_time":3.496142932346889,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":4,"defeaters_added":0,"rules_added":6,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":4,"social_review_needed":3,"total_records":7,"use_case":"BSN","verified_patches":7},{"actions_refined":3,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":4.523937463760376,"avg_total_time":12.482749700546265,"avg_validation_time":7.063562400639057,"capabilities_refined":3,"conditions_refined":6,"defeaters_added":4,"rules_added":0,"rules_deleted":3,"rules_modified":13,"social_review_needed":9,"total_records":16,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","verified_patches":16},{"actions_refined":0,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":2.0239999294281006,"avg_total_time":7.63700008392334,"avg_validation_time":4.591000080108643,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":2,"defeaters_added":1,"rules_added":2,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":3,"social_review_needed":1,"total_records":4,"use_case":"DressAssist","verified_patches":4},{"actions_refined":0,"avg_attempts":"5.0000000000000000","avg_expert_similarity":0.0,"avg_generation_time":2.8864284924098422,"avg_total_time":25.880000523158483,"avg_validation_time":21.64457106590271,"capabilities_refined":0,"conditions_refined":3,"defeaters_added":2,"rules_added":3,"rules_deleted":0,"rules_modified":5,"social_review_needed":3,"total_records":7,"use_case":"ALMI","verified_patches":7}],"experiment_candidates":[{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"379f332d85dedb29f8039ac7fb4cd660b1f632ba","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":156,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to address the specific context of distraction while driving.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to address the specific context of distraction while driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:13.266787","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"dcf232949bc31d5133393a47b69269376c1e7e7e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":155,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R1_2\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:05.246873","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2747973833c244930a7796c24a60d78f7ab02432","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":154,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:04.918821","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"ff71eaa0aaf7d39a940f79841ec8abc0c9b2349b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":153,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that emergency services are called when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that emergency services are called when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:54.872524","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"1683e8f7c6835a6261a68cecf5cf081f1937e0d8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":152,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","patch_id":"d_decompose_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:52.132052","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"c0b06ee659d22678d7a20a3dd5ab2db78614b52b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":151,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R21","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:51.835581","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"883f11026964efefb23a0ab45871d6df8b7b4c3d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":150,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R21","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:51.523839","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"ff71eaa0aaf7d39a940f79841ec8abc0c9b2349b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":149,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, emergency services are called.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, emergency services are called.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:53.148134","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2ba784285c69d39cc9ba99edf7bf57d490f4da54","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":148,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:48.029997","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"46db38599c3bcccc9db8781d0c2e1913892bc29b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":147,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R3\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R3\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:47.719946","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"b7e58fd49ac687dcf5d54846a3342c80cae49705","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":146,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:47.387486","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"a5db302b9fa9f905b0b6b6629c89b857388c6da0","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":145,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event HumanOnFloor is specialized into HumanOnFloorWithHazard to ensure that emergency services are called only when there is a hazard present.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event HumanOnFloor is specialized into HumanOnFloorWithHazard to ensure that emergency services are called only when there is a hazard present.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices","run_id":"0a92f3ec48534d308efebcfeef837ee7","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:05.278267","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"b8956ca7f413ec8aee1e6775c68facf790067e72","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":144,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R3 onto R21 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R3\", \"R21\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R3 onto R21 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})","run_id":"0a92f3ec48534d308efebcfeef837ee7","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:48:59.802134","use_case":"ALMI"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"4319fbb732392bf2288c108063c4929863315a66","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":143,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a security evaluation indicates a data breach risk at a high level, the controller is informed, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a security evaluation indicates a data breach risk at a high level, the controller is informed, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:03:15.762110","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"521485353860a353e3c09ca0f75ee56dc7e71685","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":142,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_decompose_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:03:07.057731","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"8187095864b52f621ee4bf15a3e1dd1608817ab6","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":141,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R21","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:03:06.701022","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2176c0c800ba35d828e658110276598d88295fb5","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":140,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R21","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:03:06.342390","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"00c712b158ff29d3fec60cd4350b9cd45f27a0ca","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":139,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when rights are requested and data compliance is confirmed, the subject is informed, addressing the missing normative behavior identified in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when rights are requested and data compliance is confirmed, the subject is informed, addressing the missing normative behavior identified in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject","run_id":"c2c3980ce3d84f9ab8bde3b97db67f07","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:41.441758","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4591f738f260cd87ad082e7a5b0f021847edd825","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":138,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController","run_id":"c2c3980ce3d84f9ab8bde3b97db67f07","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:37.731369","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"12bb3ea04e117bbf742abb7e408d45f567aaf400","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":137,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a DPAUpdate occurs without specific controller authorization, consent is obtained from the controller.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a DPAUpdate occurs without specific controller authorization, consent is obtained from the controller.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:01:59.333031","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"a340b005d3c8bfd9dc3c429fded699559b9be55c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":136,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:01:51.116314","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f6f6a19ae26bc8881987b5213285ff3d3b354268","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":135,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"original_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:01:50.729848","use_case":"DPA"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"09c82d518bea7640e26aa8b0e091628caa663ec7","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":134,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that communicates the robot's operational status.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4b\", \"original_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that communicates the robot's operational status.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus","run_id":"5351a92f4ace4a08ba536395bf2fc613","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:24.854552","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"3efe9e29367c8cccf7ba2bafaba1664fb050ef2d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":133,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure the inform action is contextually relevant.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4b\", \"original_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure the inform action is contextually relevant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman","run_id":"5351a92f4ace4a08ba536395bf2fc613","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:24.546125","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"c04eef6dc327a953296a98b14a71d4ba917183b8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":132,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that notifies the human of the robot's operational status.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that notifies the human of the robot's operational status.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:30.361228","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"d58873e98f33dc1d0babf64542c0955f1eee435c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":131,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure that the inform action is contextually relevant when humans are nearby.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure that the inform action is contextually relevant when humans are nearby.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:30.053276","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"3e6e61c776971252ff4a9751c20949c71c2aac58","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":130,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R4 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_remove_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R4\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R4 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:24.339149","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"f1e632e1acd5af8e8e849bbb6a27b1d240cedffd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":129,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the identified concern of safety in proximity.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the identified concern of safety in proximity.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:40.360400","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"1b94e900a6b7312722779b145ebc755a12e45027","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":128,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:35.593552","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"df7eb5f30d4c4d6e424a1825b20a0a2691773a2b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":127,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:35.245192","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"8e0be25583ceac7c052f39342df21b95e69ccfc3","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":126,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:34.884767","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"f1e632e1acd5af8e8e849bbb6a27b1d240cedffd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":125,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"61c953b0907f42aca4b7215eefaab2cf","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:57:55.869417","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"f1e632e1acd5af8e8e849bbb6a27b1d240cedffd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":124,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"3998ac49d8cc45449b40bf5cbf6bc50b","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:55:54.121506","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"cf7f70a52aa876312b67e138429eb6bfd6b66f87","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":123,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission","patch_id":"d_decompose_R6","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R6\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R6\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R6\", \"original_rule\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission","run_id":"3998ac49d8cc45449b40bf5cbf6bc50b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R6","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:55:51.114998","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"15e40b580e7da11bc75701c1b693a63879000b40","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":122,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:25.886783","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"c75e604943d48ce646f39cad4a7b1e43f9493b96","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":121,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:21.386340","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"57a4810a83e0e8f1082e29d233aa85a0ca893949","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":120,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R7","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R7\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R7\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:21.069217","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"333747bc9bfbecaf10eef67dfdf5a4efc51eccc0","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":119,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R7","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R7\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R7\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:20.736384","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"b87931569f454cd6aa2436db63ab2babe74514f8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":118,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while the robot is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while the robot is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:29.557023","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"e8454bd54a67a9e60ce902e05a15bf6fc8949e2a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":117,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:25.345994","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"61feb6b342f89bd8eeea0c030f970138358d431a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":116,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:24.962809","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2c44546fc7b65f16e0718153ff15341d66c17b80","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":115,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:24.608008","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"f1e632e1acd5af8e8e849bbb6a27b1d240cedffd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":114,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:22.081149","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f8698839c4235b4cdd81f86621a328c2acc4e05d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":113,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:17.289015","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"e0e084e210f2d8f07718129957393fca173049ef","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":112,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:16.958978","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"ae2478f0ea66dc1fb315feb4854f4f8dd6c5f0e3","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":111,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:16.636020","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"b87931569f454cd6aa2436db63ab2babe74514f8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":110,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while it is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while it is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:47.737405","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"855f943a060308e1c800974941de6261d79ebd9e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":109,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:41.202665","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"8836ed7d489822e5b80738710bd6384689224f56","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":108,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:40.846601","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"fb71f59c0c2bb6596095f138e5e24ff6b9043bf1","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":107,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:40.489370","use_case":"CSICobot"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"9a67bb59b9c2fe7c26ebaf0d494da4d42bde2711","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":106,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that sensors cannot be removed without caregiver consent, addressing the concern raised when a user wants to remove sensors.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that sensors cannot be removed without caregiver consent, addressing the concern raised when a user wants to remove sensors.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","run_id":"378926ca6cbc4213ac762d3a8d5af6a8","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:40.318519","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"d52413570a9568bdff08f0b9d2dc60600de9114c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":105,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule13_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule13_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule13_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule13_1\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors","run_id":"378926ca6cbc4213ac762d3a8d5af6a8","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule13_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:36.677984","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"fea8648ae6823e3cf5777db50a3179aef5c3c08c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":104,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when data is collected and it is needed for training, the data is anonymized to protect user privacy.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when data is collected and it is needed for training, the data is anonymized to protect user privacy.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData","run_id":"9fd4efae1b7540b9a93c350f12f82d9a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:13.698318","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"fbf439e958aa319c42988fb3c6444675b3fe7ab3","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":103,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule15","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule15\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule15\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule15\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds","run_id":"9fd4efae1b7540b9a93c350f12f82d9a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:10.518182","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"9f9caab2110c764470618e681ad281b15f00772c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":102,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the patient's discomfort exceeds moderate levels while tracking vitals, a caregiver is called to address the situation.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the patient's discomfort exceeds moderate levels while tracking vitals, a caregiver is called to address the situation.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:00.476595","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4acaa93001ca3f3d4f07b866dbe80c6c867f516a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":101,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule1\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:59:55.727594","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f0e09f43520c510798c20c739b5a537d1f2995d4","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":100,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule1\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule1\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:59:55.409888","use_case":"BSN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"38439518de3393d32c51a003b97e91fc341522a6","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":99,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to monitor user attention, enhancing the response to ensure alertness.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"MonitorUserAttention\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to monitor user attention, enhancing the response to ensure alertness.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:32.933130","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"e018e49ea19230ac6cc7e18cb5f312aa9db10738","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":98,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to ensure metrics tracking is contextually relevant.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to ensure metrics tracking is contextually relevant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:32.630044","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"c169318a776b5adea4345bf9fc1e7b6d471dde6c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":97,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R2_1 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"d_remove_R2_1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R2_1\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R2_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R2_1 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:28.289589","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"b03842d1835a36e5672b62089e78fb4f8e7294bb","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":96,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action EnsureAlertness is refined into a more specific action EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to better express the intended behavior in the context of driving.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action EnsureAlertness is refined into a more specific action EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to better express the intended behavior in the context of driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g3\"}","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:22.592738","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"c8136403ca971a2b4e1e9dc0073e1951887d79ec","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":95,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad measure fullAttentionNeeded is refined into a more specific measure userAttentionLevel to better distinguish the context of user attention while driving.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"userAttentionLevel\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad measure fullAttentionNeeded is refined into a more specific measure userAttentionLevel to better distinguish the context of user attention while driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:22.262415","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"bad1f07bb17da818d42c911b9ceabc258f2ad8c8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":94,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to distinguish when alertness is particularly necessary.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to distinguish when alertness is particularly necessary.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:21.942710","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"856d56c8ad6274791ad22c582dda1de3c9084b84","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":93,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R2 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness","patch_id":"d_remove_R2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R2\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R2 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:15.384819","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"bf6947bfb5b740d08cf32168a579ae980fa3a01f","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":92,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to track driver attention, enhancing the system's ability to monitor alertness effectively.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"TrackDriverAttention\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to track driver attention, enhancing the system's ability to monitor alertness effectively.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:33.772740","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"1349cbf2f3977935cafd7090473b087b75bd5d16","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":91,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to clarify the context in which metrics should be tracked.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to clarify the context in which metrics should be tracked.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:33.452203","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f1210dcda35b0fafb7770de049215c9996779b5c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":90,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R1_1 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics","patch_id":"d_remove_R1_1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R1_1\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R1_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R1_1 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:29.379862","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"616e23a13853866459eb3b3a7f34b67a264f671a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":89,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event TrackMetrics is specialized into TrackMetricsWithLowAttention to better capture the context of low attention levels.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"missing_element\": \"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event TrackMetrics is specialized into TrackMetricsWithLowAttention to better capture the context of low attention levels.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:52:57.651529","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"dcf232949bc31d5133393a47b69269376c1e7e7e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":88,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R1_2\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:52:54.159572","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2747973833c244930a7796c24a60d78f7ab02432","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":87,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:52:53.843067","use_case":"SafeSCAD"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"5c97eeb28bc694ace9082f3d291445086f254719","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":86,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the user says stop and the risk level is below moderate, the robot stops its actions, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the user says stop and the risk level is below moderate, the robot stops its actions, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:50.074657","use_case":"DressAssist"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"3f063af05a5faa25f659e0164d06d9b343798705","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":85,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:44.654585","use_case":"DressAssist"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"47b1f3bea8bcb4b016eb5fb99edda108cebe294f","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":84,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:44.314561","use_case":"DressAssist"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"1890abfb7c0a0b8c37ba2742cd3a25361344915a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":83,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:43.975764","use_case":"DressAssist"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"36d8ddf76441e224981244350ca666c1c98bf0be","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":82,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability CollectPatientData is refined into a more specific capability CollectPatientDataWithContext to better express the intended behavior in the context of relevant data.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"CollectPatientDataWithContext\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability CollectPatientData is refined into a more specific capability CollectPatientDataWithContext to better express the intended behavior in the context of relevant data.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g3\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:37.706254","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"065432fd0d171708f11dc83a7be8da2b86861514","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":81,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The general data relevance measure is refined into a patient-specific data relevance measure to ensure the collection of only necessary patient data.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"patientDataRelevant\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The general data relevance measure is refined into a patient-specific data relevance measure to ensure the collection of only necessary patient data.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:37.381725","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"fadcd02a922aec3885ddb0d7c9797a397e144e8b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":80,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event ExaminingPatient is specialized into ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData to ensure data collection is contextually appropriate.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event ExaminingPatient is specialized into ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData to ensure data collection is contextually appropriate.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:37.040073","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4973a8cb89172d26695145776730c2f0369e9814","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":79,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove Rule16 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData","patch_id":"d_remove_Rule16","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_Rule16\", \"id\": \"d_remove_Rule16\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove Rule16 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:30.964156","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"48452b54b990775b7fc1df61777febfbc8c3c2ae","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":78,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a patient is being examined and exhibits aggressive behavior, the system refers to a human examiner for safety.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a patient is being examined and exhibits aggressive behavior, the system refers to a human examiner for safety.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:37.563384","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4b26137138de0a5dc4cbfc991b7ac1be79fed097","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":77,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule14\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule14\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:35.541304","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"86a9378ad7559f57cf0a64bf5cf9e5ae22dd3235","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":76,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule14\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule14\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:35.213411","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2e36398de5bad0ad90003d59fe73494e0ed66136","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":75,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule14\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule14\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:34.880470","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"1aac73db71ecea366e5e244b4dad1a0924b4f466","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":74,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent calling support when meeting a user without training data representation, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent calling support when meeting a user without training data representation, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:37.725371","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"7d3281ead9d0ab08fc8436e9271a7ca05be1660d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":73,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:35.899759","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"c6d9be5acf6a6aa54580e0990c078f102c1b1c5e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":72,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:35.575741","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"5a0b6eac326d440fedfc8e4df2e579f07d42e5ed","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":71,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:35.231836","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"c2db06792fb35028ca4531be18dad8ea316a3bcd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":70,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if the patient is not comfortable or if age and consent considerations are not met, a human examiner is referred to handle the situation appropriately.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if the patient is not comfortable or if age and consent considerations are not met, a human examiner is referred to handle the situation appropriately.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:37.940477","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"63c058def9c7c36638f19edebc1066630696ded0","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":69,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule18\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:35.505328","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f42ded08522a22d891a99dd6132e63901ae9499d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":68,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule18\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule18\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:35.178495","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"260d99e0ce21cd103f0ecd40c07a5fe4d4fa8f64","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":67,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule18\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule18\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:34.862087","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"a1fe2ee8681d51f0b1dc6bfdbf7e43b250b195de","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":66,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops the session only when the user has provided consent to end the session.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops the session only when the user has provided consent to end the session.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession","run_id":"3fb3f9ec8e39483590c049be0cee107c","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:39:35.925945","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"4dc651265115a473df2f910768d4884e0595b2fe","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":65,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to handle the situation where a user requests information but it is not available or disclosure is not permitted, ensuring appropriate actions are taken.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to handle the situation where a user requests information but it is not available or disclosure is not permitted, ensuring appropriate actions are taken.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:22.446815","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4deb1a4cf95cae0f0fbbae29a9fdd1fb76285ee6","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":64,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule5\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule5\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:37:09.880626","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4e4b5ffbe28c7934fedfcacda2e0ca9162ee6cdc","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":63,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule5\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule5\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:37:09.546755","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2e0ca03ad07ca4cd2d8553a54e9ab4b16e12b8ef","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":62,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule5\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule5\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:37:09.242795","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"356e3146f9c2c4996144f45e08916688459d7518","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":61,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event MeetingUser is specialized into MeetingUserWithChild to distinguish the context of examining a child patient.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"missing_element\": \"MeetingUserWithChild\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event MeetingUser is specialized into MeetingUserWithChild to distinguish the context of examining a child patient.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:34:44.235486","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2ee14a3e25a8221e3f195f9b17203cdaf8e675d2","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":60,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule19\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:57.033294","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"e527afbfbf2418d12be2cfa5d4151518d3e53973","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":59,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:56.729936","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"57258fa019a73da343318beace0d9e8f7df27c8b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":58,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule19\", \"Rule18\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:56.423741","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"3e61d3019ae137aa439714e9befaa9dfc1117d4a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":57,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule19\", \"Rule18\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:56.090215","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"e957c1ebd0670860421775653a965473b2e1f4d4","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":56,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule19\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:55.757258","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"1b77dbd8cd3d1a63b32b6d79b62e92baad01fb29","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":55,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient","patch_id":"d1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d1\", \"patch_id\": \"d1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:32:55.437785","use_case":"DAISY"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"f4f97cd209e6823323fd686033779fae50169591","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":54,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly states the reason for not recording, which is the lack of consent.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly states the reason for not recording, which is the lack of consent.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:13.365469","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"a853f7436beac93230882dd6bf7e220b3b1dc2ca","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":53,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithNoConsent to clarify the context in which recording people is not allowed.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithNoConsent to clarify the context in which recording people is not allowed.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:13.030751","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"345b37315e293edce1633e36c6f391910e0a2fe8","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":52,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the defeater of R23 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.","operation":"defeater_propagation","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_propagate_R23","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_propagate_R23\", \"id\": \"d_propagate_R23\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_propagation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the defeater of R23 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.\"}","proposed_rule":"R23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:03.711063","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"be45c9237b4a08b500cadba68c766bd2fd75d429","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":51,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R23 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_remove_R23","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R23\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R23\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R23 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:03.395066","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"e4c3a271a3ddf45f559bd7f0adbfd3ae432e62b9","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":50,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly requires user consent to avoid redundancy in the rules.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly requires user consent to avoid redundancy in the rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:59.075404","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"2025937c001dee61b9e10ae9a0f654a971c5d86a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":49,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithUserConsent to ensure that recording people only occurs when user consent is explicitly obtained.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithUserConsent to ensure that recording people only occurs when user consent is explicitly obtained.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:58.760167","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"dcba7dbafb9c364ed566de31f2395decf928c9a4","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":48,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the defeater of R22 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.","operation":"defeater_propagation","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_propagate_R22","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_propagate_R22\", \"id\": \"d_propagate_R22\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_propagation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the defeater of R22 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.\"}","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:51.831924","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"ba674453f685f66ac895a9c2b9096274eafa1bc7","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":47,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R22 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_remove_R22","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R22\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R22\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R22 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:51.541901","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"231522b7a8edf974aa0fabd22bee127f732b5a0a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":46,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the car is driving and consent from people is not obtained, the system records the people present.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the car is driving and consent from people is not obtained, the system records the people present.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","run_id":"3447fe0a973d4619850c563dfb05b818","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:23:41.531819","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"e85734270a77c4c1b668f38d9206e8d6d84920a9","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":45,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","patch_id":"d_decompose_R_new","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R_new\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R_new\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"original_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","run_id":"3447fe0a973d4619850c563dfb05b818","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:23:38.255530","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"3dd07c8c9fbe7df19f63f52efbec96fa5a7d161f","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":44,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they have not confirmed their readiness to drive, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they have not confirmed their readiness to drive, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","run_id":"4a65aae7f15846e8bff542fff56e0b4b","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:20:59.373727","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"792b8ac6c4b7f5349c52225431bc5f7ad7696096","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":43,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"original_rule\": \"R1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors","run_id":"4a65aae7f15846e8bff542fff56e0b4b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:20:57.151554","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"231522b7a8edf974aa0fabd22bee127f732b5a0a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":42,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that people are recorded when the car is driving and consent has not been obtained, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that people are recorded when the car is driving and consent has not been obtained, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:08.059164","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"da345a71d6f95390f3435308ec8941bc2eca1655","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":41,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_decompose_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R22\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:05.860186","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"9f07f5af46370a643efa1b83ca1db01561b71d5a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":40,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R22","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R22\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R22\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:05.507976","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"d66a60230a8aec2328f2b8951dfbe558be09444d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":39,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R22","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R22\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R22\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:05.193642","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"3dd07c8c9fbe7df19f63f52efbec96fa5a7d161f","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":38,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they are not ready to drive when the system is ready, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they are not ready to drive when the system is ready, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:14:48.813688","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"04f3629ec6c1aa0fd9855796041e2394aee82edf","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":37,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving","patch_id":"d_decompose_R19","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R19\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R19\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:14:46.806598","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"2e8bdf433f5cc5496aba31c481d4a0541807c70f","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":36,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R19","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R19\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R19\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:14:46.497503","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"964e5286f14556cdf83fe397ced064060acc789d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":35,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R19","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R19\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R19\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:14:46.180897","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"04312e4bce695e4e2fdbb816510cfe687e9d49bf","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":34,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, ensuring user awareness before driving.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, ensuring user awareness before driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:14.315561","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"b863f9783f0a66d5f10de32c4d5a85c5ebd82566","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":33,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_decompose_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:12.090395","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"48745d2dae0d137944214c8e5596322a4178e6c4","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":32,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R17","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:11.790743","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"03a286dd90a7efd58279adbc25ff7620efbe9087","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":31,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R17","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:11.482240","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"fb6a84e085e7cd7514999a053a0d8bf492e2b4fb","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":30,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent changing the current driving state when the system is ready but the action is not legal.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent changing the current driving state when the system is ready but the action is not legal.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:37.629394","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"a8cfe54876d726cac5ac6614a84953782fb7d53d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":29,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput","patch_id":"d_decompose_R2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:35.077366","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"ca6a0ea39e275f493fcec3d31605f2463517c35c","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":28,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R2\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:34.764554","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"75732371e4d7b519c2f4d2ca984bd61dc8ef3172","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":27,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R2\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:34.434409","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"04312e4bce695e4e2fdbb816510cfe687e9d49bf","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":26,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, specifically when the door is not closed and the seatbelt is not on.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, specifically when the door is not closed and the seatbelt is not on.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:06:20.061964","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"1c7526e42b42d44370b8a5579a0a1fa3cbbf40b9","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":25,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_decompose_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:06:13.015708","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f9c4e067856867b949dd32fe743c072da83808f2","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":24,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R17","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:06:12.688270","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"07b1d77381692cddc67f0f2416f1cc32fd52428b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":23,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R17","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:06:12.142779","use_case":"AutoCAR"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"61280f2a082da8397fcf1c1bf201e5c755cf7498","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":22,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad action InformKeeper is refined into a more specific action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage to clarify the response to drone damage.","operation":"capability_refinement","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action InformKeeper is refined into a more specific action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage to clarify the response to drone damage.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g3\"}","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:21:33.406864","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"9adbe57ff358959ca266fcb8bd291088566fc241","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":21,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad measure 'damages' is refined into a more specific measure 'structuralDamages' to better distinguish the context of the rule.","operation":"measure_specialization","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"{structuralDamages}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad measure 'damages' is refined into a more specific measure 'structuralDamages' to better distinguish the context of the rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g2\"}","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:21:33.072050","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"4e3cc0f71090a8a79cdc61e5ec151b1b62cabf66","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":20,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event DeployDrone is specialized into DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages to ensure the inform action is only triggered in the context of critical damages.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event DeployDrone is specialized into DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages to ensure the inform action is only triggered in the context of critical damages.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:21:32.785299","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"9e56d22b4dd38d9d282a0d306f426f01be016141","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":19,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","natural_language_explanation":"Remove R14 because it is redundant.","operation":"rule_removal","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"d_remove_R14","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R14\", \"id\": \"d_remove_R14\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R14 because it is redundant.\"}","proposed_rule":"","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:21:27.322999","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"2cfd7fbef4d4c4495bd8c603eae2a3db88543109","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":18,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if a compliance check fails, the system will not ensure compliance, addressing the identified concern.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if a compliance check fails, the system will not ensure compliance, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance","run_id":"cafd58aa8fda4d77ba37f7b3d42b5848","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:28.545605","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"327756dcb1194f60ca5216c2f5c22144a9e7dafc","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":17,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper","patch_id":"d_decompose_R8_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R8_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper","run_id":"cafd58aa8fda4d77ba37f7b3d42b5848","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R8_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:26.731222","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"d50c39824851647a04bc1e8f304d434e58c7c817","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":16,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the carbon footprint is high during drone deployment, the keeper is informed to address potential environmental concerns.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the carbon footprint is high during drone deployment, the keeper is informed to address potential environmental concerns.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper","run_id":"c5d5ab900bc44a22ab2d918c74874edf","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:31.029110","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"327756dcb1194f60ca5216c2f5c22144a9e7dafc","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":15,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper","patch_id":"d_decompose_R8_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R8_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper","run_id":"c5d5ab900bc44a22ab2d918c74874edf","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R8_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:29.127761","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"1f7ed5e71b2e770633b6db8ba17a2a85f3ced737","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":14,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to prevent deploying the drone when the flight condition is dangerous during the preparation phase.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent deploying the drone when the flight condition is dangerous during the preparation phase.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:04.951618","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"b119fdeb2ef1a4d89d0eaa6fa493db44dc58988e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":13,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:01.007238","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"8de63a124994f14192598fed031bbf913232bd9b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":12,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:00.701620","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"11d651ad864866f8404e75756736111e35068b61","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":11,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:00.388384","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"8ef1e17a287f4157ef07f22b0a9df7f65b28029e","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":10,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the drone is deployed and the battery is low, it must not ground the drone within 5 minutes, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.","operation":"new_rule_generation","original_rule":"","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"original_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the drone is deployed and the battery is low, it must not ground the drone within 5 minutes, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:16:59.745923","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"5a4c9dcb047bd7ccaf04e534a8cc95ddd4d215c6","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":9,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.","operation":"rule_decomposition","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_decompose_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R14_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R14_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\"}","proposed_rule":"R14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:16:56.346064","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"6967f9521591b8c39fe4f90b02d9b864287b13cd","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":8,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R14_1\", \"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R14_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\"}","proposed_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:16:56.021374","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"3e54ab0fee9f919b976dfba361ccede81c1131f6","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":7,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","natural_language_explanation":"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.","operation":"trigger_strengthening","original_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R14_1\", \"id\": \"d_strengthen_R14_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\"}","proposed_rule":"R14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:16:55.706443","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":5,"candidate_signature":"08fa492d57a85a6f6a0098ed2a3aec5ebad191b9","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":6,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The broad event PreparingDrone is specialized into PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty to clarify the context in which the drone deployment is restricted.","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event PreparingDrone is specialized into PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty to clarify the context in which the drone deployment is restricted.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"source\": \"llm\", \"id\": \"g1\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"llm","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:36.930297","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"4fdf78ea1cf19ebed85307ad6ee1f1ad69b58c22","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":5,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:30.906695","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"5d2904b4a4748f3f81f4107020ff7491b13c6a3a","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":4,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.","operation":"trigger_refinement","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:30.570770","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"8af0439f46493ee47cf3e1b94668cc3e557da439","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":3,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R7_1 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R7_1\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R7_1 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:30.260241","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"f6b2c6739ae3d53c2e0be547d7b32cadf700319d","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":2,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:29.948008","use_case":"ASPEN"},{"attempt":1,"candidate_signature":"cc423dbfc7379604fae5079c15df29b66311513b","candidate_status":"generated","failure_reason":"","id":1,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","natural_language_explanation":"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.","operation":"defeater_introduction","original_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone","patch_id":"d1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d1\", \"patch_id\": \"d1\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\", \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.\"}","proposed_rule":"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:29.577569","use_case":"ASPEN"}],"experiment_runs":[{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/SafeSCAD/SafeSCAD_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":5.529,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":4,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen UserDriving then ( EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds )\\nwhen EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\\nwhen TrackMetrics then ( (((hearRateVariability = 0) and (eyeMovements = 0)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\\nwhen SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen FindInformation then ( DetermineImportance within 0 seconds )\\nwhen BaselineDiffers then ( ConfirmWithUser within 0 seconds )\\nwhen UserWantsControl then ( (((health and hasLicense) and (not substanceUse)) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserEnters then ( ((commonLanguage and userUnderstands) => ObtainConsentForUserDrive within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserEnters then ( ((not sameCity) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InformUser then ( RemindUser within 600 seconds )\\nwhen InformUser then ( ((not rulesFollowed) => RemindUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( ((objectNearby and (not userNotice)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( TrackVisionField within 0 seconds )\\nwhen TrackVisionField then ( (blindSpot => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserEnters then ( ShowConsentForm within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ShowConsentForm then ( ((not obtainConsent) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingSystem then ( CreateConsentForm within 0 seconds )\\nwhen UserEnters then ( (needsAccomodation => EnsureAccessibility within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingSystem then ( EnsureAlertIndependence within 0 seconds )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( (userImpaired => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserDriving then ( (((not warningSignalOff) and userImpaired) => TakeControlForSafety within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen SystemDriving then ( (((not userGivesControl) and decisionPoint) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffSystem within 0 seconds )\\nwhen SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffMonitoring within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TrackMetrics then ( (((hearRateVariability = 0) and (eyeMovements = 0)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F354', 'F353', 'F352', 'F351', 'F305', 'F304', 'F301', 'F300', 'F299', 'F298', 'F297', 'F296', 'F294', 'F293', 'F288', 'F287', 'F286', 'F285', 'F284', 'F283', 'F282', 'F281', 'F280', 'F203', 'F202', 'F195', 'F194', 'F193', 'F192', 'F191', 'F190', 'F189', 'F188', 'F187', 'F186', 'F185', 'F184', 'F183', 'F182', 'F181', 'F180', 'F179', 'F178', 'F177', 'F176', 'F134', 'F132', 'F127', 'F128', 'F111', 'F109', 'F108', 'F48', 'F3', 'F0', 'F44', 'F53', 'F47', 'F52', 'F49', 'F54', 'F45', 'F8', 'F46']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nTrackMetrics : [694, 706]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [712, 741]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [746, 768]\\nInformUser : [775, 785]\\n{informationImportant} : [1175, 1197]\\nInformUser : [1155, 1165]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F7', 'F52', 'F53', 'F51', 'F44', 'F43', 'F146', 'F215', 'F109', 'F108', 'F45', 'F42', 'F41', 'F46', 'F401', 'F416', 'F426', 'F400', 'F405', 'F419', 'F403', 'F111', 'F420', 'F415', 'F392', 'F398', 'F404', 'F399', 'F396', 'F406', 'F402', 'F393', 'F397', 'F394', 'F395']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nSensorsConnect : [2445, 2459]\\n{properlyPlaced} : [2877, 2893]\\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F26', 'F7', 'F51', 'F50', 'F49', 'F44', 'F43', 'F148', 'F129', 'F125', 'F240', 'F124', 'F242', 'F243', 'F244', 'F108', 'F106', 'F105', 'F247', 'F246', 'F245', 'F248', 'F249', 'F250', 'F266', 'F263', 'F264', 'F265', 'F267', 'F272', 'F271', 'F270', 'F269', 'F251', 'F274', 'F276', 'F277', 'F278', 'F279', 'F281', 'F282', 'F45', 'F284', 'F275', 'F286', 'F42', 'F273', 'F268', 'F305', 'F306', 'F304', 'F300', 'F41', 'F313', 'F314', 'F355', 'F46', 'F356', 'F283', 'F285', 'F287', 'F352', 'F241', 'F351', 'F362']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{properlyPlaced} : [3710, 3726]\\nSystemDriving : [4098, 4111]\\n{decisionPoint} : [4116, 4131]\\n{userGivesControl} : [4158, 4176]\\nUserDriving : [4137, 4148]\\nUserDriving : [3737, 3748]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 13\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F1', 'F2', 'F0', 'F8', 'F39', 'F40', 'F43', 'F139', 'F140', 'F141', 'F144', 'F145', 'F146', 'F147', 'F148', 'F150', 'F152', 'F153', 'F36', 'F35', 'F234', 'F236', 'F239', 'F240', 'F123', 'F118', 'F119', 'F242', 'F243', 'F102', 'F247', 'F245', 'F248', 'F272', 'F271', 'F270', 'F269', 'F274', 'F276', 'F277', 'F278', 'F279', 'F280', 'F281', 'F282', 'F45', 'F284', 'F275', 'F286', 'F288', 'F291', 'F273', 'F235', 'F99', 'F100', 'F401', 'F292', 'F283', 'F285', 'F287', 'F386', 'F388', 'F385', 'F381', 'F241', 'F382', 'F391', 'F383', 'F389', 'F390', 'F379', 'F398', 'F380', 'F361', 'F396', 'F387', 'F384', 'F402', 'F367', 'F3', 'F393', 'F397', 'F394', 'F395']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserDriving : [5593, 5604]\\nEnsureAlertness : [5610, 5625]\\nEnsureAlertness : [5737, 5752]\\nTrackMetrics : [5758, 5770]\\nTrackMetrics : [5392, 5404]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [5410, 5439]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [5444, 5466]\\nInformUser : [5473, 5483]\\nInformUser : [4999, 5009]\\n{informationImportant} : [5019, 5041]\\nchecking when FindInformation then ( DetermineImportance within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when BaselineDiffers then ( ConfirmWithUser within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserWantsControl then ( (((health and hasLicense) and (not substanceUse)) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F11', 'F47', 'F48', 'F20', 'F49', 'F55', 'F56', 'F130', 'F57', 'F160', 'F159', 'F158', 'F111', 'F52', 'F163', 'F131', 'F185', 'F173', 'F164', 'F314', 'F172', 'F171', 'F1056', 'F162', 'F165', 'F161', 'F167', 'F112', 'F114', 'F179', 'F1049', 'F1055', 'F1046', 'F50', 'F135', 'F168', 'F1060', 'F51', 'F1044', 'F175', 'F1054', 'F174', 'F184', 'F1048', 'F1057', 'F1059', 'F1058', 'F178', 'F1045', 'F170', 'F166', 'F177', 'F176', 'F1053', 'F1061', 'F1047', 'F169', 'F1065', 'F1062', 'F1066']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserWantsControl : [6501, 6517]\\n{health} : [6524, 6532]\\n{hasLicense} : [6537, 6549]\\n{substanceUse} : [6560, 6574]\\nUserDriving : [6582, 6593]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nShowConsentForm : [6945, 6960]\\n{obtainConsent} : [6970, 6985]\\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ((commonLanguage and userUnderstands) => ObtainConsentForUserDrive within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ((not sameCity) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 11\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F196', 'F195', 'F8', 'F194', 'F1', 'F3', 'F2', 'F45', 'F42', 'F191', 'F41', 'F198', 'F197', 'F199', 'F192', 'F190', 'F193', 'F49', 'F201', 'F200', 'F46', 'F189', 'F106', 'F130', 'F129', 'F139', 'F137', 'F132', 'F143', 'F144', 'F160', 'F159', 'F158', 'F154', 'F155', 'F105', 'F108', 'F131', 'F250', 'F251', 'F252', 'F253', 'F254', 'F255', 'F256', 'F186', 'F271', 'F185', 'F257', 'F272', 'F280', 'F183', 'F164', 'F246', 'F261', 'F263', 'F259', 'F260', 'F277', 'F278', 'F187', 'F162', 'F245', 'F262', 'F264', 'F267', 'F153', 'F161', 'F268', 'F136', 'F248', 'F167', 'F138', 'F125', 'F188', 'F135', 'F51', 'F249', 'F184', 'F243', 'F141', 'F182', 'F166', 'F244', 'F247', 'F124']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserDriving : [8224, 8235]\\nEnsureAlertness : [8241, 8256]\\nEnsureAlertness : [8744, 8759]\\nTrackMetrics : [8765, 8777]\\nTrackMetrics : [8368, 8380]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [8386, 8415]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [8420, 8442]\\nInformUser : [8449, 8459]\\n{informationImportant} : [8610, 8632]\\nInformUser : [8590, 8600]\\nchecking when InformUser then ( RemindUser within 600 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 4\\nunsat\\nchecking when InformUser then ( ((not rulesFollowed) => RemindUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((objectNearby and (not userNotice)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F384', 'F365', 'F393', 'F245', 'F149', 'F402', 'F385', 'F395', 'F252', 'F398', 'F243', 'F386', 'F238', 'F239', 'F276', 'F397', 'F371', 'F244', 'F0', 'F251', 'F148', 'F151', 'F399', 'F280', 'F394', 'F145', 'F144', 'F143', 'F150', 'F8', 'F401', 'F122', 'F1', 'F2', 'F400', 'F405', 'F275', 'F415', 'F387', 'F410', 'F123', 'F127', 'F246', 'F409', 'F416', 'F282', 'F247', 'F273', 'F418', 'F274', 'F388', 'F392', 'F383', 'F44', 'F249', 'F390', 'F290', 'F51', 'F281', 'F279', 'F240', 'F277', 'F292', 'F46', 'F278', 'F391', 'F406', 'F156', 'F288', 'F389', 'F106', 'F47', 'F289', 'F152', 'F284', 'F291', 'F108', 'F45', 'F285', 'F287', 'F105', 'F3', 'F286', 'F283', 'F50', 'F157', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserDriving : [10283, 10294]\\nEnsureAlertness : [10300, 10315]\\nEnsureAlertness : [10140, 10155]\\nTrackMetrics : [10161, 10173]\\nTrackMetrics : [10427, 10439]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [10445, 10474]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [10479, 10501]\\nInformUser : [10508, 10518]\\nInformUser : [9986, 9996]\\n{informationImportant} : [10006, 10028]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( TrackVisionField within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TrackVisionField then ( (blindSpot => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 11\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F186', 'F189', 'F137', 'F245', 'F272', 'F255', 'F194', 'F252', 'F257', 'F243', 'F264', 'F201', 'F244', 'F261', 'F0', 'F250', 'F251', 'F280', 'F141', 'F144', 'F143', 'F138', 'F8', 'F136', 'F1', 'F130', 'F2', 'F183', 'F256', 'F162', 'F196', 'F195', 'F263', 'F187', 'F135', 'F132', 'F131', 'F129', 'F125', 'F139', 'F124', 'F164', 'F191', 'F268', 'F246', 'F248', 'F155', 'F153', 'F159', 'F158', 'F254', 'F197', 'F167', 'F271', 'F192', 'F259', 'F188', 'F185', 'F184', 'F198', 'F262', 'F166', 'F193', 'F267', 'F247', 'F260', 'F200', 'F249', 'F42', 'F49', 'F51', 'F160', 'F190', 'F182', 'F277', 'F46', 'F199', 'F278', 'F41', 'F106', 'F253', 'F108', 'F45', 'F161', 'F105', 'F3', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserDriving : [12207, 12218]\\nEnsureAlertness : [12224, 12239]\\nEnsureAlertness : [11861, 11876]\\nTrackMetrics : [11882, 11894]\\nTrackMetrics : [12006, 12018]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [12024, 12053]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [12058, 12080]\\nInformUser : [12087, 12097]\\n{informationImportant} : [11727, 11749]\\nInformUser : [11707, 11717]\\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ShowConsentForm within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ShowConsentForm then ( ((not obtainConsent) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 13\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F186', 'F189', 'F333', 'F137', 'F245', 'F149', 'F329', 'F134', 'F356', 'F327', 'F272', 'F351', 'F209', 'F255', 'F320', 'F252', 'F257', 'F318', 'F243', 'F244', 'F261', 'F221', 'F0', 'F250', 'F324', 'F218', 'F251', 'F148', 'F151', 'F146', 'F140', 'F141', 'F145', 'F144', 'F143', 'F142', 'F150', 'F138', 'F8', 'F136', 'F1', 'F130', 'F2', 'F183', 'F256', 'F319', 'F322', 'F332', 'F180', 'F187', 'F133', 'F135', 'F132', 'F131', 'F213', 'F325', 'F129', 'F125', 'F139', 'F124', 'F316', 'F191', 'F268', 'F242', 'F246', 'F248', 'F153', 'F212', 'F158', 'F216', 'F254', 'F192', 'F259', 'F185', 'F184', 'F269', 'F328', 'F326', 'F207', 'F215', 'F247', 'F273', 'F260', 'F258', 'F249', 'F331', 'F220', 'F42', 'F49', 'F179', 'F51', 'F334', 'F335', 'F277', 'F46', 'F346', 'F317', 'F178', 'F41', 'F106', 'F253', 'F26', 'F152', 'F352', 'F108', 'F336', 'F208', 'F323', 'F45', 'F214', 'F345', 'F105', 'F3', 'F321', 'F157', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nSystemDriving : [14063, 14076]\\n{decisionPoint} : [14081, 14096]\\n{userGivesControl} : [14123, 14141]\\nUserDriving : [14102, 14113]\\nUserDriving : [13747, 13758]\\nEnsureAlertness : [13764, 13779]\\nEnsureAlertness : [13604, 13619]\\nTrackMetrics : [13625, 13637]\\nTrackMetrics : [13401, 13413]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [13419, 13448]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [13453, 13475]\\nInformUser : [13482, 13492]\\n{informationImportant} : [13930, 13952]\\nInformUser : [13910, 13920]\\nchecking when PreparingSystem then ( CreateConsentForm within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserEnters then ( (needsAccomodation => EnsureAccessibility within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingSystem then ( EnsureAlertIndependence within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (userImpaired => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F241', 'F237', 'F8', 'F240', 'F42', 'F243', 'F242', 'F146', 'F145', 'F372', 'F153', 'F271', 'F1', 'F105', 'F358', 'F235', 'F246', 'F236', 'F148', 'F244', 'F289', 'F41', 'F124', 'F270', 'F43', 'F154', 'F119', 'F248', 'F249', 'F361', 'F47', 'F351', 'F359', 'F273', 'F278', 'F284', 'F3', 'F368', 'F357', 'F285', 'F353', 'F373', 'F366', 'F362', 'F369', 'F365', 'F120', 'F276', 'F277', 'F281', 'F2', 'F355', 'F142', 'F151', 'F140', 'F44', 'F367', 'F283', 'F274', 'F103', 'F364', 'F282', 'F352', 'F286', 'F360', 'F279', 'F288', 'F407', 'F280', 'F272', 'F354', 'F338', 'F147', 'F102', 'F141', 'F275', 'F350', 'F149', 'F332', 'F48', 'F356', 'F287', 'F406']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nUserDriving : [15303, 15314]\\nEnsureAlertness : [15320, 15335]\\nEnsureAlertness : [15823, 15838]\\nTrackMetrics : [15844, 15856]\\nTrackMetrics : [15447, 15459]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [15465, 15494]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [15499, 15521]\\nInformUser : [15528, 15538]\\nInformUser : [15669, 15679]\\n{informationImportant} : [15689, 15711]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (((not warningSignalOff) and userImpaired) => TakeControlForSafety within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SystemDriving then ( (((not userGivesControl) and decisionPoint) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 13\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F389', 'F169', 'F8', 'F390', 'F177', 'F155', 'F42', 'F129', 'F170', 'F372', 'F168', 'F166', 'F162', 'F161', 'F157', 'F106', 'F255', 'F211', 'F251', 'F371', 'F260', 'F399', 'F291', 'F1', 'F253', 'F105', 'F254', 'F182', 'F225', 'F246', 'F252', 'F289', 'F247', 'F303', 'F108', 'F173', 'F41', 'F49', 'F259', 'F164', 'F124', 'F175', 'F156', 'F224', 'F248', 'F295', 'F375', 'F158', 'F159', 'F163', 'F297', 'F212', 'F213', 'F172', 'F51', 'F219', 'F374', 'F385', 'F46', 'F293', 'F220', 'F3', 'F300', 'F125', 'F26', 'F373', 'F376', 'F381', 'F178', 'F314', 'F317', 'F383', 'F302', 'F216', 'F377', 'F2', 'F378', 'F296', 'F313', 'F165', 'F45', 'F298', 'F305', 'F304', 'F386', 'F294', 'F136', 'F306', 'F380', 'F176', 'F400', 'F288', 'F299', 'F379', 'F292', 'F403', 'F387', 'F318', 'F181', 'F322', 'F217', 'F257', 'F382', 'F290', 'F410', 'F388', 'F174', 'F301', 'F222', 'F404', 'F167', 'F287', 'F370', 'F160', 'F218']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: UserEnters()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nSystemDriving : [16599, 16612]\\n{decisionPoint} : [16617, 16632]\\n{userGivesControl} : [16659, 16677]\\nUserDriving : [16638, 16649]\\nUserDriving : [17171, 17182]\\nEnsureAlertness : [17188, 17203]\\nEnsureAlertness : [17028, 17043]\\nTrackMetrics : [17049, 17061]\\nTrackMetrics : [17315, 17327]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [17333, 17362]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [17367, 17389]\\nInformUser : [17396, 17406]\\n{informationImportant} : [17557, 17579]\\nInformUser : [17537, 17547]\\nchecking when SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffSystem within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffMonitoring within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"], [\"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\"], [\"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\nunless {informationImportant}\", \"R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\", \"R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\", \"R17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\nunless {userGivesControl}\", \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\", \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\", \"R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\", \"R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\", \"R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\", \"R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\", \"R16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[], [], []], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_1\", \"text\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2_1\", \"text\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_2\", \"text\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\nunless {informationImportant}\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3_1\", \"text\": \"R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\nunless {userGivesControl}\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_1\", \"text\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R12_1\", \"text\": \"R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R9\", \"text\": \"R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10\", \"text\": \"R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_1\", \"text\": \"R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16\", \"text\": \"R16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2_1\", \"text\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_1\", \"text\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"score\": 2}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16_1\", \"text\": \"R16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\nunless {warningSignalOff}\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8\", \"text\": \"R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\nthen ObtainConsentForUserDrive\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R9_2\", \"text\": \"R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\", \"score\": 3}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_refinement\", \"defeater_introduction\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed conflict contains contextual predicates that can be propagated into a trigger.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"Two diagnosed conflicting obligations are available for explicit prioritisation.\"}, \"rule_merging\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Rule merging requires the same triggering event and compatible default/specialized contexts.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"At least one diagnosed rule has a triggering event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The conflicting rules do not share a declared environmental measure.\"}}}","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","selected_issue":":\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\n\nFor rule:\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nwhen UserDriving then ( EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds )\nwhen EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\nwhen TrackMetrics then ( (((hearRateVariability = 0) and (eyeMovements = 0)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\nwhen EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\nwhen SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen FindInformation then ( DetermineImportance within 0 seconds )\nwhen BaselineDiffers then ( ConfirmWithUser within 0 seconds )\nwhen UserWantsControl then ( (((health and hasLicense) and (not substanceUse)) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserEnters then ( ((commonLanguage and userUnderstands) => ObtainConsentForUserDrive within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserEnters then ( ((not sameCity) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen InformUser then ( RemindUser within 600 seconds )\nwhen InformUser then ( ((not rulesFollowed) => RemindUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserDriving then ( ((objectNearby and (not userNotice)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserDriving then ( TrackVisionField within 0 seconds )\nwhen TrackVisionField then ( (blindSpot => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserEnters then ( ShowConsentForm within 0 seconds )\nwhen ShowConsentForm then ( ((not obtainConsent) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingSystem then ( CreateConsentForm within 0 seconds )\nwhen UserEnters then ( (needsAccomodation => EnsureAccessibility within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingSystem then ( EnsureAlertIndependence within 0 seconds )\nwhen UserDriving then ( (userImpaired => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserDriving then ( (((not warningSignalOff) and userImpaired) => TakeControlForSafety within 0 seconds) )\nwhen SystemDriving then ( (((not userGivesControl) and decisionPoint) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nwhen SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffSystem within 0 seconds )\nwhen SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffMonitoring within 0 seconds )\nchecking when UserDriving then ( EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TrackMetrics then ( (((hearRateVariability = 0) and (eyeMovements = 0)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 7\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\nmerged\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F354', 'F353', 'F352', 'F351', 'F305', 'F304', 'F301', 'F300', 'F299', 'F298', 'F297', 'F296', 'F294', 'F293', 'F288', 'F287', 'F286', 'F285', 'F284', 'F283', 'F282', 'F281', 'F280', 'F203', 'F202', 'F195', 'F194', 'F193', 'F192', 'F191', 'F190', 'F189', 'F188', 'F187', 'F186', 'F185', 'F184', 'F183', 'F182', 'F181', 'F180', 'F179', 'F178', 'F177', 'F176', 'F134', 'F132', 'F127', 'F128', 'F111', 'F109', 'F108', 'F48', 'F3', 'F0', 'F44', 'F53', 'F47', 'F52', 'F49', 'F54', 'F45', 'F8', 'F46']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\nTrackMetrics : [694, 706]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [712, 741]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [746, 768]\nInformUser : [775, 785]\n{informationImportant} : [1175, 1197]\nInformUser : [1155, 1165]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 8\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F7', 'F52', 'F53', 'F51', 'F44', 'F43', 'F146', 'F215', 'F109', 'F108', 'F45', 'F42', 'F41', 'F46', 'F401', 'F416', 'F426', 'F400', 'F405', 'F419', 'F403', 'F111', 'F420', 'F415', 'F392', 'F398', 'F404', 'F399', 'F396', 'F406', 'F402', 'F393', 'F397', 'F394', 'F395']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\nSensorsConnect : [2445, 2459]\n{properlyPlaced} : [2877, 2893]\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F26', 'F7', 'F51', 'F50', 'F49', 'F44', 'F43', 'F148', 'F129', 'F125', 'F240', 'F124', 'F242', 'F243', 'F244', 'F108', 'F106', 'F105', 'F247', 'F246', 'F245', 'F248', 'F249', 'F250', 'F266', 'F263', 'F264', 'F265', 'F267', 'F272', 'F271', 'F270', 'F269', 'F251', 'F274', 'F276', 'F277', 'F278', 'F279', 'F281', 'F282', 'F45', 'F284', 'F275', 'F286', 'F42', 'F273', 'F268', 'F305', 'F306', 'F304', 'F300', 'F41', 'F313', 'F314', 'F355', 'F46', 'F356', 'F283', 'F285', 'F287', 'F352', 'F241', 'F351', 'F362']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\n{properlyPlaced} : [3710, 3726]\nSystemDriving : [4098, 4111]\n{decisionPoint} : [4116, 4131]\n{userGivesControl} : [4158, 4176]\nUserDriving : [4137, 4148]\nUserDriving : [3737, 3748]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 7\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 13\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F1', 'F2', 'F0', 'F8', 'F39', 'F40', 'F43', 'F139', 'F140', 'F141', 'F144', 'F145', 'F146', 'F147', 'F148', 'F150', 'F152', 'F153', 'F36', 'F35', 'F234', 'F236', 'F239', 'F240', 'F123', 'F118', 'F119', 'F242', 'F243', 'F102', 'F247', 'F245', 'F248', 'F272', 'F271', 'F270', 'F269', 'F274', 'F276', 'F277', 'F278', 'F279', 'F280', 'F281', 'F282', 'F45', 'F284', 'F275', 'F286', 'F288', 'F291', 'F273', 'F235', 'F99', 'F100', 'F401', 'F292', 'F283', 'F285', 'F287', 'F386', 'F388', 'F385', 'F381', 'F241', 'F382', 'F391', 'F383', 'F389', 'F390', 'F379', 'F398', 'F380', 'F361', 'F396', 'F387', 'F384', 'F402', 'F367', 'F3', 'F393', 'F397', 'F394', 'F395']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserDriving : [5593, 5604]\nEnsureAlertness : [5610, 5625]\nEnsureAlertness : [5737, 5752]\nTrackMetrics : [5758, 5770]\nTrackMetrics : [5392, 5404]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [5410, 5439]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [5444, 5466]\nInformUser : [5473, 5483]\nInformUser : [4999, 5009]\n{informationImportant} : [5019, 5041]\nchecking when FindInformation then ( DetermineImportance within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when BaselineDiffers then ( ConfirmWithUser within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserWantsControl then ( (((health and hasLicense) and (not substanceUse)) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 17\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F11', 'F47', 'F48', 'F20', 'F49', 'F55', 'F56', 'F130', 'F57', 'F160', 'F159', 'F158', 'F111', 'F52', 'F163', 'F131', 'F185', 'F173', 'F164', 'F314', 'F172', 'F171', 'F1056', 'F162', 'F165', 'F161', 'F167', 'F112', 'F114', 'F179', 'F1049', 'F1055', 'F1046', 'F50', 'F135', 'F168', 'F1060', 'F51', 'F1044', 'F175', 'F1054', 'F174', 'F184', 'F1048', 'F1057', 'F1059', 'F1058', 'F178', 'F1045', 'F170', 'F166', 'F177', 'F176', 'F1053', 'F1061', 'F1047', 'F169', 'F1065', 'F1062', 'F1066']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserWantsControl : [6501, 6517]\n{health} : [6524, 6532]\n{hasLicense} : [6537, 6549]\n{substanceUse} : [6560, 6574]\nUserDriving : [6582, 6593]\n : [-1, -1]\nShowConsentForm : [6945, 6960]\n{obtainConsent} : [6970, 6985]\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ((commonLanguage and userUnderstands) => ObtainConsentForUserDrive within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ((not sameCity) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\nvol: 8\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 11\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F196', 'F195', 'F8', 'F194', 'F1', 'F3', 'F2', 'F45', 'F42', 'F191', 'F41', 'F198', 'F197', 'F199', 'F192', 'F190', 'F193', 'F49', 'F201', 'F200', 'F46', 'F189', 'F106', 'F130', 'F129', 'F139', 'F137', 'F132', 'F143', 'F144', 'F160', 'F159', 'F158', 'F154', 'F155', 'F105', 'F108', 'F131', 'F250', 'F251', 'F252', 'F253', 'F254', 'F255', 'F256', 'F186', 'F271', 'F185', 'F257', 'F272', 'F280', 'F183', 'F164', 'F246', 'F261', 'F263', 'F259', 'F260', 'F277', 'F278', 'F187', 'F162', 'F245', 'F262', 'F264', 'F267', 'F153', 'F161', 'F268', 'F136', 'F248', 'F167', 'F138', 'F125', 'F188', 'F135', 'F51', 'F249', 'F184', 'F243', 'F141', 'F182', 'F166', 'F244', 'F247', 'F124']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserDriving : [8224, 8235]\nEnsureAlertness : [8241, 8256]\nEnsureAlertness : [8744, 8759]\nTrackMetrics : [8765, 8777]\nTrackMetrics : [8368, 8380]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [8386, 8415]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [8420, 8442]\nInformUser : [8449, 8459]\n{informationImportant} : [8610, 8632]\nInformUser : [8590, 8600]\nchecking when InformUser then ( RemindUser within 600 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 4\nunsat\nchecking when InformUser then ( ((not rulesFollowed) => RemindUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((objectNearby and (not userNotice)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F384', 'F365', 'F393', 'F245', 'F149', 'F402', 'F385', 'F395', 'F252', 'F398', 'F243', 'F386', 'F238', 'F239', 'F276', 'F397', 'F371', 'F244', 'F0', 'F251', 'F148', 'F151', 'F399', 'F280', 'F394', 'F145', 'F144', 'F143', 'F150', 'F8', 'F401', 'F122', 'F1', 'F2', 'F400', 'F405', 'F275', 'F415', 'F387', 'F410', 'F123', 'F127', 'F246', 'F409', 'F416', 'F282', 'F247', 'F273', 'F418', 'F274', 'F388', 'F392', 'F383', 'F44', 'F249', 'F390', 'F290', 'F51', 'F281', 'F279', 'F240', 'F277', 'F292', 'F46', 'F278', 'F391', 'F406', 'F156', 'F288', 'F389', 'F106', 'F47', 'F289', 'F152', 'F284', 'F291', 'F108', 'F45', 'F285', 'F287', 'F105', 'F3', 'F286', 'F283', 'F50', 'F157', 'F154']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserDriving : [10283, 10294]\nEnsureAlertness : [10300, 10315]\nEnsureAlertness : [10140, 10155]\nTrackMetrics : [10161, 10173]\nTrackMetrics : [10427, 10439]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [10445, 10474]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [10479, 10501]\nInformUser : [10508, 10518]\nInformUser : [9986, 9996]\n{informationImportant} : [10006, 10028]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( TrackVisionField within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TrackVisionField then ( (blindSpot => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 11\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F186', 'F189', 'F137', 'F245', 'F272', 'F255', 'F194', 'F252', 'F257', 'F243', 'F264', 'F201', 'F244', 'F261', 'F0', 'F250', 'F251', 'F280', 'F141', 'F144', 'F143', 'F138', 'F8', 'F136', 'F1', 'F130', 'F2', 'F183', 'F256', 'F162', 'F196', 'F195', 'F263', 'F187', 'F135', 'F132', 'F131', 'F129', 'F125', 'F139', 'F124', 'F164', 'F191', 'F268', 'F246', 'F248', 'F155', 'F153', 'F159', 'F158', 'F254', 'F197', 'F167', 'F271', 'F192', 'F259', 'F188', 'F185', 'F184', 'F198', 'F262', 'F166', 'F193', 'F267', 'F247', 'F260', 'F200', 'F249', 'F42', 'F49', 'F51', 'F160', 'F190', 'F182', 'F277', 'F46', 'F199', 'F278', 'F41', 'F106', 'F253', 'F108', 'F45', 'F161', 'F105', 'F3', 'F154']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\n\nFor rule:\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserDriving : [12207, 12218]\nEnsureAlertness : [12224, 12239]\nEnsureAlertness : [11861, 11876]\nTrackMetrics : [11882, 11894]\nTrackMetrics : [12006, 12018]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [12024, 12053]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [12058, 12080]\nInformUser : [12087, 12097]\n{informationImportant} : [11727, 11749]\nInformUser : [11707, 11717]\nchecking when UserEnters then ( ShowConsentForm within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ShowConsentForm then ( ((not obtainConsent) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 13\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F186', 'F189', 'F333', 'F137', 'F245', 'F149', 'F329', 'F134', 'F356', 'F327', 'F272', 'F351', 'F209', 'F255', 'F320', 'F252', 'F257', 'F318', 'F243', 'F244', 'F261', 'F221', 'F0', 'F250', 'F324', 'F218', 'F251', 'F148', 'F151', 'F146', 'F140', 'F141', 'F145', 'F144', 'F143', 'F142', 'F150', 'F138', 'F8', 'F136', 'F1', 'F130', 'F2', 'F183', 'F256', 'F319', 'F322', 'F332', 'F180', 'F187', 'F133', 'F135', 'F132', 'F131', 'F213', 'F325', 'F129', 'F125', 'F139', 'F124', 'F316', 'F191', 'F268', 'F242', 'F246', 'F248', 'F153', 'F212', 'F158', 'F216', 'F254', 'F192', 'F259', 'F185', 'F184', 'F269', 'F328', 'F326', 'F207', 'F215', 'F247', 'F273', 'F260', 'F258', 'F249', 'F331', 'F220', 'F42', 'F49', 'F179', 'F51', 'F334', 'F335', 'F277', 'F46', 'F346', 'F317', 'F178', 'F41', 'F106', 'F253', 'F26', 'F152', 'F352', 'F108', 'F336', 'F208', 'F323', 'F45', 'F214', 'F345', 'F105', 'F3', 'F321', 'F157', 'F154']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\n\nFor rule:\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nSystemDriving : [14063, 14076]\n{decisionPoint} : [14081, 14096]\n{userGivesControl} : [14123, 14141]\nUserDriving : [14102, 14113]\nUserDriving : [13747, 13758]\nEnsureAlertness : [13764, 13779]\nEnsureAlertness : [13604, 13619]\nTrackMetrics : [13625, 13637]\nTrackMetrics : [13401, 13413]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [13419, 13448]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [13453, 13475]\nInformUser : [13482, 13492]\n{informationImportant} : [13930, 13952]\nInformUser : [13910, 13920]\nchecking when PreparingSystem then ( CreateConsentForm within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserEnters then ( (needsAccomodation => EnsureAccessibility within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingSystem then ( EnsureAlertIndependence within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (userImpaired => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F241', 'F237', 'F8', 'F240', 'F42', 'F243', 'F242', 'F146', 'F145', 'F372', 'F153', 'F271', 'F1', 'F105', 'F358', 'F235', 'F246', 'F236', 'F148', 'F244', 'F289', 'F41', 'F124', 'F270', 'F43', 'F154', 'F119', 'F248', 'F249', 'F361', 'F47', 'F351', 'F359', 'F273', 'F278', 'F284', 'F3', 'F368', 'F357', 'F285', 'F353', 'F373', 'F366', 'F362', 'F369', 'F365', 'F120', 'F276', 'F277', 'F281', 'F2', 'F355', 'F142', 'F151', 'F140', 'F44', 'F367', 'F283', 'F274', 'F103', 'F364', 'F282', 'F352', 'F286', 'F360', 'F279', 'F288', 'F407', 'F280', 'F272', 'F354', 'F338', 'F147', 'F102', 'F141', 'F275', 'F350', 'F149', 'F332', 'F48', 'F356', 'F287', 'F406']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\n\nFor rule:\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nUserDriving : [15303, 15314]\nEnsureAlertness : [15320, 15335]\nEnsureAlertness : [15823, 15838]\nTrackMetrics : [15844, 15856]\nTrackMetrics : [15447, 15459]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [15465, 15494]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [15499, 15521]\nInformUser : [15528, 15538]\nInformUser : [15669, 15679]\n{informationImportant} : [15689, 15711]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (((not warningSignalOff) and userImpaired) => TakeControlForSafety within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SystemDriving then ( (((not userGivesControl) and decisionPoint) => UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 13\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F389', 'F169', 'F8', 'F390', 'F177', 'F155', 'F42', 'F129', 'F170', 'F372', 'F168', 'F166', 'F162', 'F161', 'F157', 'F106', 'F255', 'F211', 'F251', 'F371', 'F260', 'F399', 'F291', 'F1', 'F253', 'F105', 'F254', 'F182', 'F225', 'F246', 'F252', 'F289', 'F247', 'F303', 'F108', 'F173', 'F41', 'F49', 'F259', 'F164', 'F124', 'F175', 'F156', 'F224', 'F248', 'F295', 'F375', 'F158', 'F159', 'F163', 'F297', 'F212', 'F213', 'F172', 'F51', 'F219', 'F374', 'F385', 'F46', 'F293', 'F220', 'F3', 'F300', 'F125', 'F26', 'F373', 'F376', 'F381', 'F178', 'F314', 'F317', 'F383', 'F302', 'F216', 'F377', 'F2', 'F378', 'F296', 'F313', 'F165', 'F45', 'F298', 'F305', 'F304', 'F386', 'F294', 'F136', 'F306', 'F380', 'F176', 'F400', 'F288', 'F299', 'F379', 'F292', 'F403', 'F387', 'F318', 'F181', 'F322', 'F217', 'F257', 'F382', 'F290', 'F410', 'F388', 'F174', 'F301', 'F222', 'F404', 'F167', 'F287', 'F370', 'F160', 'F218']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: SensorsConnect()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserWantsControl()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: UserEnters()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\nat time 1: ShowConsentForm()\n\nFor rule:\nR9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackVisionField()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\n\nFor rule:\nR11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SystemDriving()\nat time 0: ShowConsentForm()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 0: blocked_UserDriving(end=0)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nSystemDriving : [16599, 16612]\n{decisionPoint} : [16617, 16632]\n{userGivesControl} : [16659, 16677]\nUserDriving : [16638, 16649]\nUserDriving : [17171, 17182]\nEnsureAlertness : [17188, 17203]\nEnsureAlertness : [17028, 17043]\nTrackMetrics : [17049, 17061]\nTrackMetrics : [17315, 17327]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [17333, 17362]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [17367, 17389]\nInformUser : [17396, 17406]\n{informationImportant} : [17557, 17579]\nInformUser : [17537, 17547]\nchecking when SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffSystem within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SystemOn then ( UserCanTurnOffMonitoring within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:23.709298","total_time_seconds":11.867,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","validation_time_seconds":3.255,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.633,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","selected_issue":"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:22.648863","total_time_seconds":30.268,"use_case":"ALMI","validation_time_seconds":26.684,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/ALMI/ALMI_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.258,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","selected_issue":"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:25.595370","total_time_seconds":33.408,"use_case":"ALMI","validation_time_seconds":30.213,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/ALMI/ALMI_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":4.27,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":3,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\nConcern is raised\", \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen MonitorMealTime then ( (userOccupied => RemindLater within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MonitorMealTime then ( ((not userOccupied) => InformUser within 600 seconds) )\\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\\nwhen TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => InformCaregiver within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => GiveSuggestion within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen HumanOnFloor then ( ((not humanAssents) => not_CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen HumanOnFloor then ( ((not (not humanAssents)) => CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InterfereSafely then ( (((not userOccupied) and (not safePathFound)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserWantsToCook then ( AllowUserToCook within 0 seconds )\\nwhen AllowUserToCook then ( ((hazardDetected or (riskLevel = 2)) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserHasLimitation then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nwhen UserWantsToCook then ( CheckTemperature within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckTemperature then ( (hazardDetected => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen FoodPreparation then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\\nwhen TrackTime then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( CollectandRecordInformation within 0 seconds )\\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( UpdateInformation within 0 seconds )\\nwhen GiveSuggestion then ( ConsiderUserPractices within 0 seconds )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( AskForEmergencyContact within 0 seconds )\\nwhen AskForEmergencyContact then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( ((not personAuthorized) => not_ShowDataHistory within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ShowDataHistory then ( (dataNeedsChecking => ProvideDataSummaries within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserUnpredictable then ( not_GiveUserDangerousObjects within 0 seconds )\\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( (((not (needLevel > 1)) and (not userAsksForAppropriateTasks)) => RemindUserOfLimitations within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingDeployment then ( ((not userNeedsSpecialAccomodations) => AgentHasAppropriateAppearance within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingDeployment then ( CalibrateSpeech within 0 seconds )\\nwhen GivingCookingInstructions then ( UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage within 0 seconds )\\nwhen GivingCookingInstructions then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nwhen BeforeCookingBegins then ( AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions within 0 seconds )\\nwhen UserChangeMind then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => RecalculateApproach within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((riskLevel = 2) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => UpdateMap within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts)) => FireSafetyMeasures within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((not (userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts))) => CallEmergencyServices within 300 seconds) )\\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( OpenWindows within 0 seconds )\\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( AskUserIfOK within 0 seconds )\\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( InformCaregiver within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when MonitorMealTime then ( (userOccupied => RemindLater within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MonitorMealTime then ( ((not userOccupied) => InformUser within 600 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 4\\nunsat\\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => InformCaregiver within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => GiveSuggestion within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when HumanOnFloor then ( ((not humanAssents) => not_CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 10\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F255', 'F0', 'F5', 'F254', 'F51', 'F52', 'F252', 'F60', 'F50', 'F45', 'F43', 'F42', 'F40', 'F253', 'F181', 'F280', 'F210', 'F257', 'F175', 'F262', 'F205', 'F183', 'F281', 'F202', 'F194', 'F258', 'F41', 'F284', 'F275', 'F171', 'F209', 'F260', 'F259', 'F169', 'F192', 'F285', 'F193', 'F180', 'F200', 'F185', 'F153', 'F188', 'F133', 'F261', 'F277', 'F30', 'F132', 'F170', 'F176', 'F311', 'F174', 'F186', 'F256', 'F191', 'F263', 'F135', 'F71', 'F179', 'F44', 'F189', 'F184', 'F154', 'F160', 'F199', 'F195', 'F279', 'F203', 'F208', 'F187', 'F178', 'F197', 'F201', 'F190', 'F278', 'F207', 'F312', 'F177', 'F230', 'F182', 'F264']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nSmokeDetectorAlarm : [1379, 1397]\\n{userDisablesAlarm} : [1455, 1474]\\n{alarmRestarts} : [1484, 1499]\\nFireSafetyMeasures : [1507, 1525]\\n{userDisablesAlarm} : [1455, 1474]\\n{alarmRestarts} : [1484, 1499]\\nCallEmergencyServices : [1403, 1424]\\n5 minutes : [1432, 1441]\\nCallEmergencyServices : [1008, 1029]\\nHumanOnFloor : [927, 939]\\n{humanAssents} : [983, 997]\\nchecking when HumanOnFloor then ( ((not (not humanAssents)) => CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when InterfereSafely then ( (((not userOccupied) and (not safePathFound)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserWantsToCook then ( AllowUserToCook within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AllowUserToCook then ( ((hazardDetected or (riskLevel = 2)) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserHasLimitation then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserWantsToCook then ( CheckTemperature within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckTemperature then ( (hazardDetected => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when FoodPreparation then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TrackTime then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( CollectandRecordInformation within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( UpdateInformation within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when GiveSuggestion then ( ConsiderUserPractices within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( AskForEmergencyContact within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AskForEmergencyContact then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( ((not personAuthorized) => not_ShowDataHistory within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ShowDataHistory then ( (dataNeedsChecking => ProvideDataSummaries within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserUnpredictable then ( not_GiveUserDangerousObjects within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( (((not (needLevel > 1)) and (not userAsksForAppropriateTasks)) => RemindUserOfLimitations within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDeployment then ( ((not userNeedsSpecialAccomodations) => AgentHasAppropriateAppearance within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDeployment then ( CalibrateSpeech within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when GivingCookingInstructions then ( UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when GivingCookingInstructions then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when BeforeCookingBegins then ( AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserChangeMind then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => RecalculateApproach within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((riskLevel = 2) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => UpdateMap within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts)) => FireSafetyMeasures within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((not (userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts))) => CallEmergencyServices within 300 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 4\\nunsat\\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( OpenWindows within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( AskUserIfOK within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( InformCaregiver within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"R19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\nunless ({riskLevel} = high)\", \"R20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\nunless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\", \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\"], [\"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\nunless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\nunless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c4\", \"text\": \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R21\", \"text\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\nunless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\nunless ({riskLevel} = high)\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R20\", \"text\": \"R20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\nunless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R5_1\", \"text\": \"R5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\nthen InterfereSafely\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\nunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R21\", \"text\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\nunless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\nunless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\nunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\nunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R20\", \"text\": \"R20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\nunless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\nunless {userOccupied}\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R5_1\", \"text\": \"R5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\nthen InterfereSafely\", \"score\": 4}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_refinement\", \"defeater_introduction\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed conflict contains contextual predicates that can be propagated into a trigger.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"Two diagnosed conflicting obligations are available for explicit prioritisation.\"}, \"rule_merging\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Rule merging requires the same triggering event and compatible default/specialized contexts.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"At least one diagnosed rule has a triggering event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The conflicting rules do not share a declared environmental measure.\"}}}","run_id":"0a92f3ec48534d308efebcfeef837ee7","selected_issue":":\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\n\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nwhen MonitorMealTime then ( (userOccupied => RemindLater within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MonitorMealTime then ( ((not userOccupied) => InformUser within 600 seconds) )\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\nwhen TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => InformCaregiver within 0 seconds) )\nwhen TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => GiveSuggestion within 0 seconds) )\nwhen HumanOnFloor then ( ((not humanAssents) => not_CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\nwhen HumanOnFloor then ( ((not (not humanAssents)) => CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\nwhen InterfereSafely then ( (((not userOccupied) and (not safePathFound)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserWantsToCook then ( AllowUserToCook within 0 seconds )\nwhen AllowUserToCook then ( ((hazardDetected or (riskLevel = 2)) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserHasLimitation then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nwhen UserWantsToCook then ( CheckTemperature within 0 seconds )\nwhen CheckTemperature then ( (hazardDetected => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nwhen FoodPreparation then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\nwhen TrackTime then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( CollectandRecordInformation within 0 seconds )\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( UpdateInformation within 0 seconds )\nwhen GiveSuggestion then ( ConsiderUserPractices within 0 seconds )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( AskForEmergencyContact within 0 seconds )\nwhen AskForEmergencyContact then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( ((not personAuthorized) => not_ShowDataHistory within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ShowDataHistory then ( (dataNeedsChecking => ProvideDataSummaries within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserUnpredictable then ( not_GiveUserDangerousObjects within 0 seconds )\nwhen AgentDeployed then ( (((not (needLevel > 1)) and (not userAsksForAppropriateTasks)) => RemindUserOfLimitations within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingDeployment then ( ((not userNeedsSpecialAccomodations) => AgentHasAppropriateAppearance within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingDeployment then ( CalibrateSpeech within 0 seconds )\nwhen GivingCookingInstructions then ( UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage within 0 seconds )\nwhen GivingCookingInstructions then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nwhen BeforeCookingBegins then ( AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions within 0 seconds )\nwhen UserChangeMind then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => RecalculateApproach within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((riskLevel = 2) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => UpdateMap within 0 seconds) )\nwhen SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts)) => FireSafetyMeasures within 0 seconds) )\nwhen SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((not (userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts))) => CallEmergencyServices within 300 seconds) )\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( OpenWindows within 0 seconds )\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( AskUserIfOK within 0 seconds )\nwhen FireSafetyMeasures then ( InformCaregiver within 0 seconds )\nchecking when MonitorMealTime then ( (userOccupied => RemindLater within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MonitorMealTime then ( ((not userOccupied) => InformUser within 600 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 4\nunsat\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => InformCaregiver within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TrackTime then ( ((timeBetweenMeals > 28800) => GiveSuggestion within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when HumanOnFloor then ( ((not humanAssents) => not_CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 10\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F255', 'F0', 'F5', 'F254', 'F51', 'F52', 'F252', 'F60', 'F50', 'F45', 'F43', 'F42', 'F40', 'F253', 'F181', 'F280', 'F210', 'F257', 'F175', 'F262', 'F205', 'F183', 'F281', 'F202', 'F194', 'F258', 'F41', 'F284', 'F275', 'F171', 'F209', 'F260', 'F259', 'F169', 'F192', 'F285', 'F193', 'F180', 'F200', 'F185', 'F153', 'F188', 'F133', 'F261', 'F277', 'F30', 'F132', 'F170', 'F176', 'F311', 'F174', 'F186', 'F256', 'F191', 'F263', 'F135', 'F71', 'F179', 'F44', 'F189', 'F184', 'F154', 'F160', 'F199', 'F195', 'F279', 'F203', 'F208', 'F187', 'F178', 'F197', 'F201', 'F190', 'F278', 'F207', 'F312', 'F177', 'F230', 'F182', 'F264']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm()\nat time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nmedium, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=medium, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: HumanOnFloor()\nat time 300: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=0, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDisablesAlarm=False, alarmRestarts=False, needLevel=nlow, humanAssents=False, safePathFound=False, hazardDetected=False, kitchenSafe=False, riskLevel=low, alarmOn=False)\nat time 300: blocked_not_CallEmergencyServices(end=300)\nat time 301: CallEmergencyServices()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\n\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nSmokeDetectorAlarm : [1379, 1397]\n{userDisablesAlarm} : [1455, 1474]\n{alarmRestarts} : [1484, 1499]\nFireSafetyMeasures : [1507, 1525]\n{userDisablesAlarm} : [1455, 1474]\n{alarmRestarts} : [1484, 1499]\nCallEmergencyServices : [1403, 1424]\n5 minutes : [1432, 1441]\nCallEmergencyServices : [1008, 1029]\nHumanOnFloor : [927, 939]\n{humanAssents} : [983, 997]\nchecking when HumanOnFloor then ( ((not (not humanAssents)) => CallEmergencyServices within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 5\nunsat\nchecking when InterfereSafely then ( (((not userOccupied) and (not safePathFound)) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserWantsToCook then ( AllowUserToCook within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AllowUserToCook then ( ((hazardDetected or (riskLevel = 2)) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserHasLimitation then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserWantsToCook then ( CheckTemperature within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when CheckTemperature then ( (hazardDetected => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when FoodPreparation then ( TrackTime within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TrackTime then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( CollectandRecordInformation within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( UpdateInformation within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when GiveSuggestion then ( ConsiderUserPractices within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( AskForEmergencyContact within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AskForEmergencyContact then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( ((not personAuthorized) => not_ShowDataHistory within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ShowDataHistory then ( (dataNeedsChecking => ProvideDataSummaries within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserUnpredictable then ( not_GiveUserDangerousObjects within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AgentDeployed then ( (((not (needLevel > 1)) and (not userAsksForAppropriateTasks)) => RemindUserOfLimitations within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDeployment then ( ((not userNeedsSpecialAccomodations) => AgentHasAppropriateAppearance within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDeployment then ( CalibrateSpeech within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when GivingCookingInstructions then ( UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when GivingCookingInstructions then ( InformUser within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when BeforeCookingBegins then ( AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserChangeMind then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => RecalculateApproach within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((riskLevel = 2) => InterfereSafely within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserChangeItemLocation then ( ((not (riskLevel = 2)) => UpdateMap within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts)) => FireSafetyMeasures within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SmokeDetectorAlarm then ( ((not (userDisablesAlarm and (not alarmRestarts))) => CallEmergencyServices within 300 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 4\nunsat\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( OpenWindows within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( AskUserIfOK within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when FireSafetyMeasures then ( InformCaregiver within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:09.027471","total_time_seconds":8.63,"use_case":"ALMI","validation_time_seconds":1.988,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/DPA/DPA_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.174,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","selected_issue":"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:07.756079","total_time_seconds":56.987,"use_case":"DPA","validation_time_seconds":52.733,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/DPA/DPA_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.108,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"c2c3980ce3d84f9ab8bde3b97db67f07","selected_issue":"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:45.951988","total_time_seconds":5.586,"use_case":"DPA","validation_time_seconds":3.133,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/DPA/DPA_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.018,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":3,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\nConcern is raised\", \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\nunless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"R19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\", \"R20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\"], [\"R11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\", \"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"R8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\"], [\"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\nunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\nor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\nthen InformController\", \"R12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\nthen not StartDPAProcess\", \"R13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c4\", \"text\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c9\", \"text\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\nunless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R20\", \"text\": \"R20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11\", \"text\": \"R11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8\", \"text\": \"R8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R21\", \"text\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\nunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\nor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\nthen InformController\", \"score\": 10}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R12\", \"text\": \"R12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\nthen not StartDPAProcess\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R5\", \"text\": \"R5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\nunless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R6\", \"text\": \"R6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","selected_issue":"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:05.734040","total_time_seconds":11.495,"use_case":"DPA","validation_time_seconds":7.223,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":4.66,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"5351a92f4ace4a08ba536395bf2fc613","selected_issue":"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:28.839815","total_time_seconds":6.285,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":1.624,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.946,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","selected_issue":"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:35.879002","total_time_seconds":8.24,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":3.932,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.038,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","selected_issue":"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:45.650850","total_time_seconds":6.579,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":3.488,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.167,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"61c953b0907f42aca4b7215eefaab2cf","selected_issue":"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:57:58.933810","total_time_seconds":4.015,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":0.846,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.172,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"3998ac49d8cc45449b40bf5cbf6bc50b","selected_issue":"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:55:58.956334","total_time_seconds":4.818,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":2.325,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.011,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","selected_issue":"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:31.912841","total_time_seconds":6.338,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":3.34,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.216,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","selected_issue":"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:35.869708","total_time_seconds":6.519,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":3.189,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.126,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","selected_issue":"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:27.851097","total_time_seconds":6.379,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":3.244,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/CSICobot/CSICobot_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":4.336,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":10,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\nConcern is raised\", \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\nConcern is raised\", \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\"], [\"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\"], [\"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\"], [\"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\"], [\"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\", \"R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\"], [\"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\"], [\"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\", \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\"], [\"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\"], [\"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c4\", \"text\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c7\", \"text\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[], [], []], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4b\", \"text\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13_1\", \"text\": \"R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R15\", \"text\": \"R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R6\", \"text\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R6\", \"text\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R15_1\", \"text\": \"R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R5\", \"text\": \"R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R6\", \"text\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nunless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R6\", \"text\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\nunless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\nunless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10_1\", \"text\": \"R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4b\", \"text\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10_1\", \"text\": \"R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\", \"score\": 2}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","selected_issue":"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:53.510901","total_time_seconds":10.988,"use_case":"CSICobot","validation_time_seconds":2.941,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/BSN/BSN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.006,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"378926ca6cbc4213ac762d3a8d5af6a8","selected_issue":"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:44.433461","total_time_seconds":5.553,"use_case":"BSN","validation_time_seconds":3.232,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/BSN/BSN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":1.888,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"9fd4efae1b7540b9a93c350f12f82d9a","selected_issue":"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:17.715272","total_time_seconds":4.908,"use_case":"BSN","validation_time_seconds":2.7,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/BSN/BSN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":1.978,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":3,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\nConcern is raised\", \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\nConcern is raised\", \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\nor ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\nunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"Rule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\notherwise CallCaregiver\\nunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\", \"Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\nand {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\"], [\"Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\nunless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\", \"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\"], [\"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\nthen not RemoveSensors\", \"Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"C2\", \"text\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"C8\", \"text\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"C9\", \"text\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\nor ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\nunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\notherwise CallCaregiver\\nunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\nand {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\nunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\nunless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule15\", \"text\": \"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13_1\", \"text\": \"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\nthen not RemoveSensors\", \"score\": 8}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13_2\", \"text\": \"Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","selected_issue":"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:05.873639","total_time_seconds":6.811,"use_case":"BSN","validation_time_seconds":4.203,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/SafeSCAD/SafeSCAD_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.966,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","selected_issue":"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:37.488618","total_time_seconds":6.3,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","validation_time_seconds":2.019,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/SafeSCAD/SafeSCAD_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":6.572,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"measure_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule uses declared measure(s): fullAttentionNeeded\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","selected_issue":"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:47.326416","total_time_seconds":28.196,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","validation_time_seconds":21.31,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/SafeSCAD/SafeSCAD_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.777,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","selected_issue":"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:38.133585","total_time_seconds":6.023,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","validation_time_seconds":1.936,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/SafeSCAD/SafeSCAD_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.093,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":4,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nTrackMetrics : [695, 707]\\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [713, 742]\\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [747, 769]\\nInformUser : [776, 786]\\n{informationImportant} : [1176, 1198]\\nInformUser : [1156, 1166]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 13\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F436', 'F109', 'F462', 'F426', 'F433', 'F427', 'F108', 'F437', 'F53', 'F450', 'F425', 'F7', 'F438', 'F430', 'F111', 'F51', 'F42', 'F428', 'F41', 'F429', 'F453', 'F424', 'F449', 'F454', 'F431', 'F435', 'F432', 'F434', 'F44', 'F215', 'F45', 'F43', 'F46', 'F52', 'F146']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nSensorsConnect : [2450, 2464]\\n{properlyPlaced} : [2882, 2898]\\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=1)\\nat time 2: UserDriving()\\nvol: 6\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 15\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F278', 'F247', 'F381', 'F242', 'F250', 'F109', 'F246', 'F11', 'F388', 'F389', 'F398', 'F455', 'F108', 'F53', 'F450', 'F243', 'F391', 'F394', 'F7', 'F239', 'F251', 'F245', 'F465', 'F111', 'F51', 'F382', 'F384', 'F42', 'F237', 'F252', 'F249', 'F163', 'F253', 'F129', 'F236', 'F41', 'F390', 'F385', 'F397', 'F254', 'F380', 'F387', 'F241', 'F238', 'F393', 'F454', 'F235', 'F130', 'F392', 'F44', 'F255', 'F45', 'F43', 'F451', 'F244', 'F256', 'F248', 'F46', 'F136', 'F386', 'F240', 'F52', 'F383']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: UserDriving()\\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\\nat time 1: InformUser()\\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: UserDriving()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\\nat time 2: InformUser()\\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\\nat time 1: UserWantsControl()\\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\\nat time 1: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=1)\\nat time 2: UserDriving()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nUserWantsControl : [4533, 4549]\\n{health} : [4556, 4564]\\n{hasLicense} : [4569, 4581]\\n{substanceUse} : [4592, 4606]\\nUserDriving : [4614, 4625]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{properlyPlaced} : [4146, 4162]\\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"], [\"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\"], [\"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\nunless {informationImportant}\", \"R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\", \"R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\", \"R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[], [], []], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_1\", \"text\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2_1\", \"text\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_2\", \"text\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\nunless {informationImportant}\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3\", \"text\": \"R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R3_1\", \"text\": \"R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2_1\", \"text\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\", \"score\": 2}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1_1\", \"text\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"score\": 2}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10\", \"text\": \"R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_1\", \"text\": \"R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16\", \"text\": \"R16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16_1\", \"text\": \"R16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\nunless {warningSignalOff}\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\nunless {userGivesControl}\", \"score\": 3}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_refinement\", \"defeater_introduction\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed conflict contains contextual predicates that can be propagated into a trigger.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"Two diagnosed conflicting obligations are available for explicit prioritisation.\"}, \"rule_merging\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Rule merging requires the same triggering event and compatible default/specialized contexts.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"At least one diagnosed rule has a triggering event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The conflicting rules do not share a declared environmental measure.\"}}}","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","selected_issue":":\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\nTrackMetrics : [695, 707]\n({hearRateVariability} = low) : [713, 742]\n({eyeMovements} = low) : [747, 769]\nInformUser : [776, 786]\n{informationImportant} : [1176, 1198]\nInformUser : [1156, 1166]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( (fullAttentionNeeded => EnsureAlertness within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EnsureAlertness then ( TrackMetrics within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\nvol: 8\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 13\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F436', 'F109', 'F462', 'F426', 'F433', 'F427', 'F108', 'F437', 'F53', 'F450', 'F425', 'F7', 'F438', 'F430', 'F111', 'F51', 'F42', 'F428', 'F41', 'F429', 'F453', 'F424', 'F449', 'F454', 'F431', 'F435', 'F432', 'F434', 'F44', 'F215', 'F45', 'F43', 'F46', 'F52', 'F146']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\nSensorsConnect : [2450, 2464]\n{properlyPlaced} : [2882, 2898]\nchecking when SensorsConnect then ( ((not properlyPlaced) => not_UserDriving within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: UserWantsControl()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=1)\nat time 2: UserDriving()\nvol: 6\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\nmerged\ndomain size 15\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F0', 'F278', 'F247', 'F381', 'F242', 'F250', 'F109', 'F246', 'F11', 'F388', 'F389', 'F398', 'F455', 'F108', 'F53', 'F450', 'F243', 'F391', 'F394', 'F7', 'F239', 'F251', 'F245', 'F465', 'F111', 'F51', 'F382', 'F384', 'F42', 'F237', 'F252', 'F249', 'F163', 'F253', 'F129', 'F236', 'F41', 'F390', 'F385', 'F397', 'F254', 'F380', 'F387', 'F241', 'F238', 'F393', 'F454', 'F235', 'F130', 'F392', 'F44', 'F255', 'F45', 'F43', 'F451', 'F244', 'F256', 'F248', 'F46', 'F136', 'F386', 'F240', 'F52', 'F383']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: UserDriving()\nat time 0: TrackMetrics()\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 0: blocked_InformUser(end=0)\nat time 1: InformUser()\nat time 1: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 1: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=True, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=False, userNotice=True, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: UserDriving()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=True, userNotice=False, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: blocked_InformUser(end=1)\nat time 2: InformUser()\nat time 2: EnsureAlertness()\nat time 2: TrackVisionField()\n\nFor rule:\nR3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=medium, eyeMovements=medium1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=True, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=False, substanceUse=True, commonLanguage=False, userUnderstands=False, sameCity=False, rulesFollowed=False, objectNearby=False, userNotice=False, blindSpot=False, obtainConsent=False, needsAccomodation=False, userImpaired=True, warningSignalOff=False, userGivesControl=False, decisionPoint=False)\nat time 1: UserWantsControl()\nat time 1: SensorsConnect()\nat time 1: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=True, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=True, health=True, hasLicense=True, substanceUse=False, commonLanguage=True, userUnderstands=True, sameCity=True, rulesFollowed=True, objectNearby=True, userNotice=True, blindSpot=True, obtainConsent=True, needsAccomodation=True, userImpaired=False, warningSignalOff=True, userGivesControl=True, decisionPoint=True)\nat time 1: blocked_not_UserDriving(end=1)\nat time 2: UserDriving()\n\nFor rule:\nR3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\nUserWantsControl : [4533, 4549]\n{health} : [4556, 4564]\n{hasLicense} : [4569, 4581]\n{substanceUse} : [4592, 4606]\nUserDriving : [4614, 4625]\n : [-1, -1]\n{properlyPlaced} : [4146, 4162]\nchecking when UserDriving then ( ((not informationImportant) => not_InformUser within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:02.323323","total_time_seconds":4.79,"use_case":"SafeSCAD","validation_time_seconds":2.049,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/DressAssist/DressAssist_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.024,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":1,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop\\nunless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\nunless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\\nunless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\nunless {consentGranted}\\nunless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\nunless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\", \"Rule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\nunless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\\nunless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\nunless {consentGranted}\\nunless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\nunless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop\\nunless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule7\", \"text\": \"Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\nunless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\\nunless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\nunless {consentGranted}\\nunless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\nunless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule7_1\", \"text\": \"Rule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\nunless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\\nunless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\nunless {consentGranted}\\nunless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\nunless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","selected_issue":"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:55.735541","total_time_seconds":7.637,"use_case":"DressAssist","validation_time_seconds":4.591,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":1,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":6.714,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"measure_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule uses declared measure(s): dataRelevantToContext, dataUnnecessary\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","selected_issue":"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:03.594782","total_time_seconds":89.728,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":82.66,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.891,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","selected_issue":"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:06.132603","total_time_seconds":30.3,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":27.359,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.71,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","selected_issue":"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:05.780240","total_time_seconds":29.623,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":26.872,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.319,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","selected_issue":"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:06.113107","total_time_seconds":30.291,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":26.972,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.37,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"3fb3f9ec8e39483590c049be0cee107c","selected_issue":"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:04.496560","total_time_seconds":29.422,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":27.009,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.842,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":7,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F649', 'F48', 'F390', 'F593', 'F578', 'F577', 'F595', 'F397', 'F594', 'F591', 'F583', 'F581', 'F574', 'F579', 'F392', 'F407', 'F385', 'F401', 'F655', 'F164', 'F52', 'F162', 'F596', 'F49', 'F402', 'F136', 'F389', 'F388', 'F158', 'F387', 'F400', 'F592', 'F394', 'F391', 'F395', 'F386', 'F157', 'F0', 'F46', 'F47', 'F220', 'F587', 'F384', 'F408', 'F383', 'F597', 'F393', 'F23', 'F573', 'F399', 'F626', 'F396', 'F582', 'F576', 'F139', 'F648', 'F54', 'F580', 'F137', 'F398', 'F650', 'F22', 'F43', 'F588', 'F654', 'F575', 'F42', 'F55']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1103, 1123]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1129, 1149]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1154, 1176]\\nExaminingPatient : [1183, 1199]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1568, 1586]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1656, 1674]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1623, 1645]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F450', 'F445', 'F458', 'F456', 'F449', 'F448', 'F452', 'F462', 'F155', 'F45', 'F733', 'F712', 'F133', 'F711', 'F457', 'F455', 'F710', 'F713', 'F705', 'F706', 'F447', 'F716', 'F719', 'F461', 'F703', 'F721', 'F454', 'F52', 'F732', 'F49', 'F136', 'F465', 'F553', 'F0', 'F134', 'F46', 'F453', 'F443', 'F725', 'F176', 'F723', 'F51', 'F264', 'F39', 'F44', 'F23', 'F459', 'F707', 'F466', 'F451', 'F709', 'F704', 'F720', 'F446', 'F724', 'F708', 'F159', 'F701', 'F22', 'F715', 'F460', 'F43', 'F444', 'F40', 'F714', 'F702', 'F722', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3358, 3378]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3384, 3404]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3438, 3454]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2899, 2917]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2987, 3005]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2954, 2976]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule20\", \"text\": \"Rule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","selected_issue":"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:52.908568","total_time_seconds":102.589,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":99.794,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":2,"generated_file_path":"results/DAISY/DAISY_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.185,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":7,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 20\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F1066', 'F1067', 'F1068', 'F1039', 'F22', 'F0', 'F52', 'F43', 'F261', 'F42', 'F46', 'F23', 'F47', 'F50', 'F764', 'F768', 'F756', 'F761', 'F759', 'F816', 'F830', 'F485', 'F769', 'F820', 'F755', 'F757', 'F460', 'F471', 'F465', 'F459', 'F772', 'F475', 'F464', 'F760', 'F132', 'F466', 'F133', 'F476', 'F777', 'F776', 'F774', 'F152', 'F173', 'F461', 'F469', 'F775', 'F484', 'F467', 'F462', 'F135', 'F819', 'F778', 'F474', 'F156', 'F477', 'F151', 'F470', 'F758', 'F472', 'F468', 'F815', 'F773', 'F473', 'F754', 'F763', 'F463', 'F762']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1088, 1108]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1113, 1135]\\nExaminingPatient : [1142, 1158]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1527, 1545]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1615, 1633]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1582, 1604]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F40', 'F22', 'F0', 'F43', 'F39', 'F23', 'F44', 'F47', 'F49', 'F705', 'F756', 'F659', 'F677', 'F668', 'F757', 'F680', 'F460', 'F471', 'F465', 'F459', 'F663', 'F710', 'F661', 'F709', 'F669', 'F464', 'F132', 'F658', 'F676', 'F670', 'F466', 'F456', 'F458', 'F170', 'F457', 'F148', 'F461', 'F469', 'F679', 'F130', 'F665', 'F657', 'F467', 'F462', 'F153', 'F474', 'F129', 'F470', 'F258', 'F706', 'F149', 'F472', 'F546', 'F674', 'F468', 'F667', 'F664', 'F666', 'F675', 'F656', 'F473', 'F660', 'F463', 'F678', 'F671', 'F716', 'F662']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3300, 3320]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3325, 3347]\\nExaminingPatient : [3354, 3370]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2824, 2842]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2912, 2930]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2879, 2901]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_refinement\", \"defeater_introduction\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed conflict contains contextual predicates that can be propagated into a trigger.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"Two diagnosed conflicting obligations are available for explicit prioritisation.\"}, \"rule_merging\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Rule merging requires the same triggering event and compatible default/specialized contexts.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"At least one diagnosed rule has a triggering event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The conflicting rules do not share a declared environmental measure.\"}}}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","selected_issue":":\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\n\nFor rule:\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\n\nFor rule:\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 5\nunsat\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\nvol: 7\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\nmerged\nmerged\nmerged\ndomain size 20\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F1066', 'F1067', 'F1068', 'F1039', 'F22', 'F0', 'F52', 'F43', 'F261', 'F42', 'F46', 'F23', 'F47', 'F50', 'F764', 'F768', 'F756', 'F761', 'F759', 'F816', 'F830', 'F485', 'F769', 'F820', 'F755', 'F757', 'F460', 'F471', 'F465', 'F459', 'F772', 'F475', 'F464', 'F760', 'F132', 'F466', 'F133', 'F476', 'F777', 'F776', 'F774', 'F152', 'F173', 'F461', 'F469', 'F775', 'F484', 'F467', 'F462', 'F135', 'F819', 'F778', 'F474', 'F156', 'F477', 'F151', 'F470', 'F758', 'F472', 'F468', 'F815', 'F773', 'F473', 'F754', 'F763', 'F463', 'F762']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\n\nFor rule:\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\n{patientComfortable} : [1088, 1108]\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1113, 1135]\nExaminingPatient : [1142, 1158]\n{patientXReligion} : [1527, 1545]\n{medicalEmergency} : [1615, 1633]\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1582, 1604]\n : [-1, -1]\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\nvol: 7\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\nmerged\nmerged\nmerged\ndomain size 17\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F40', 'F22', 'F0', 'F43', 'F39', 'F23', 'F44', 'F47', 'F49', 'F705', 'F756', 'F659', 'F677', 'F668', 'F757', 'F680', 'F460', 'F471', 'F465', 'F459', 'F663', 'F710', 'F661', 'F709', 'F669', 'F464', 'F132', 'F658', 'F676', 'F670', 'F466', 'F456', 'F458', 'F170', 'F457', 'F148', 'F461', 'F469', 'F679', 'F130', 'F665', 'F657', 'F467', 'F462', 'F153', 'F474', 'F129', 'F470', 'F258', 'F706', 'F149', 'F472', 'F546', 'F674', 'F468', 'F667', 'F664', 'F666', 'F675', 'F656', 'F473', 'F660', 'F463', 'F678', 'F671', 'F716', 'F662']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=10, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\n\nFor rule:\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\nat time 1: ExamineState()\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\n\nFor rule:\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\n : [-1, -1]\n{patientComfortable} : [3300, 3320]\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3325, 3347]\nExaminingPatient : [3354, 3370]\n : [-1, -1]\n{patientXReligion} : [2824, 2842]\n{medicalEmergency} : [2912, 2930]\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2879, 2901]\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:11.776719","total_time_seconds":130.146,"use_case":"DAISY","validation_time_seconds":126.035,"verified_patch_count":5},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/AutoCAR/AutoCAR_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":4.251,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\", \"defeater_propagation\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule contains a defeater that can be propagated into its trigger.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","selected_issue":"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:40.211710","total_time_seconds":32.805,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":27.924,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/AutoCAR/AutoCAR_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":4.163,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\", \"defeater_propagation\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule contains a defeater that can be propagated into its trigger.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Measure specialization requires an environmental measure in the redundant rule.\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","selected_issue":"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:24.119896","total_time_seconds":28.591,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":23.799,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/AutoCAR/AutoCAR_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":1.779,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"3447fe0a973d4619850c563dfb05b818","selected_issue":"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:20.527406","total_time_seconds":40.4,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":38.239,"verified_patch_count":2},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":1,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.168,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"4a65aae7f15846e8bff542fff56e0b4b","selected_issue":"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:21:38.731654","total_time_seconds":40.717,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":38.115,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.068,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","selected_issue":"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:27.522513","total_time_seconds":21.422,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":18.312,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.859,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","selected_issue":"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:27.249298","total_time_seconds":39.946,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":37.087,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.068,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","selected_issue":"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:53.422587","total_time_seconds":40.909,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":37.84,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":3,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":2.41,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","selected_issue":"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:56.705618","total_time_seconds":21.409,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":17.961,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/AutoCAR/AutoCAR_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.889,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":9,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nConcern is raised\", \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nConcern is raised\", \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\nConcern is raised\", \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\"], [\"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"R20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\"], [\"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\"], [\"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\", \"R16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\"], [\"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\"], [\"R1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"R10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\", \"R26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually\"], [\"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"R4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\nunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\nunless (not {actionIsLegal})\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\"], [\"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c4\", \"text\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c10\", \"text\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c12\", \"text\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[], []], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\"}], [{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R23\", \"text\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R15\", \"text\": \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16_cont\", \"text\": \"R16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R20\", \"text\": \"R20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R21\", \"text\": \"R21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\nunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\nunless (not {actionIsLegal})\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R2\", \"text\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R20\", \"text\": \"R20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R15\", \"text\": \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16_cont\", \"text\": \"R16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R17\", \"text\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\nthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7\", \"text\": \"R7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R23\", \"text\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R15\", \"text\": \"R15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\nunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R16_cont\", \"text\": \"R16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R19\", \"text\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10_1\", \"text\": \"R10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R26\", \"text\": \"R26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R23\", \"text\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\nunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\nunless (not {actionIsLegal})\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R23\", \"text\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 9}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R22\", \"text\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\nunless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"score\": 9}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","selected_issue":"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:00.378039","total_time_seconds":43.505,"use_case":"AutoCAR","validation_time_seconds":39.328,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":1,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":6.058,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"rule_removal\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\", \"measure_specialization\", \"capability_refinement\"], \"applicability\": {\"rule_removal\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed redundant rule can be removed.\"}, \"defeater_propagation\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Defeater propagation requires an existing defeater.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a trigger event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule uses declared measure(s): damages\"}, \"capability_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The redundant rule has a response that can be replaced by a more distinguishable capability.\"}}}","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","selected_issue":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:39.377094","total_time_seconds":69.089,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":62.655,"verified_patch_count":3},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":1,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.761,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"cafd58aa8fda4d77ba37f7b3d42b5848","selected_issue":"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:49.985139","total_time_seconds":22.518,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":20.369,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":1,"generated_file_path":"","generation_time_seconds":1.861,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"c5d5ab900bc44a22ab2d918c74874edf","selected_issue":"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:50.437871","total_time_seconds":20.503,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":18.278,"verified_patch_count":1},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/ASPEN/ASPEN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":2.109,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","selected_issue":"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:27.930311","total_time_seconds":23.552,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":20.509,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/ASPEN/ASPEN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":1.816,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":0,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_strengthening\", \"defeater_introduction\", \"rule_decomposition\"], \"llm\": [\"new_rule_generation\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_strengthening\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern provides contextual conditions that can strengthen a related rule.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The witness concern can be converted into an explicit exception on a related rule.\"}, \"rule_decomposition\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"A related rule can be split into context-specific branches using the witness concern.\"}, \"new_rule_generation\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"An insufficiency represents missing normative behaviour; a new rule is a candidate semantic repair.\"}}}","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","selected_issue":"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\nConcern is raised","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:23.388939","total_time_seconds":23.116,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":20.333,"verified_patch_count":4},{"attempts":5,"failed_patch_count":0,"generated_file_path":"results/ASPEN/ASPEN_SLEECPATCH.sleec","generation_time_seconds":3.447,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","max_attempts":5,"original_issue_count":6,"original_structured_json":"{\"concerns\": [\"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\nConcern is raised\", \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nConcern is raised\", \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen EncounterHuman then ( ((sameLanguage and humanUnderstands) => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EncounterHuman then ( IdentifyActivity within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyActivity then ( (unrelatedActivity => not_StoreData within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen HumanNearby then ( (environmentDangerous => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( ((onIndigenousLand and landTreatyInPlace) => DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( (((not landTreatyInPlace) and onIndigenousLand) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (relevantLand => MonitorLand within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen CollectSample then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( UpdateTerritories within 0 seconds )\\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( (privateTerritory => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (privateTerritory => ExitArea within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( MonitorCarbon within 0 seconds )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((carbonFootprint > 0) and (benefits < 1)) => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen TakePictures then ( ((humanIdentified and unrelatedActivity) => DeletePictures within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen TakePictures then ( (((not unrelatedActivity) and humanIdentified) => AnonymizeHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ImplementASPEN then ( EnsureCompliance within 0 seconds )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((flightCondition < 2) and (flightCondition = 0)) => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((not (flightCondition = 0)) and (flightCondition < 2)) => ReturnHome within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ReturnHome then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\\nwhen GroundDrone then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => ExitArea within 60 seconds) )\\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeInteractswithDrone) and wildlifeDisturbed) => BackUp within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeDisturbed) and (not wildlifeInteractswithDrone)) => AvoidInterference within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( ((((battery = 0) or (store = 0)) or damages) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (damages => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (damages => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nchecking when EncounterHuman then ( ((sameLanguage and humanUnderstands) => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EncounterHuman then ( IdentifyActivity within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyActivity then ( (unrelatedActivity => not_StoreData within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when HumanNearby then ( (environmentDangerous => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( ((onIndigenousLand and landTreatyInPlace) => DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F398', 'F37', 'F40', 'F36', 'F409', 'F182', 'F410', 'F420', 'F46', 'F399', 'F400', 'F408', 'F162', 'F401', 'F123', 'F405', 'F397', 'F403', 'F0', 'F166', 'F154', 'F5', 'F99', 'F165', 'F423', 'F155', 'F186', 'F175', 'F178', 'F180', 'F185', 'F206', 'F406', 'F419', 'F130', 'F10', 'F181', 'F213', 'F164', 'F44', 'F404', 'F163', 'F161', 'F159', 'F119', 'F167', 'F118', 'F430', 'F407', 'F156', 'F177', 'F179', 'F424', 'F102', 'F157', 'F100', 'F41', 'F160', 'F158', 'F168', 'F402']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nPreparingDrone : [590, 604]\\n{onIndigenousLand} : [609, 627]\\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [660, 679]\\nDeployDrone : [685, 696]\\nDeployDrone : [637, 648]\\n{privateTerritory} : [1066, 1084]\\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( (((not landTreatyInPlace) and onIndigenousLand) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (relevantLand => MonitorLand within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectSample then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( UpdateTerritories within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( (privateTerritory => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 10\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F37', 'F364', 'F363', 'F40', 'F359', 'F361', 'F36', 'F182', 'F379', 'F356', 'F46', 'F162', 'F123', 'F355', 'F358', 'F0', 'F366', 'F166', 'F378', 'F154', 'F5', 'F99', 'F165', 'F155', 'F186', 'F362', 'F175', 'F178', 'F180', 'F185', 'F354', 'F206', 'F130', 'F10', 'F375', 'F181', 'F213', 'F164', 'F357', 'F44', 'F163', 'F161', 'F159', 'F360', 'F119', 'F167', 'F374', 'F118', 'F156', 'F177', 'F179', 'F102', 'F367', 'F157', 'F100', 'F41', 'F160', 'F158', 'F383', 'F365', 'F168']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nPreparingDrone : [2219, 2233]\\n{onIndigenousLand} : [2238, 2256]\\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [2289, 2308]\\nDeployDrone : [2314, 2325]\\nDeployDrone : [2266, 2277]\\n{privateTerritory} : [1831, 1849]\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (privateTerritory => ExitArea within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( MonitorCarbon within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((carbonFootprint > 0) and (benefits < 1)) => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TakePictures then ( ((humanIdentified and unrelatedActivity) => DeletePictures within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when TakePictures then ( (((not unrelatedActivity) and humanIdentified) => AnonymizeHuman within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ImplementASPEN then ( EnsureCompliance within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((flightCondition < 2) and (flightCondition = 0)) => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((not (flightCondition = 0)) and (flightCondition < 2)) => ReturnHome within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ReturnHome then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when GroundDrone then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => ExitArea within 60 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 4\\nunsat\\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeInteractswithDrone) and wildlifeDisturbed) => BackUp within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeDisturbed) and (not wildlifeInteractswithDrone)) => AvoidInterference within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( ((((battery = 0) or (store = 0)) or damages) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\nvol: 5\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 12\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F10', 'F5', 'F104', 'F44', 'F41', 'F40', 'F48', 'F50', 'F123', 'F179', 'F182', 'F183', 'F184', 'F185', 'F186', 'F127', 'F164', 'F162', 'F166', 'F165', 'F172', 'F159', 'F217', 'F161', 'F163', 'F168', 'F169', 'F160', 'F167', 'F45', 'F171', 'F190', 'F106', 'F403', 'F405', 'F406', 'F407', 'F409', 'F410', 'F411', 'F412', 'F413', 'F414', 'F423', 'F424', 'F122', 'F427', 'F428', 'F434', 'F134', 'F189', 'F401', 'F408', 'F404', 'F103', 'F210', 'F402', 'F170', 'F0', 'F181', 'F158']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nR13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\nPreparingDrone : [3465, 3479]\\n{onIndigenousLand} : [3484, 3502]\\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [3535, 3554]\\nDeployDrone : [3560, 3571]\\nDeployDrone : [3512, 3523]\\n{privateTerritory} : [3702, 3720]\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (damages => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (damages => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\", \"R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\nunless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\", \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\"], [\"R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\nunless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\", \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\", \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\nunless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\"], [\"R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\", \"R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\", \"R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\"], [\"R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\", \"R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\", \"R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\nunless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c4\", \"text\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c7\", \"text\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c8\", \"text\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\nunless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7_1\", \"text\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11\", \"text\": \"R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\nunless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14_1\", \"text\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8_1\", \"text\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\nthen InformKeeper\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_cont_1\", \"text\": \"R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11\", \"text\": \"R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\nunless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R4\", \"text\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\nunless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R7_1\", \"text\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_cont\", \"text\": \"R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_cont_1\", \"text\": \"R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R12_1\", \"text\": \"R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8_1\", \"text\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\nthen InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R10\", \"text\": \"R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_cont\", \"text\": \"R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11_cont_1\", \"text\": \"R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R12_1\", \"text\": \"R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14\", \"text\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R13\", \"text\": \"R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\nthen not DeployDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R14_1\", \"text\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8_1\", \"text\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\nthen InformKeeper\", \"score\": 2}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R12\", \"text\": \"R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\nunless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\nunless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\", \"score\": 6}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R11\", \"text\": \"R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\nunless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R8_1\", \"text\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\nthen InformKeeper\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R9\", \"text\": \"R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\nunless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"R1\", \"text\": \"R1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\nthen InformHuman\", \"score\": 4}]]}}","repair_operators_json":"{\"deterministic\": [\"trigger_refinement\", \"defeater_introduction\"], \"llm\": [\"event_specialization\"], \"applicability\": {\"trigger_refinement\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"The diagnosed conflict contains contextual predicates that can be propagated into a trigger.\"}, \"defeater_introduction\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"Two diagnosed conflicting obligations are available for explicit prioritisation.\"}, \"rule_merging\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"Rule merging requires the same triggering event and compatible default/specialized contexts.\"}, \"event_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": true, \"reason\": \"At least one diagnosed rule has a triggering event that can be semantically specialized.\"}, \"measure_specialization\": {\"is_applicable\": false, \"reason\": \"The conflicting rules do not share a declared environmental measure.\"}}}","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","selected_issue":":\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nwhen EncounterHuman then ( ((sameLanguage and humanUnderstands) => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\nwhen EncounterHuman then ( IdentifyActivity within 0 seconds )\nwhen IdentifyActivity then ( (unrelatedActivity => not_StoreData within 0 seconds) )\nwhen HumanNearby then ( (environmentDangerous => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( ((onIndigenousLand and landTreatyInPlace) => DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( (((not landTreatyInPlace) and onIndigenousLand) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (relevantLand => MonitorLand within 0 seconds) )\nwhen CollectSample then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( UpdateTerritories within 0 seconds )\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( (privateTerritory => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (privateTerritory => ExitArea within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( MonitorCarbon within 0 seconds )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((carbonFootprint > 0) and (benefits < 1)) => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nwhen TakePictures then ( ((humanIdentified and unrelatedActivity) => DeletePictures within 0 seconds) )\nwhen TakePictures then ( (((not unrelatedActivity) and humanIdentified) => AnonymizeHuman within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ImplementASPEN then ( EnsureCompliance within 0 seconds )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((flightCondition < 2) and (flightCondition = 0)) => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (((not (flightCondition = 0)) and (flightCondition < 2)) => ReturnHome within 0 seconds) )\nwhen ReturnHome then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\nwhen GroundDrone then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => ExitArea within 60 seconds) )\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeInteractswithDrone) and wildlifeDisturbed) => BackUp within 0 seconds) )\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeDisturbed) and (not wildlifeInteractswithDrone)) => AvoidInterference within 0 seconds) )\nwhen EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nwhen PreparingDrone then ( ((((battery = 0) or (store = 0)) or damages) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (damages => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nwhen DeployDrone then ( (damages => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\nchecking when EncounterHuman then ( ((sameLanguage and humanUnderstands) => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EncounterHuman then ( IdentifyActivity within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when IdentifyActivity then ( (unrelatedActivity => not_StoreData within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when HumanNearby then ( (environmentDangerous => InformHuman within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( ((onIndigenousLand and landTreatyInPlace) => DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F398', 'F37', 'F40', 'F36', 'F409', 'F182', 'F410', 'F420', 'F46', 'F399', 'F400', 'F408', 'F162', 'F401', 'F123', 'F405', 'F397', 'F403', 'F0', 'F166', 'F154', 'F5', 'F99', 'F165', 'F423', 'F155', 'F186', 'F175', 'F178', 'F180', 'F185', 'F206', 'F406', 'F419', 'F130', 'F10', 'F181', 'F213', 'F164', 'F44', 'F404', 'F163', 'F161', 'F159', 'F119', 'F167', 'F118', 'F430', 'F407', 'F156', 'F177', 'F179', 'F424', 'F102', 'F157', 'F100', 'F41', 'F160', 'F158', 'F168', 'F402']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nPreparingDrone : [590, 604]\n{onIndigenousLand} : [609, 627]\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [660, 679]\nDeployDrone : [685, 696]\nDeployDrone : [637, 648]\n{privateTerritory} : [1066, 1084]\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( (((not landTreatyInPlace) and onIndigenousLand) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 5\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (relevantLand => MonitorLand within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when CollectSample then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( AvoidInterference within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( UpdateTerritories within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( (privateTerritory => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 10\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F37', 'F364', 'F363', 'F40', 'F359', 'F361', 'F36', 'F182', 'F379', 'F356', 'F46', 'F162', 'F123', 'F355', 'F358', 'F0', 'F366', 'F166', 'F378', 'F154', 'F5', 'F99', 'F165', 'F155', 'F186', 'F362', 'F175', 'F178', 'F180', 'F185', 'F354', 'F206', 'F130', 'F10', 'F375', 'F181', 'F213', 'F164', 'F357', 'F44', 'F163', 'F161', 'F159', 'F360', 'F119', 'F167', 'F374', 'F118', 'F156', 'F177', 'F179', 'F102', 'F367', 'F157', 'F100', 'F41', 'F160', 'F158', 'F383', 'F365', 'F168']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nPreparingDrone : [2219, 2233]\n{onIndigenousLand} : [2238, 2256]\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [2289, 2308]\nDeployDrone : [2314, 2325]\nDeployDrone : [2266, 2277]\n{privateTerritory} : [1831, 1849]\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (privateTerritory => ExitArea within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( MonitorCarbon within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((carbonFootprint > 0) and (benefits < 1)) => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TakePictures then ( ((humanIdentified and unrelatedActivity) => DeletePictures within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when TakePictures then ( (((not unrelatedActivity) and humanIdentified) => AnonymizeHuman within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ImplementASPEN then ( EnsureCompliance within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((flightCondition < 2) and (flightCondition = 0)) => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (((not (flightCondition = 0)) and (flightCondition < 2)) => ReturnHome within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when ReturnHome then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when GroundDrone then ( InformKeeper within 0 seconds )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => ExitArea within 60 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 4\nunsat\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeInteractswithDrone) and wildlifeDisturbed) => BackUp within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (((not wildlifeDisturbed) and (not wildlifeInteractswithDrone)) => AvoidInterference within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when EncounterWildlife then ( (wildlifeInteractswithDrone => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when PreparingDrone then ( ((((battery = 0) or (store = 0)) or damages) => not_DeployDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nfind trace\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\nvol: 5\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\nmerged\ndomain size 12\nunsat\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\n['F10', 'F5', 'F104', 'F44', 'F41', 'F40', 'F48', 'F50', 'F123', 'F179', 'F182', 'F183', 'F184', 'F185', 'F186', 'F127', 'F164', 'F162', 'F166', 'F165', 'F172', 'F159', 'F217', 'F161', 'F163', 'F168', 'F169', 'F160', 'F167', 'F45', 'F171', 'F190', 'F106', 'F403', 'F405', 'F406', 'F407', 'F409', 'F410', 'F411', 'F412', 'F413', 'F414', 'F423', 'F424', 'F122', 'F427', 'F428', 'F434', 'F134', 'F189', 'F401', 'F408', 'F404', 'F103', 'F210', 'F402', 'F170', 'F0', 'F181', 'F158']\nConflict detected, start backward checking\nUNSAT CORE\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=False, humanUnderstands=False, unrelatedActivity=False, environmentDangerous=False, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=False, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=False, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=dangerous, wildlifeDisturbed=False, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=False, unKnownObject=False, damages=False, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nSituational conflict under situation :\nat time 0: PreparingDrone()\nat time 0: UpdateTerritories()\nat time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True, relevantLand=True, privateTerritory=True, humanIdentified=True, carbonFootprint=low, benefits=low1, flightCondition=unsafe, wildlifeDisturbed=True, wildlifeInteractswithDrone=True, unKnownObject=False, damages=True, battery=medium2, store=medium3)\nat time 0: blocked_not_DeployDrone(end=0)\nat time 1: DeployDrone()\n\nFor rule:\nR13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\nPreparingDrone : [3465, 3479]\n{onIndigenousLand} : [3484, 3502]\n{landTreatyInPlace} : [3535, 3554]\nDeployDrone : [3560, 3571]\nDeployDrone : [3512, 3523]\n{privateTerritory} : [3702, 3720]\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (damages => InformKeeper within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat\nchecking when DeployDrone then ( (damages => GroundDrone within 0 seconds) )\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\ndomain size 3\nunsat","successful":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:47.272670","total_time_seconds":9.935,"use_case":"ASPEN","validation_time_seconds":4.244,"verified_patch_count":6}],"experiment_verifications":[{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":156,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\n\\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 50.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 60.0, \"interpretability\": 50.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The introduction of an additional 'unless' clause creates ambiguity regarding the conditions under which 'InformUser' is suppressed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 70.75}, \"ranking_score\": 70.75, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 60.0, \"interpretability\": 50.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The introduction of an additional 'unless' clause creates ambiguity regarding the conditions under which 'InformUser' is suppressed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the modification.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 70.75}","ranking_score":70.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:24.886723","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":155,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R1_2\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R1_2 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The introduction of '{informationImportant}' adds a condition that is not clearly defined in the context of existing rules, potentially leading to ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 76.25}, \"ranking_score\": 76.25, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The introduction of '{informationImportant}' adds a condition that is not clearly defined in the context of existing rules, potentially leading to ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change does not sufficiently explain how the new condition interacts with existing rules, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 76.25}","ranking_score":76.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:24.510707","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.","id":154,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_event\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_measure\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_capability\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_rule\": \"R1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to address the specific context of distraction while driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"UserDrivingWithDistraction\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): UserDrivingWithDistraction\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"at\", \"backward\", \"baselinediffers\", \"bcr\", \"be\", \"because\", \"blindspot\", \"blocked_informuser\", \"blocked_not_informuser\", \"blocked_not_userdriving\", \"blocked_userdriving\", \"checking\", \"commonlanguage\", \"config\", \"confirmwithuser\", \"conflict\", \"core\", \"createconsentform\", \"decisionpoint\", \"detect\", \"detected\", \"determineimportance\", \"domain\", \"end\", \"ensureaccessibility\", \"ensurealertindependence\", \"eyemovements\", \"f0\", \"f1\", \"f100\", \"f102\", \"f103\", \"f1044\", \"f1045\", \"f1046\", \"f1047\", \"f1048\", \"f1049\", \"f105\", \"f1053\", \"f1054\", \"f1055\", \"f1056\", \"f1057\", \"f1058\", \"f1059\", \"f106\", \"f1060\", \"f1061\", \"f1062\", \"f1065\", \"f1066\", \"f108\", \"f109\", \"f11\", \"f111\", \"f112\", \"f114\", \"f118\", \"f119\", \"f120\", \"f122\", \"f123\", \"f124\", \"f125\", \"f127\", \"f128\", \"f129\", \"f130\", \"f131\", \"f132\", \"f133\", \"f134\", \"f135\", \"f136\", \"f137\", \"f138\", \"f139\", \"f140\", \"f141\", \"f142\", \"f143\", \"f144\", \"f145\", \"f146\", \"f147\", \"f148\", \"f149\", \"f150\", \"f151\", \"f152\", \"f153\", \"f154\", \"f155\", \"f156\", \"f157\", \"f158\", \"f159\", \"f160\", \"f161\", \"f162\", \"f163\", \"f164\", \"f165\", \"f166\", \"f167\", \"f168\", \"f169\", \"f170\", \"f171\", \"f172\", \"f173\", \"f174\", \"f175\", \"f176\", \"f177\", \"f178\", \"f179\", \"f180\", \"f181\", \"f182\", \"f183\", \"f184\", \"f185\", \"f186\", \"f187\", \"f188\", \"f189\", \"f190\", \"f191\", \"f192\", \"f193\", \"f194\", \"f195\", \"f196\", \"f197\", \"f198\", \"f199\", \"f2\", \"f20\", \"f200\", \"f201\", \"f202\", \"f203\", \"f207\", \"f208\", \"f209\", \"f211\", \"f212\", \"f213\", \"f214\", \"f215\", \"f216\", \"f217\", \"f218\", \"f219\", \"f220\", \"f221\", \"f222\", \"f224\", \"f225\", \"f234\", \"f235\", \"f236\", \"f237\", \"f238\", \"f239\", \"f240\", \"f241\", \"f242\", \"f243\", \"f244\", \"f245\", \"f246\", \"f247\", \"f248\", \"f249\", \"f250\", \"f251\", \"f252\", \"f253\", \"f254\", \"f255\", \"f256\", \"f257\", \"f258\", \"f259\", \"f26\", \"f260\", \"f261\", \"f262\", \"f263\", \"f264\", \"f265\", \"f266\", \"f267\", \"f268\", \"f269\", \"f270\", \"f271\", \"f272\", \"f273\", \"f274\", \"f275\", \"f276\", \"f277\", \"f278\", \"f279\", \"f280\", \"f281\", \"f282\", \"f283\", \"f284\", \"f285\", \"f286\", \"f287\", \"f288\", \"f289\", \"f290\", \"f291\", \"f292\", \"f293\", \"f294\", \"f295\", \"f296\", \"f297\", \"f298\", \"f299\", \"f3\", \"f300\", \"f301\", \"f302\", \"f303\", \"f304\", \"f305\", \"f306\", \"f313\", \"f314\", \"f316\", \"f317\", \"f318\", \"f319\", \"f320\", \"f321\", \"f322\", \"f323\", \"f324\", \"f325\", \"f326\", \"f327\", \"f328\", \"f329\", \"f331\", \"f332\", \"f333\", \"f334\", \"f335\", \"f336\", \"f338\", \"f345\", \"f346\", \"f35\", \"f350\", \"f351\", \"f352\", \"f353\", \"f354\", \"f355\", \"f356\", \"f357\", \"f358\", \"f359\", \"f36\", \"f360\", \"f361\", \"f362\", \"f364\", \"f365\", \"f366\", \"f367\", \"f368\", \"f369\", \"f370\", \"f371\", \"f372\", \"f373\", \"f374\", \"f375\", \"f376\", \"f377\", \"f378\", \"f379\", \"f380\", \"f381\", \"f382\", \"f383\", \"f384\", \"f385\", \"f386\", \"f387\", \"f388\", \"f389\", \"f39\", \"f390\", \"f391\", \"f392\", \"f393\", \"f394\", \"f395\", \"f396\", \"f397\", \"f398\", \"f399\", \"f40\", \"f400\", \"f401\", \"f402\", \"f403\", \"f404\", \"f405\", \"f406\", \"f407\", \"f409\", \"f41\", \"f410\", \"f415\", \"f416\", \"f418\", \"f419\", \"f42\", \"f420\", \"f426\", \"f43\", \"f44\", \"f45\", \"f46\", \"f47\", \"f48\", \"f49\", \"f50\", \"f51\", \"f52\", \"f53\", \"f54\", \"f55\", \"f56\", \"f57\", \"f7\", \"f8\", \"f99\", \"find\", \"findinformation\", \"following\", \"for\", \"fullattentionneeded\", \"haslicense\", \"health\", \"hearratevariability\", \"highlighted\", \"informationimportant\", \"low\", \"low1\", \"measure\", \"medium\", \"medium1\", \"merged\", \"min\", \"needsaccomodation\", \"not_informuser\", \"not_userdriving\", \"objectnearby\", \"obtainconsent\", \"obtainconsentforuserdrive\", \"of\", \"preparingsystem\", \"properlyplaced\", \"reminduser\", \"restart\", \"rule\", \"rulesfollowed\", \"samecity\", \"sensorsconnect\", \"showconsentform\", \"situation\", \"situational\", \"size\", \"sleec\", \"solving\", \"start\", \"substanceuse\", \"systemdriving\", \"systemon\", \"takecontrolforsafety\", \"the\", \"time\", \"to\", \"trace\", \"trackvisionfield\", \"ub\", \"under\", \"unsat\", \"usercanturnoffmonitoring\", \"usercanturnoffsystem\", \"userenters\", \"usergivescontrol\", \"userimpaired\", \"usernotice\", \"userunderstands\", \"userwantscontrol\", \"vol\", \"warningsignaloff\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: at, backward, baselinediffers, bcr, be, because, blindspot, blocked_informuser, blocked_not_informuser, blocked_not_userdriving, blocked_userdriving, checking\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": false, \"issue_time_bounds\": [\"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 600 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 600 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\"], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: at, backward, baselinediffers, bcr, be, because, blindspot, blocked_informuser, blocked_not_informuser, blocked_not_userdriving, blocked_userdriving, checking\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": false, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\nR1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\n\\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' is specific and unambiguous, but its introduction may not be fully grounded in the existing context of the system.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"total_score\": 82.5}, \"ranking_score\": 82.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\nR1 when UserDrivingWithDistraction then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' is specific and unambiguous, but its introduction may not be fully grounded in the existing context of the system.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The change introduces a new condition that may not be clearly understood without additional context about how distraction is defined and measured.\"], \"total_score\": 82.5}","ranking_score":82.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8ed02be98ee8470e\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1\", \"R10\", \"R11_1\", \"R12_1\", \"R16\", \"R17\", \"R1_1\", \"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\", \"R9\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1b7fc2b6886f45aeb27ea2c3fdb1d686","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:24.127133","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'","id":153,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that emergency services are called when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule maintains stakeholder intent by directly addressing the concern of calling emergency services when a human is in a hazardous situation, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which emergency services are called, aligning with the system's purpose.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rule maintains stakeholder intent by directly addressing the concern of calling emergency services when a human is in a hazardous situation, with a clear rationale provided.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule maintains stakeholder intent by directly addressing the concern of calling emergency services when a human is in a hazardous situation, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 99.0}, \"ranking_score\": 99.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which emergency services are called, aligning with the system's purpose.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rule maintains stakeholder intent by directly addressing the concern of calling emergency services when a human is in a hazardous situation, with a clear rationale provided.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule maintains stakeholder intent by directly addressing the concern of calling emergency services when a human is in a hazardous situation, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 99.0}","ranking_score":99.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:24.082027","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'","id":152,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R21 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\nR21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\nR21_1 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\nR21_2 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and (not ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:23.711818","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'","id":151,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R21 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})\\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts})\n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:23.350260","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'","id":150,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R21 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:113:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"636e83f55a194cc89211c4ddb2716a58","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:51:22.987094","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":149,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R3 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 33}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 78.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))' could be clearer in its implications for emergency response.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\"], \"rationale\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 77.75}, \"ranking_score\": 77.75, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices unless ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 78.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))' could be clearer in its implications for emergency response.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\"], \"rationale\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is somewhat vague, potentially leading to confusion about the intent behind the exception to calling emergency services.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 77.75}","ranking_score":77.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:27.260155","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":148,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R3 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 33}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 74.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines the conditions under which emergency services are called, though the combination of conditions could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 78.25}, \"ranking_score\": 78.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 74.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines the conditions under which emergency services are called, though the combination of conditions could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance understanding of the changes made.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 78.25}","ranking_score":78.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:26.949718","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":147,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R3 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 34}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 81.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '({riskLevel} = high)' could be clearer if it specified the implications of this risk level in context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 80.62}, \"ranking_score\": 80.62, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3_1 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\nR3_2 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 81.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '({riskLevel} = high)' could be clearer if it specified the implications of this risk level in context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule decomposition maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific conditions and their implications is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 80.62}","ranking_score":80.62,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:26.641119","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'","id":146,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a human is on the floor with a hazard and the risk level is high, emergency services are called.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:114:51: Expected 'then' => 'iskLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale clearly explains the intent of the rule, but the context of the 'riskLevel' measure could be further clarified for complete understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'HumanOnFloorWithHazard' and 'riskLevel', making it specific and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale clearly explains the intent of the rule, but the context of the 'riskLevel' measure could be further clarified for complete understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale clearly explains the intent of the rule, but the context of the 'riskLevel' measure could be further clarified for complete understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nR_new when HumanOnFloorWithHazard and {riskLevel} = high then CallEmergencyServices\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'HumanOnFloorWithHazard' and 'riskLevel', making it specific and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale clearly explains the intent of the rule, but the context of the 'riskLevel' measure could be further clarified for complete understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale clearly explains the intent of the rule, but the context of the 'riskLevel' measure could be further clarified for complete understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b58cf4be6eee45bea55902874259d54c","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:50:26.017221","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":145,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R3_to_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R3\", \"R21\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R21 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R3 onto R21 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\n\\tR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 33}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 2, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3aeedcf52a6ccc2d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:8a72201fb4217932\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:ca48dfbfbe8c9b47\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm() at time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDi...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R21\", \"R3\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 78.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the use of existing concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which emergency services are called, though the addition of the new condition could introduce some ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 77.75}, \"ranking_score\": 77.75, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\n\tR3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices\n\t unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\nR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures unless (not {humanAssents})\n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 78.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the use of existing concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which emergency services are called, though the addition of the new condition could introduce some ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand its implications.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 77.75}","ranking_score":77.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 2, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3aeedcf52a6ccc2d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:8a72201fb4217932\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:ca48dfbfbe8c9b47\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm() at time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDi...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R21\", \"R3\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0a92f3ec48534d308efebcfeef837ee7","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:09.683142","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.","id":144,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloor then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"missing_element\": \"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"new_event\": \"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"new_measure\": \"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"new_capability\": \"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"new_rule\": \"R3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event HumanOnFloor is specialized into HumanOnFloorWithHazard to ensure that emergency services are called only when there is a hazard present.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 33}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 2, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3aeedcf52a6ccc2d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:8a72201fb4217932\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:ca48dfbfbe8c9b47\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm() at time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDi...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R21\", \"R3\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"HumanOnFloorWithHazard\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): HumanOnFloorWithHazard\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.006, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humanassents\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"agentdeployed\", \"agenthasappropriateappearance\", \"alarmon\", \"alarmrestarts\", \"allowusertocook\", \"askfordetaillevelofinstructions\", \"askforemergencycontact\", \"askuserifok\", \"at\", \"backward\", \"bcr\", \"be\", \"because\", \"beforecookingbegins\", \"blocked_not_callemergencyservices\", \"calibratespeech\", \"checking\", \"checktemperature\", \"collectandrecordinformation\", \"config\", \"conflict\", \"consideruserpractices\", \"core\", \"dataneedschecking\", \"detect\", \"detected\", \"domain\", \"end\", \"f0\", \"f132\", \"f133\", \"f135\", \"f153\", \"f154\", \"f160\", \"f169\", \"f170\", \"f171\", \"f174\", \"f175\", \"f176\", \"f177\", \"f178\", \"f179\", \"f180\", \"f181\", \"f182\", \"f183\", \"f184\", \"f185\", \"f186\", \"f187\", \"f188\", \"f189\", \"f190\", \"f191\", \"f192\", \"f193\", \"f194\", \"f195\", \"f197\", \"f199\", \"f200\", \"f201\", \"f202\", \"f203\", \"f205\", \"f207\", \"f208\", \"f209\", \"f210\", \"f230\", \"f252\", \"f253\", \"f254\", \"f255\", \"f256\", \"f257\", \"f258\", \"f259\", \"f260\", \"f261\", \"f262\", \"f263\", \"f264\", \"f275\", \"f277\", \"f278\", \"f279\", \"f280\", \"f281\", \"f284\", \"f285\", \"f30\", \"f311\", \"f312\", \"f40\", \"f41\", \"f42\", \"f43\", \"f44\", \"f45\", \"f5\", \"f50\", \"f51\", \"f52\", \"f60\", \"f71\", \"find\", \"following\", \"foodpreparation\", \"for\", \"givesuggestion\", \"givingcookinginstructions\", \"hazarddetected\", \"highlighted\", \"humanonfloor\", \"informcaregiver\", \"informuser\", \"interferesafely\", \"kitchensafe\", \"low\", \"measure\", \"medium\", \"meetinguser\", \"min\", \"monitormealtime\", \"needlevel\", \"nlow\", \"nmedium\", \"not_callemergencyservices\", \"not_giveuserdangerousobjects\", \"not_showdatahistory\", \"of\", \"openwindows\", \"personauthorized\", \"preparingdeployment\", \"providedatasummaries\", \"recalculateapproach\", \"remindlater\", \"reminduseroflimitations\", \"restart\", \"risklevel\", \"rule\", \"safepathfound\", \"showdatahistory\", \"situation\", \"situational\", \"size\", \"sleec\", \"smokedetectoralarm\", \"solving\", \"start\", \"the\", \"time\", \"timebetweenmeals\", \"to\", \"trace\", \"tracktime\", \"ub\", \"under\", \"unsat\", \"updateinformation\", \"updatemap\", \"usefirstpersonplurallanguage\", \"userasksforappropriatetasks\", \"userchangeitemlocation\", \"userchangemind\", \"userdisablesalarm\", \"userhaslimitation\", \"userneedsspecialaccomodations\", \"useroccupied\", \"userunpredictable\", \"userwantstocook\", \"vol\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: agentdeployed, agenthasappropriateappearance, alarmon, alarmrestarts, allowusertocook, askfordetaillevelofinstructions, askforemergencycontact, askuserifok, at, backward, bcr, be\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": false, \"issue_time_bounds\": [\"within 5 minutes\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 600 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 300 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 600 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 5 minutes\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 300 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\"], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): HumanOnFloorWithHazard\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: agentdeployed, agenthasappropriateappearance, alarmon, alarmrestarts, allowusertocook, askfordetaillevelofinstructions, askforemergencycontact, askuserifok, at, backward, bcr, be\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": false, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent PreparingDeployment\\n\\tevent AgentDeployed\\n\\tevent MeetingUser \\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent InformCaregiver\\n\\tevent CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tevent RemindLater\\n\\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tevent CalibrateSpeech \\n\\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t// Safety\\n\\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent HumanOnFloor\\n\\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\\n\\tevent OpenWindows\\n\\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\\n\\tevent AskUserIfOK\\n\\tevent InterfereSafely\\n\\tevent UserHasLimitation\\n\\tevent CheckTemperature\\n\\tevent FoodPreparation\\n\\tevent TrackTime \\n\\tevent UserUnpredictable\\n\\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\\n\\tevent MonitorMealTime\\n\\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\\n\\tevent UserWantsToCook\\n\\tevent AllowUserToCook\\n\\tevent GiveSuggestion\\n\\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\\n\\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\\n\\tevent UserChangeMind\\n\\tevent RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tevent UpdateInformation\\n\\tevent ShowDataHistory\\n\\tevent UpdateMap\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\\n\\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\\n\\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\\n\\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\\n\\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\\n\\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\\n\\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\\n\\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\\n\\t\\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\\n\\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\\n\\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\\n\\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\\n\\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n\\n\\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\\n\\t unless {userOccupied}\\n\\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\\n\\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tthen InterfereSafely\\n\\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\\n\\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\\n\\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\\n\\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\\n\\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\\n\\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\\n\\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\\n\\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\\n\\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\\n\\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\\n\\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\\n\\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\\n\\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\\n\\t\\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\\n\\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\\n\\t\\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\\n\\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\\n\\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n\\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\\n\\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\\n\\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\\n\\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\\n\\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\\n\\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \\n\\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\\n\\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety\\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\\n\\t// Autonomy\\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\\n\\t// Cultural sensitivity\\n\\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\\n\\t// Privacy\\n\\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\\n\\t// Security\\n\\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\\n\\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\\n\\tpr3 exists InformUser\\n\\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\\n\\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\\n\\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\\n\\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\\n\\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\\n\\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\\n\\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\\n\\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\\n\\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\\n\\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 88.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'HumanOnFloorWithHazard' is a specific and unambiguous specialization of an existing event, enhancing clarity regarding the conditions under which emergency services should be called.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"total_score\": 83.0}, \"ranking_score\": 83.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\n\t// Events\n\tevent PreparingDeployment\n\tevent AgentDeployed\n\tevent MeetingUser \n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent InformCaregiver\n\tevent CallEmergencyServices\n\tevent RemindLater\n\tevent AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\tevent AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tevent UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tevent CalibrateSpeech \n\tevent RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t// Safety\n\tevent AskForEmergencyContact\n\tevent HumanOnFloor\n\tevent SmokeDetectorAlarm\n\tevent OpenWindows\n\tevent FireSafetyMeasures\n\tevent AskUserIfOK\n\tevent InterfereSafely\n\tevent UserHasLimitation\n\tevent CheckTemperature\n\tevent FoodPreparation\n\tevent TrackTime \n\tevent UserUnpredictable\n\tevent GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\t// Cooking/kitchen related specifically\n\tevent MonitorMealTime\n\tevent BeforeCookingBegins\n\tevent UserWantsToCook\n\tevent AllowUserToCook\n\tevent GiveSuggestion\n\tevent GivingCookingInstructions\n\tevent ConsiderUserPractices\n\tevent UserChangeItemLocation\n\tevent UserChangeMind\n\tevent RecalculateApproach\n\t// Privacy\n\tevent ProvideDataSummaries\n\tevent CollectandRecordInformation\n\tevent UpdateInformation\n\tevent ShowDataHistory\n\tevent UpdateMap\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userOccupied: boolean\n\tmeasure timeBetweenMeals: numeric\n\tmeasure personAuthorized: boolean\n\tmeasure dataNeedsChecking: boolean\n\tmeasure userAsksForAppropriateTasks: boolean\n\tmeasure userNeedsSpecialAccomodations: boolean\n\tmeasure userDisablesAlarm: boolean\n\tmeasure alarmRestarts: boolean\n\tmeasure needLevel: scale(nlow, nmedium, nhigh)\n\tmeasure humanAssents: boolean\n\tmeasure safePathFound: boolean\n\tmeasure hazardDetected: boolean\n\tmeasure kitchenSafe: boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure alarmOn: boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant maxTimeBetweenMeals = 28800 // is predetermined\nevent HumanOnFloorWithHazard\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when MonitorMealTime then InformUser within 10 minutes\n\t\tunless {userOccupied} then RemindLater\n\t// If the max time limit is exceeded, call the caregiver and inform them of the situation and in the meantime, suggest they have a snack.\n\tR2 when AgentDeployed then TrackTime\n\tR2_1 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then InformCaregiver\n\tR2_2 when TrackTime and ({timeBetweenMeals} > maxTimeBetweenMeals) then GiveSuggestion\nR3 when HumanOnFloorWithHazard then CallEmergencyServices unless (not {humanAssents}) then not CallEmergencyServices\n\n\tR4 when InterfereSafely and (not {safePathFound}) then InformUser\n\t unless {userOccupied}\n\tR5 when UserWantsToCook then AllowUserToCook\n\tR5_1 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tthen InterfereSafely\n\tR6 when UserHasLimitation then InformUser\n\tR7 when UserWantsToCook then CheckTemperature\n\tR7_1 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then InformUser\n\tR8 when FoodPreparation then TrackTime\n\tR8_1 when TrackTime then InformUser\n\tR9 when MeetingUser then CollectandRecordInformation\n\tR9_1 when AgentDeployed then UpdateInformation\n\tR10 when GiveSuggestion then ConsiderUserPractices\n\tR11 when MeetingUser then AskForEmergencyContact\n\tR11_1 when AskForEmergencyContact then InformUser\n\tR12 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then not ShowDataHistory\n\tR12_1 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then ProvideDataSummaries\n\tR13 when UserUnpredictable then not GiveUserDangerousObjects\n\tR14 when AgentDeployed and (not {userAsksForAppropriateTasks}) then RemindUserOfLimitations\n\t\tunless ({needLevel} > nmedium)\n\tR15 when PreparingDeployment then AgentHasAppropriateAppearance\n\t\tunless {userNeedsSpecialAccomodations}\n\tR16 when PreparingDeployment then CalibrateSpeech\n\tR17 when GivingCookingInstructions then UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n\tR17_1 when GivingCookingInstructions then InformUser //offer to repeat\n\tR18 when BeforeCookingBegins then AskForDetailLevelOfInstructions\n\tR19 when UserChangeMind then RecalculateApproach\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high)\n\tR20 when UserChangeItemLocation then UpdateMap\n\t unless ({riskLevel} = high) then InterfereSafely\n\tR21 when SmokeDetectorAlarm then CallEmergencyServices within 5 minutes\n\t unless ({userDisablesAlarm} and (not {alarmRestarts})) then FireSafetyMeasures \n\tR21_1 when FireSafetyMeasures then OpenWindows\n\tR21_2 when FireSafetyMeasures then AskUserIfOK\n\tR21_3 when FireSafetyMeasures then InformCaregiver\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety\n c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices\n c2 when AllowUserToCook and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high)) then not InterfereSafely\n c3 when CheckTemperature and {hazardDetected} then not InformUser\n c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes\n c5 when FireSafetyMeasures then not OpenWindows\n\t// Autonomy\n c6 when UserWantsToCook then not AllowUserToCook\n c7 when GivingCookingInstructions then not UseFirstPersonPluralLanguage\n c8 when UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high) then not RecalculateApproach\n\t// Cultural sensitivity\n\tc9 when GiveSuggestion then not ConsiderUserPractices\n\t// Privacy\n\tc10 when AgentDeployed and (not {personAuthorized}) then ShowDataHistory\n\t// Security\n\tc11 when ShowDataHistory and {dataNeedsChecking} then not ProvideDataSummaries\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists PreparingDeployment\n\tpr2 exists MeetingUser\n\tpr3 exists InformUser\n\tpr4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ({userDisablesAlarm} or {alarmRestarts}) then InformUser\n\tpr5 exists RemindUserOfLimitations and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\tpr6 when HumanOnFloor and {humanAssents} then AskUserIfOK\n\tpr7 when HumanOnFloor and ({riskLevel} = high) then CallEmergencyServices\n\tpr8 when UserUnpredictable then AskUserIfOK\n // Avoid sharing user\u2019s personal information\n\tp9 exists ShowDataHistory and {personAuthorized}\n // Ensuring that the user gets fed\n p10 exists InformUser and (not {userOccupied}) while MonitorMealTime\n // Must be able to keep the user reasonably safe in the kitchen\n\tp13 exists InformUser and {hazardDetected}\n\tp14 exists InterfereSafely and ({hazardDetected} or ({riskLevel} = high))\n // Respecting user\u2019s autonomy when they request it\n\tp15 exists UserChangeMind and ({riskLevel} < high)\n // Must be able to connect user to help when needed\n\tp16 exists CallEmergencyServices while HumanOnFloor\n\tp17 exists CallEmergencyServices while SmokeDetectorAlarm\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 88.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'HumanOnFloorWithHazard' is a specific and unambiguous specialization of an existing event, enhancing clarity regarding the conditions under which emergency services should be called.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new event without fully explaining its implications, which may lead to some confusion about the context in which it applies.\"], \"total_score\": 83.0}","ranking_score":83.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 2, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3aeedcf52a6ccc2d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SmokeDetectorAlarm and ((not {userDisablesAlarm}) or {alarmRestarts}) then not CallEmergencyServices within 2 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:8a72201fb4217932\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when HumanOnFloor and ({userOccupied} and ({riskLevel} = high)) then not CallEmergencyServices Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:ca48dfbfbe8c9b47\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: SmokeDetectorAlarm() at time 0: Measure(userOccupied=False, timeBetweenMeals=7, personAuthorized=False, dataNeedsChecking=False, userAsksForAppropriateTasks=False, userNeedsSpecialAccomodations=False, userDi...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R21\", \"R3\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0a92f3ec48534d308efebcfeef837ee7","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-14T11:49:09.369848","use_case":"ALMI","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":143,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R21 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\nR21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 25}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 17.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the complexity of the conditions may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific scenarios being addressed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"total_score\": 36.94}, \"ranking_score\": 36.94, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21_1 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\nR21_2 when EvaluateSecurity and (not ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 17.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the complexity of the conditions may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific scenarios being addressed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rule decomposition introduces multiple branches that could confuse stakeholders regarding the intent and rationale behind the changes.\"], \"total_score\": 36.94}","ranking_score":36.94,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:09.571210","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":142,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R21 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 15.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts consistently, maintaining clarity in the context of security evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 41.25}, \"ranking_score\": 41.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 15.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts consistently, maintaining clarity in the context of security evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of an additional 'unless' clause may confuse the intent without further explanation.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 41.25}","ranking_score":41.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:09.212202","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":141,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R21","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R21\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R21\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R21 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 21.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity in the context of security evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 42.75}, \"ranking_score\": 42.75, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\nR21 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity unless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 21.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity in the context of security evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the complexity of the conditions may lead to some confusion without additional context or explanation.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 42.75}","ranking_score":42.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R21","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:08.682891","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:134:82: Expected ')' => 'taBreach) *and ({risk'","id":140,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a security evaluation indicates a data breach risk at a high level, the controller is informed, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\\nR_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:134:82: Expected ')' => 'taBreach) *and ({risk'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:134:82: Expected ')' => 'taBreach) *and ({risk'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 80.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 82.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 85.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'EvaluateSecurity', 'personalData', 'typesOfRisk', and 'riskLevel', which are clearly defined in the existing vocabulary, ensuring clarity in the context of data breach risks.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}, \"ranking_score\": 85.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nR_new when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ({typesOfRisk} = dataBreach) and ({riskLevel} > high)) then InformController\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 82.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 85.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'EvaluateSecurity', 'personalData', 'typesOfRisk', and 'riskLevel', which are clearly defined in the existing vocabulary, ensuring clarity in the context of data breach risks.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, but the introduction of 'high' as a risk level could benefit from further clarification on its specific threshold.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}","ranking_score":85.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"f2a8fc060f57431f8c849d59df0dc647","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:04:08.273879","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":139,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R7 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\nR7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the use of existing concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which the AssistController is invoked, ensuring clarity in the context of rights requests.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\nR7_1 when RightsRequested then AssistController\nR7_2 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the use of existing concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which the AssistController is invoked, ensuring clarity in the context of rights requests.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, the lack of explicit explanation for the change in context regarding 'not InformSubject' may lead to ambiguity in stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c2c3980ce3d84f9ab8bde3b97db67f07","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:46.573331","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":138,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when rights are requested and data compliance is confirmed, the subject is informed, addressing the missing normative behavior identified in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.25, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"rightsrequested\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of 'dataCompliance' could be further clarified for complete transparency.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'RightsRequested' and 'dataCompliance', making it clear and specific.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of 'dataCompliance' could be further clarified for complete transparency.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of 'dataCompliance' could be further clarified for complete transparency.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR_new when RightsRequested and {dataCompliance} then InformSubject\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'RightsRequested' and 'dataCompliance', making it clear and specific.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of 'dataCompliance' could be further clarified for complete transparency.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of 'dataCompliance' could be further clarified for complete transparency.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c2c3980ce3d84f9ab8bde3b97db67f07","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:46.259553","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":137,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R3 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\nR3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 86.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 51.25, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the structure of the rules may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific conditions under which actions are taken.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"total_score\": 66.94}, \"ranking_score\": 66.94, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\nR3_1 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\nR3_2 when DPAUpdate and (not ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth}))) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 86.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 51.25, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the structure of the rules may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific conditions under which actions are taken.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is provided, but the changes in context and the introduction of multiple branches may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended flow of actions.\"], \"total_score\": 66.94}","ranking_score":66.94,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:06.914777","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":136,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R3\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R3 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\nR3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 22}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 58.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 74.25}, \"ranking_score\": 74.25, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\nR3 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 58.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of 'concern' could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 74.25}","ranking_score":74.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R3","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:06.567417","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 33% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":135,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a DPAUpdate occurs without specific controller authorization, consent is obtained from the controller.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.333, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"dpaupdate\", \"specificcontrollerauth\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"gencontrollerauth\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 33% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, gencontrollerauth, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 33% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, gencontrollerauth, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent DPAMade\\n\\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\\n\\t// DPA initial terms\\n\\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\t// Prior to starting processing\\n\\tevent StartDPAProcess \\t\\t// Process information started\\n\\tevent DPAComplete\\n\\tevent DPAIncomplete\\n\\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \\n\\tevent DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t// If DPA agreement has expired\\n\\tevent DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\\n\\tevent ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tevent RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// Events processor is doing for controller\\n \\tevent EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tevent InformController \\t\\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tevent AssistController\\n\\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t// Obtain controller authorization\\n\\n\\tevent InformSubject\\n\\tevent InformSupervisor\\n\\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// Events that happen to DPA\\n\\tevent DataBreach\\n\\tevent RightsRequested\\n\\tevent RespondToRequest\\n\\tevent AllowAudits\\n\\tevent HelpAuditors\\n\\tevent AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tevent PassSecurity //created\\n\\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\t// event DPACompliant //created\\n\\n\\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorID: boolean\\n\\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\\n\\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \\t\\t\\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\\n\\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \\t\\t\\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\\n\\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \\t\\t\\n\\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \\t// Specific controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\\t\\t// General controller authorization\\n\\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \\t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\\n\\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \\t\\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\\n\\tmeasure personalData: boolean \\t\\t// Whether or not personal data exists\\n\\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\\t\\t\\t// Law requires processing without controller \\n\\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\\t\\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\\n\\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \\t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\\n\\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \\t\\t// Security about personal data ensured \\t \\n measure measureTaken: boolean \\t\\t//TODO: to make it concrete\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\\n\\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\\n\\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\\n\\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\\t\\t\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\\n\\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\\n\\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\\n\\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\\n\\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\\n\\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\\n\\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\\n\\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \\t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\\n\\n\\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\\n\\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\\n\\t otherwise DPATerminate\\n\\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\\n\\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\\n\\t\\t\\n\\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\\n\\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\\n\\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\\n\\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\\n\\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\\n\\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\\n\\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\\n\\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\\n\\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\t// As a processor\\n\\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\\n\\t// As a controller\\n\\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\\n\\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\\n\\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\\n\\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\\n\\tthen AssistController\\n\\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\\n\\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\\n\\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\\n\\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\\n\\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\\n\\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\\n\\t\\tthen not StartDPAProcess\\n\\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\\n\\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\\n\\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\\n\\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\\n\\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\\n\\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\\n\\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\\n\\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\\n\\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\\n\\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\\n\\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\\n\\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\t// come back to this and add legal act?\\n\\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\\n\\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\\n\\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\\n\\t\\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\\n\\t\\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\\n\\t\\tthen InformController\\n\\n\\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\\n\\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// The DPA is never completed\\n\\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\\n\\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \\n\\tthen not RemovePersonalData \\n\\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \\n\\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\\n\\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\\n\\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\\n\\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\\n\\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\\n\\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\\n\\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\\n\\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\\n\\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \\n\\tthen not InformController\\n\\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\\n\\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\\n\\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\\n\\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\\n\\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\\n\\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\\n\\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\\n\\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists DPAMade\\n\\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \\t\\n\\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \\t\\t\\n\\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\\n\\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\\n\\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \\t\\t\\t\\n\\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\\n\\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\\n \\tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\\n\\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\\n\\tpr12 exists InformController \\t\\t\\n\\tpr13 exists AssistController\\n\\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \\t\\t\\n\\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \\t\\t\\n\\tpr16 exists InformSubject\\n\\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\\n\\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\\n\\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\\n\\tpr20 exists DataBreach\\n\\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\\n\\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\\n\\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\\n\\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\\n\\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\\n\\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\\n\\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\\n\\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\\n\\n\\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\\n\\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\\n\\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\\n\\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\\n\\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\\n\\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\\n\\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\\n\\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\\n\\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\\n\\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\\n\\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \\n\\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\\n\\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\\n\\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\\n\\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 33% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and specifies the conditions under which consent must be obtained, making it understandable.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent DPAMade\n\t// For DPA shall contain (i.e regarding completion)\n\t// DPA initial terms\n\tevent EvaluateDPAProcess \t\t// Prior to starting processing\n\tevent StartDPAProcess \t\t// Process information started\n\tevent DPAComplete\n\tevent DPAIncomplete\n\t// After DPA completion, events that can happen \n\tevent DPATerminate \t\t\t// If DPA agreement has expired\n\tevent DPAUpdate \t\t\t// Making changes to agreement (after DPAComplete)\n\tevent ProcessPersonalData\n\tevent RemovePersonalData\n\t// Events processor is doing for controller\n \tevent EngageSubProcessor\n\tevent ChangeSubProcessor\n\tevent InformController \t\t// Concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tevent AssistController\n\tevent ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tevent ObtainControllerConsent \t\t// Obtain controller authorization\n\n\tevent InformSubject\n\tevent InformSupervisor\n\tevent TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tevent ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// Events that happen to DPA\n\tevent DataBreach\n\tevent RightsRequested\n\tevent RespondToRequest\n\tevent AllowAudits\n\tevent HelpAuditors\n\tevent AuditsOccur //created\n\tevent EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tevent PassSecurity //created\n\tevent CanObjectToChange //created\n\t// event DPACompliant //created\n\n\tmeasure controllerID: boolean\n\tmeasure controllerInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure processorID: boolean\n\tmeasure processorInfo: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaPurpose: boolean \t\n\tmeasure dpaNature: boolean\t\t\n\tmeasure dpaCategories: boolean\n\tmeasure dpaLength: numeric \t\t\t// Length of DPA processing, i.e years\n\tmeasure dpaActive: boolean \t\t\t// Whether or not the DPA agreement is active\n\tmeasure dataCompliance: boolean \t\t\n\tmeasure specificControllerAuth: boolean \t// Specific controller authorization\n\tmeasure genControllerAuth: boolean\t\t// General controller authorization\n\tmeasure controllerInstructions: boolean \t// Controller gave processor instructor or not\n\tmeasure rulesConform: boolean \t\t// If goes along with GDPR rules\n\tmeasure personalData: boolean \t\t// Whether or not personal data exists\n\tmeasure lawRequires: boolean\t\t\t// Law requires processing without controller \n\tmeasure informingAllowed: boolean\t\t// Processor allowed to inform Controller\n\tmeasure confidentialityEnsured: boolean \t// Agreed to be confidential about personal data\n\tmeasure securityEnsured: boolean \t\t// Security about personal data ensured \t \n measure measureTaken: boolean \t\t//TODO: to make it concrete\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure typesOfRisk: scale(dataDestruction, dataLoss, dataAlter, unauthDataAccess)\n\tmeasure auditorType: scale(controller, mandatedAuditor)\n\tmeasure auditType: scale(audit, inspection)\n\tmeasure art28Compliance: boolean\t\t\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Measures that need to be true (things DPA needs to contain) in order to be complete\n\t// 1. The DPA shall contain at least one controller\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 2. The DPA shall contain at least one processor\u2019s identity and contact details\n\t// 4. The DPA shall contain the nature and purpose of the processing\n\t// 5. The DPA shall contain the types of personal data\n\t// 6. The DPA shall contain the categories of data subjects\n\tR1 when DPAMade then DPAComplete\n\t unless (((((((not {controllerID}) or (not {controllerInfo})) or (not {processorInfo}))\n\t or (not {processorID})) or (not {dpaPurpose})) or (not {dpaNature})) or (not \t{dpaCategories})) then DPAIncomplete\n\n\t// 3. The DPA shall contain the duration of the processing\n\tR2 when DPAMade and (({dpaLength} > 0) or {dpaActive}) then DPAComplete\n\t otherwise DPATerminate\n\t// 7. The processor shall not engage a sub-processor without a prior specific or general written authorization of the controller\n\tR3 when DPAUpdate then EngageSubProcessor\n\t unless ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then ObtainControllerConsent\n\t\t\n\t// 8. In case of general written authorization, the processor shall inform the controller of any intended changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors\n\tR4 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then InformController\n\t// 9. The processor shall process personal data only on documented instructions from the controller\n\t// 10. If the processor requires by Union or Member State law to process personal data without instructions and law does not prohibit informing the controller on grounds of public interest, the processor shall inform the controller of that legal requirement BEFORE processing\n\t// 11. The processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process personal data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality\n\t// 12. The processor shall take all measures required pursuant to Article 32 or to ensure the security of processing\n\tR5 when StartDPAProcess and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t unless ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) then InformController\n\t// When there is personalData to process, and you have informed controller, you can process\n\tR6 when InformController and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) then ProcessPersonalData\n\t// 13. The processor shall assist the controller in fulfilling its obligation to respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\t// As a processor\n\tR7 when RightsRequested then AssistController\n\t// As a controller\n\tR8 when RightsRequested then RespondToRequest\n\t// 14. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring the security of processing\n\t// 17. The processor shall assist the controller in ensuring compliance with the obligations pursuant to data protection impact assessment\n\tR9 when StartDPAProcess and ((not {securityEnsured}) or (not {dataCompliance}))\n\tthen AssistController\n\t// 15. The processor shall assist the controller in notifying a personal data breach to the supervisory authority\n\t// 16. The processor shall assist the controller in communicating a personal data breach to the data subject\n\tR10 when DataBreach then InformSupervisor\n\tR11 when DataBreach then InformSubject\n\t// 18. The processor shall assist the controller in consulting the supervisory authorities prior to processing where the processing would result in a high risk in the absence of measures taken by the controller to mitigate the risk\n\tR12 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high))\n\t\tthen not StartDPAProcess\n\tR13 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then InformSupervisor\n\t// 19. The processor shall return or delete all personal data to the controller after the end of the provision of services relating to processing\n\tR14 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) then RemovePersonalData\n\t// 20. The processor shall immediately inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions\n\tR15 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) then InformController\n\t// 21. The processor shall make available to the controller information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the obligations Article 28 in GDPR\n\tR16 when StartDPAProcess and (not {art28Compliance}) then ProvideControllerInformation\n\t// 22. The processor shall allow for and contribute to audits, including inspections, conducted by the controller or another auditor mandated by the controller\n\tR17 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then AllowAudits\n\tR18 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then HelpAuditors\n\t// 23. The processor shall impose the same obligations on the engaged sub-processors by way of contract or other legal act under Union or Member State law\n\tR19 when EngageSubProcessor then ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\t// come back to this and add legal act?\n\t// 24. The processor shall remain fully liable to the controller for the performance of sub-processor\u2019s obligations\n\tR20 when EngageSubProcessor then TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\t// 25. When assessing the level of security, the processor shall take into account the risk of accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alternation, unauthorized disclosure of or access to the personal data transmitted, stored or processed\n\tR21 when EvaluateSecurity then PassSecurity\n\t\tunless ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss))\n\t\tor ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess) ) and ({riskLevel} > low)))\n\t\tthen InformController\n\n\t// 26. In case of general written authorization, the controller shall have the right to object to changes concerning the addition or replacement of sub-processors, after having been informed of such intended changes by the processor\n\tR22 when InformController and {genControllerAuth} then CanObjectToChange\nR_new when DPAUpdate and (not {specificControllerAuth}) then ObtainControllerConsent\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// The DPA is never completed\n\tc1 when DPAMade and ({controllerID} and ({controllerInfo} and ({processorInfo} and ({processorID} and ({dpaPurpose} and ({dpaNature} and {dpaCategories})))))) then not DPAComplete\n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) keeps personal data after processing has been complete\n\tc2 when StartDPAProcess and (({dpaLength} <= 0) or (not {dpaActive})) \n\tthen not RemovePersonalData \n\t// The data processor (and/or sub-processors) did not ensure security of data prior to processing \n\tc3 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and ({personalData} and ({confidentialityEnsured} and ({securityEnsured} and ((not {lawRequires}) and (not {informingAllowed})))))) then not ProcessPersonalData\n\t// The controller shares personal data to an organization that is not an approved data processor\n\tc4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor\n\t// The processor did not respond to requests for exercising the data subject\u2019s rights\n\tc5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject\n\t// The processor processed personal data even when processing would result in a high risk of a data breach\n\tc6 when EvaluateDPAProcess and ((not {measureTaken}) and ({riskLevel} = high)) then StartDPAProcess\n\t// The processor does not inform the controller if an instruction infringes the GDPR or other data protection provisions.\n\tc7 when StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform})) \n\tthen not InformController\n\t // Does not inform subject of databreach\n\tc8 when DataBreach then not InformSubject\n\t// Passes security when evaluated, even if there is risk\n\tc9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then PassSecurity\n\t// Does not inform controller of changing (add/remove) subprocessor\n\tc10 when ChangeSubProcessor and {genControllerAuth} then not InformController\n\t// Does not allow audits even when there is an audit and auditor\n\tc11 when AuditsOccur and (((({auditType} = audit) or ({auditType} = inspection)) or ({auditorType} = controller)) or ({auditorType} = mandatedAuditor)) then not AllowAudits\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists DPAMade\n\tpr2 exists EvaluateDPAProcess \t\n\tpr3 exists StartDPAProcess \t\t\n\tpr4 exists DPAComplete\n\tpr5 exists DPAIncomplete\n\tpr6 exists DPATerminate \t\t\t\n\tpr7 exists DPAUpdate \t\t\t\n\tpr8 exists ProcessPersonalData\n\tpr9 exists RemovePersonalData\n \tpr10 exists EngageSubProcessor\n\tpr11 exists ChangeSubProcessor\n\tpr12 exists InformController \t\t\n\tpr13 exists AssistController\n\tpr14 exists ProvideControllerInformation \t\t\n\tpr15 exists ObtainControllerConsent \t\t\n\tpr16 exists InformSubject\n\tpr17 exists InformSupervisor\n\tpr18 exists TakeLiabilityForSubProcessor\n\tpr19 exists ImposeObligationsOnSubProcessor\n\tpr20 exists DataBreach\n\tpr21 exists RightsRequested\n\tpr22 exists RespondToRequest\n\tpr23 exists AllowAudits\n\tpr24 exists HelpAuditors\n\tpr25 exists AuditsOccur //created\n\tpr26 exists EvaluateSecurity //created\n\tpr27 exists PassSecurity //created\n\tpr28 exists CanObjectToChange //created\n\n\t// The purpose of the data subject is to preserve user privacy\n\tP1 exists InformSupervisor while DataBreach\n\tP2 exists InformSubject while DataBreach\n\tP3 exists AssistController while RightsRequested\n\tP4 exists ObtainControllerConsent while DPAUpdate\n\t// The purpose of the data processor is to process personal data\n\tP5 exists ProcessPersonalData and ((({controllerInstructions} and {personalData}) and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while StartDPAProcess\n\tP6 exists ProcessPersonalData and (({personalData} and {confidentialityEnsured}) and {securityEnsured}) while InformController\n\t// A completed DPA must explicitly cover all GDPR provisions concerning data processing\n\tP6 exists PassSecurity while EvaluateSecurity\n\tP7 exists InformController and ({lawRequires} and {informingAllowed}) \n\tP8 exists StartDPAProcess and ({controllerInstructions} and (not {rulesConform}))\n\t// The purpose of the DPA is to be complete\n\tP9 exists DPATerminate while DPAIncomplete\n\tP10 exists DPAComplete while DPAMade\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and specifies the conditions under which consent must be obtained, making it understandable.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is mostly clear, the introduction of the new rule could benefit from more context regarding the implications of obtaining consent.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:4199b3bcb80089cd\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DPAUpdate and ((not {specificControllerAuth}) or (not {genControllerAuth})) then EngageSubProcessor Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ba929814a2395457\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when RightsRequested then not InformSubject Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:e45993dc72dc7ad1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c9 when EvaluateSecurity and ({personalData} and ((((({typesOfRisk} = dataDestruction) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataLoss)) or ({typesOfRisk} = dataAlter)) or ({typesOfRisk} = unauthDataAccess)) and ({riskLevel} > low))) then...\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"382cde8b0dda4362bf1a0b0104752bb5","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T19:02:06.169123","use_case":"DPA","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":134,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4b\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"missing_element\": \"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"new_event\": \"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"new_measure\": \"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"new_capability\": \"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"new_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that communicates the robot's operational status.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 1.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"robotworking\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\\nevent InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\\n \\nR4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses a specific and unambiguous term 'InformHumanAboutRobotStatus' that clearly indicates the action being taken, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\nevent InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \nR4b when RobotWorking then InformHumanAboutRobotStatus\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses a specific and unambiguous term 'InformHumanAboutRobotStatus' that clearly indicates the action being taken, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the proposed rule refines the action, it introduces a new term without explicit context or explanation, which may lead to some ambiguity regarding stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"5351a92f4ace4a08ba536395bf2fc613","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:29.579806","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":133,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4b\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_event\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_measure\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_capability\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_rule\": \"R4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure the inform action is contextually relevant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"robotworking\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: robotworking\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: robotworking\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\\n \\nR4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change preserves stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which the robot should inform the human, minimizing dependence on unstated context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed event 'RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the inform action is relevant.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change preserves stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which the robot should inform the human, minimizing dependence on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change preserves stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which the robot should inform the human, minimizing dependence on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 100.0}, \"ranking_score\": 100.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \nR4b when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed event 'RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the inform action is relevant.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change preserves stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which the robot should inform the human, minimizing dependence on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change preserves stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which the robot should inform the human, minimizing dependence on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 100.0}","ranking_score":100.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"5351a92f4ace4a08ba536395bf2fc613","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4b","timestamp":"2026-09-13T18:00:29.172756","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":132,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R4 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R4 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing R4 is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R4 is clearly justified as redundant, using established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing R4 is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing R4 is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R4 is clearly justified as redundant, using established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing R4 is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing R4 is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:36.902662","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":131,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"missing_element\": \"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"new_event\": \"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"new_measure\": \"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"new_capability\": \"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action of informing a human is refined into a more specific capability that notifies the human of the robot's operational status.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 1.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"robotworking\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\nevent NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the intent to inform the human about the robot's operational state.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the intent to inform the human about the robot's operational state.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the term 'NotifyHumanOfRobotStatus' could benefit from further context to clarify its implications compared to 'InformHuman'.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:36.565727","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":130,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_event\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_measure\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_capability\": \"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event RobotWorking is specialized into RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent to ensure that the inform action is contextually relevant when humans are nearby.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"robotworking\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: robotworking\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"Event specialization also changed the response.\"]}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: robotworking\", \"Event specialization also changed the response.\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed event 'RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the action 'InformHuman' should occur.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\nevent RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed event 'RobotWorkingWithHumanPresent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the action 'InformHuman' should occur.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the absence of explicit context for the new event may lead to some ambiguity regarding its application.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"70941d9f05d243c481118f44f90492bf","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:59:36.202560","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":129,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R4 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition of 'humanTooClose' in a way that aligns with the system's safety focus.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition of 'humanTooClose' in a way that aligns with the system's safety focus.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for strengthening the rule is provided, the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the actions taken in the proposed rule.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:47.092820","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":128,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R4 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 98.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions related to human proximity, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 87.0}, \"ranking_score\": 87.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 98.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions related to human proximity, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, the context of the concern regarding 'not InformHuman' is not fully explained.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 87.0}","ranking_score":87.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:46.719824","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":127,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the introduction of the exception could benefit from further context on how it affects the overall safety protocol.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule clearly specifies an exception to the existing rule using a well-defined concept, 'humanTooClose', which is already part of the existing measures.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the introduction of the exception could benefit from further context on how it affects the overall safety protocol.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the introduction of the exception could benefit from further context on how it affects the overall safety protocol.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.25}, \"ranking_score\": 92.25, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless {humanTooClose}\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule clearly specifies an exception to the existing rule using a well-defined concept, 'humanTooClose', which is already part of the existing measures.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the introduction of the exception could benefit from further context on how it affects the overall safety protocol.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the introduction of the exception could benefit from further context on how it affects the overall safety protocol.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.25}","ranking_score":92.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:46.345647","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":126,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the identified concern of safety in proximity.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.2, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humantooclose\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"is\", \"raised\", \"trackhumanlocation\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised, trackhumanlocation\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised, trackhumanlocation\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder safety concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of stopping actions.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly related to the robot's operation and safety measures, ensuring unambiguous understanding.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder safety concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of stopping actions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder safety concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of stopping actions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly related to the robot's operation and safety measures, ensuring unambiguous understanding.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder safety concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of stopping actions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder safety concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of stopping actions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"77a6d1b4ef2849c1b1b5f1a085284459","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:58:45.971608","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":125,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"actionhumanrandom\", \"concern\", \"is\", \"raised\", \"routeavailable\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, is, raised, routeavailable\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, is, raised, routeavailable\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and addresses a specific safety concern regarding human proximity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and addresses a specific safety concern regarding human proximity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"61c953b0907f42aca4b7215eefaab2cf","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:57:59.256883","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":124,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R6","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R6\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R6\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R6\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R6 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\nR6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 25}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 94.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 83.0}, \"ranking_score\": 83.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \nR6_1 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\nR6_2 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 94.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rules are understandable, the rationale for splitting into branches lacks detailed context for stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 83.0}","ranking_score":83.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"3998ac49d8cc45449b40bf5cbf6bc50b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R6","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:55:59.655411","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":123,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 25}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"actionhumanrandom\", \"concern\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly related to safety and human proximity, making it specific and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly related to safety and human proximity, making it specific and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"3998ac49d8cc45449b40bf5cbf6bc50b","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:55:59.289896","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":122,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R7\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R7 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\nR7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 82.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for stopping the robot, though the redundancy of {humanInRange} may cause slight ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 80.25}, \"ranking_score\": 80.25, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 82.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for stopping the robot, though the redundancy of {humanInRange} may cause slight ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is somewhat clear, but the introduction of multiple conditions without explicit explanation may confuse stakeholders regarding intent.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 80.25}","ranking_score":80.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:33.269080","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":121,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R7\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R7 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\nR7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and introduces a clear exception regarding human proximity, enhancing specificity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 82.5}, \"ranking_score\": 82.5, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask unless ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and introduces a clear exception regarding human proximity, enhancing specificity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the additional condition may require further context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 82.5}","ranking_score":82.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:32.920048","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":120,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R7","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R7\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R7 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\nR7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 89.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, but the introduction of multiple branches may create slight ambiguity in understanding the specific conditions under which actions are taken.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 82.62}, \"ranking_score\": 82.62, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\nR7_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose})) then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\nR7_2 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 89.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, but the introduction of multiple branches may create slight ambiguity in understanding the specific conditions under which actions are taken.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is provided, the context of the action changes and the implications of the new branches could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 82.62}","ranking_score":82.62,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:32.569905","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Declared semantic element is not used in proposed rule: robotworking and {humantooclose} then robotstopaction; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 17% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":119,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"new_event\": \"RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"new_measure\": \"RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"new_capability\": \"RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": false, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [\"Declared semantic element is not used in proposed rule: robotworking and {humantooclose} then robotstopaction\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.167, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humantooclose\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"actionhumanrandom\", \"concern\", \"humaninrange\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 17% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, humaninrange, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Declared semantic element is not used in proposed rule: robotworking and {humantooclose} then robotstopaction\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 17% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: actionhumanrandom, concern, humaninrange, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": false, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Declared semantic element is not used in proposed rule: robotworking and {humantooclose} then robotstopaction; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 17% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to address a specific safety concern.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to address a specific safety concern.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'humanTooClose' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"bdf7aad2b4da4864b2a4fae0e545ea03","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:53:32.228698","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":118,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 54.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 42.75, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the order of operations and their implications.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 56.88}, \"ranking_score\": 56.88, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 54.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 42.75, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the order of operations and their implications.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is clear, but the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context or explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 56.88}","ranking_score":56.88,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:37.271782","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":117,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R1 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 22}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 52.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 53.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the introduction of the complex condition with multiple nested logical operators may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific circumstances under which actions are modified.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"total_score\": 58.88}, \"ranking_score\": 58.88, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 52.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 53.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the introduction of the complex condition with multiple nested logical operators may lead to ambiguity in understanding the specific circumstances under which actions are modified.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"While the rationale for the change is stated, the added complexity and the introduction of a new condition without clear explanation may obscure stakeholder intent and the overall logic of the rule.\"], \"total_score\": 58.88}","ranking_score":58.88,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:36.901776","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":116,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R1 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 22}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 58.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 49.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the order of evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 59.38}, \"ranking_score\": 59.38, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 58.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 49.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the order of evaluation.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, and the introduction of 'not AdjustRoute' without context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 59.38}","ranking_score":59.38,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:36.533543","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 12% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":115,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while the robot is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.125, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humaninrange\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"bumphuman\", \"concern\", \"humantooclose\", \"is\", \"raised\", \"robotmoving\", \"routeavailable\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 12% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: bumphuman, concern, humantooclose, is, raised, robotmoving, routeavailable\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 12% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: bumphuman, concern, humantooclose, is, raised, robotmoving, routeavailable\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 12% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to specify the robot's action in response to human presence.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to specify the robot's action in response to human presence.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2e1f704f0793450483df423e30d6b9c0","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:51:36.183548","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":114,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 22}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 62.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 55.75, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' may create ambiguity regarding its specific implications in the context of robot movement.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"total_score\": 62.12}, \"ranking_score\": 62.12, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1_1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\nR1_2 when RobotMoving and (not ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 62.75, \"logical_simplicity\": 55.75, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' may create ambiguity regarding its specific implications in the context of robot movement.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is somewhat clear, but the changes in conditions and actions could confuse stakeholders without further explanation of the implications of 'not AvoidBumping'.\"], \"total_score\": 62.12}","ranking_score":62.12,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:29.278112","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":113,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R1 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 21}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 60.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 66.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule effectively reuses existing concepts and introduces a new condition that is specific and relevant to the context of human presence and route availability.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 69.12}, \"ranking_score\": 69.12, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety unless ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 60.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 66.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule effectively reuses existing concepts and introduces a new condition that is specific and relevant to the context of human presence and route availability.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the change is somewhat clear, the introduction of the new condition could lead to confusion regarding the intent behind the adjustments to the original rule.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 69.12}","ranking_score":69.12,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:28.908801","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":112,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R1 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 21}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 66.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 62.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, though the nested conditions could be simplified for better clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 69.62}, \"ranking_score\": 69.62, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then AvoidBumping unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 66.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 62.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, though the nested conditions could be simplified for better clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, but the introduction of 'not {routeAvailable}' without explicit context may confuse stakeholders.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 69.62}","ranking_score":69.62,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:28.551345","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 14% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":111,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops when a human is too close, addressing the concern of safety in the working environment.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 22}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.143, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humantooclose\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"humaninrange\", \"is\", \"raised\", \"robotmoving\", \"routeavailable\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 14% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, humaninrange, is, raised, robotmoving, routeavailable\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 14% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, humaninrange, is, raised, robotmoving, routeavailable\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 14% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to address safety concerns in a collaborative environment.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanTooClose} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to address safety concerns in a collaborative environment.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"369b16004044438ea11c153a07532854","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:48:28.195437","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":110,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R4 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 21}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 82.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 54.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for informing the human, though the nested conditions could be simplified for better clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 71.62}, \"ranking_score\": 71.62, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4_1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\nR4_2 when RobotWorking and (not ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))) then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 82.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 54.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for informing the human, though the nested conditions could be simplified for better clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern and its implications on robot behavior could be more explicitly stated.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 71.62}","ranking_score":71.62,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:55.083539","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":109,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 20}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 79.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 64.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed_rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions under which the robot should not continue tasks, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 73.25}, \"ranking_score\": 73.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman unless ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))))\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 79.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 64.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed_rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions under which the robot should not continue tasks, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rationale for the exception is somewhat clear, the introduction of the 'unless' clause may confuse stakeholders about the robot's decision-making process.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 73.25}","ranking_score":73.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:54.724615","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":108,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R4 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\nR4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 20}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 85.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 60.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and combines them in a way that reflects the intended safety measures without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 73.75}, \"ranking_score\": 73.75, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\nR4 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 85.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 60.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and combines them in a way that reflects the intended safety measures without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the specific combination of conditions could be more explicitly explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 73.75}","ranking_score":73.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:54.400158","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":107,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops its action when a human is detected within range while it is working, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 21}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.25, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"humaninrange\", \"robotworking\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"bumphuman\", \"concern\", \"humantooclose\", \"is\", \"raised\", \"routeavailable\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: bumphuman, concern, humantooclose, is, raised, routeavailable\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: bumphuman, concern, humantooclose, is, raised, routeavailable\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\\n event RobotWorking\\n event RobotContinueTask\\n event RobotStopAction\\n event AvoidBumping\\n event AdjustRoute\\n event InquireSafety\\n event AccountHumanRandomness\\n event TrackHumanLocation\\n event InformHuman\\n event HumanSaysStop\\n event AskPermission\\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n event IncreaseSpeed\\n event PreparingRobot\\n event AssignToRobot\\n event AssignLiability\\n event ConsiderAppearance\\n event ReportIncident\\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n event PrioritizeHumans\\n event ActionHumanRandom\\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\\n \\n // measures\\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\\n measure humanInRange: boolean\\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\\n measure humanConsents: boolean\\n measure accident: boolean\\n measure humansPresent: boolean\\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\\n\\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\\n\\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\\n\\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\\n\\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\\n\\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n \\n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\\n\\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n \\n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\\n \\t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\\n\\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\n \\t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\\n\\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n \\t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\\n\\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\\n \\t unless {humanConsents}\\n\\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n \\n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\\n\\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\\n\\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\\n\\n\\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\\n\\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\\n\\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\\n\\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\\n\\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\\n \\n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n // Safety\\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 25% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the concern raised.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to specify the robot's action in response to human presence.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the concern raised.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the concern raised.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n event RobotMoving //Includes arm and base movement\n event RobotWorking\n event RobotContinueTask\n event RobotStopAction\n event AvoidBumping\n event AdjustRoute\n event InquireSafety\n event AccountHumanRandomness\n event TrackHumanLocation\n event InformHuman\n event HumanSaysStop\n event AskPermission\n event MoveAtSafeSpeed\n event IncreaseSpeed\n event PreparingRobot\n event AssignToRobot\n event AssignLiability\n event ConsiderAppearance\n event ReportIncident\n event MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n event PrioritizeHumans\n event ActionHumanRandom\n event MoveAwayFromHuman\n \n // measures\n measure humanInRoute: boolean\n measure humanInRange: boolean\n measure bumpHuman: boolean\n measure humanTooClose: boolean\n measure routeAvailable: boolean\n measure humanReEnables: boolean\n measure risk: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure efficiency: scale(elow, emedium, ehigh)\n measure isHumanTask: boolean\n measure humanConsents: boolean\n measure accident: boolean\n measure humansPresent: boolean\n measure obstaclePresent: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when RobotMoving then AvoidBumping\n\t unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {humanTooClose} then AdjustRoute\n\t unless {bumpHuman} then InquireSafety\n\n R2 when RobotMoving then AccountHumanRandomness\n\n R3 when RobotMoving then TrackHumanLocation\n\n R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n \n R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman\n\n R5 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n \n R6 when InformHuman then RobotMoving unless {humanInRoute} then AdjustRoute\n \t unless (not {routeAvailable}) then AskPermission\n\n R7 when RobotMoving and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\n \t unless {humanReEnables} then RobotContinueTask\n\n R8 when RobotMoving then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n \t unless (({efficiency} = elow) and ({risk} = low)) then IncreaseSpeed\n\n R9 when PreparingRobot and {isHumanTask} then not AssignToRobot\n \t unless {humanConsents}\n\n R10 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n \n R10_1 when PreparingRobot then InformHuman\n\n R11 when PreparingRobot then ConsiderAppearance\n\n R12 when PreparingRobot then MinimizeCobotCollaboration\n\n\tR12_1 when PreparingRobot then PrioritizeHumans\n\n R13 when RobotWorking and {accident} then RobotStopAction\n\n R13_1 when RobotWorking and {accident} then ReportIncident\n\n R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman\n\n R15 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then ReportIncident\n \n R15_1 when RobotWorking and {obstaclePresent} then RobotStopAction\nR_new when RobotWorking and {humanInRange} then RobotStopAction\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n // Safety\n c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask\n c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping\n c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute\n c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction\n c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving\n c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman\n c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman\n c8 when HumanSaysStop then not RobotStopAction\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists RobotMoving and ({humanInRoute} and ((not {bumpHuman}) and (not {humanTooClose})))\n p2 exists RobotWorking and {humanInRange}\n p3 exists RobotContinueTask and {humanInRange}\n p4 exists RobotStopAction and {humanTooClose}\n p5 exists AvoidBumping and {humanTooClose}\n p6 exists AdjustRoute and {humanTooClose}\n p7 exists InquireSafety and ({risk} > medium)\n p8 when AccountHumanRandomness then RobotStopAction\n p9 when AccountHumanRandomness then MoveAtSafeSpeed\n p10 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then InformHuman\n p11 when HumanSaysStop then RobotStopAction\n p12 when AskPermission then AssignToRobot\n p13 when TrackHumanLocation and (not {humanTooClose}) then IncreaseSpeed\n p14 when PreparingRobot then AssignLiability\n p15 exists ReportIncident and {accident}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously to specify the robot's action in response to human presence.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the concern raised.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the concern raised.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 10, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 10, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5ad54791ca359897\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when ActionHumanRandom and ({humanInRange} or {humanTooClose}) then not RobotStopAction Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:640a1996a5723aec\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ActionHumanRandom and {routeAvailable} then not MoveAwayFromHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6da9e432d44cd8ee\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable}))) then not AvoidBumping Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:78f5e6047d7473f7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when ActionHumanRandom then RobotMoving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:97edca92d3f3bd8b\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when RobotMoving and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then not AdjustRoute Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:9cb4814fb3adf1b3\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when TrackHumanLocation and {humanTooClose} then not InformHuman Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:facf7f0abe36777f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when RobotWorking and ({humanInRange} or ({bumpHuman} or ({humanTooClose} or (not {routeAvailable})))) then RobotContinueTask Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:19f2c4bba0d025e8\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4 when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:85b9a327b7275a55\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when PreparingRobot and {humansPresent} then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ccaf8b3cb0d84e6c\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R4b when RobotWorking then InformHuman ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b95ccc69f34e44488f480e938228b839","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T17:46:54.028317","use_case":"CSICobot","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":106,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule13_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule13_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule13_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule13_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule13_1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\n\\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\n\\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\nRule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 32}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 80.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"total_score\": 90.0}, \"ranking_score\": 90.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\nRule13_1_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nRule13_1_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of 'eventually Concern is raised' could be clearer.\"], \"total_score\": 90.0}","ranking_score":90.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"378926ca6cbc4213ac762d3a8d5af6a8","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule13_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:45.127329","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":105,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that sensors cannot be removed without caregiver consent, addressing the concern raised when a user wants to remove sensors.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 32}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.2, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"userwantstoremovesensors\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"eventually\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, eventually, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, eventually, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\n\\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\n\\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\\nr_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of caregiver consent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, ensuring caregiver consent is required for sensor removal.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of caregiver consent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of caregiver consent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nr_new when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then not RemoveSensors\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, ensuring caregiver consent is required for sensor removal.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of caregiver consent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of caregiver consent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"378926ca6cbc4213ac762d3a8d5af6a8","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:03:44.756238","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":104,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when data is collected and it is needed for training, the data is anonymized to protect user privacy.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 31}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.2, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"datacollected\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"eventually\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, eventually, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, eventually, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\n\\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\n\\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\\nr_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 20% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'dataNeededForTraining' could be further clarified.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which data should be anonymized, aligning with the system's intent to protect user privacy.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'dataNeededForTraining' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'dataNeededForTraining' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nr_new when DataCollected and {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the conditions under which data should be anonymized, aligning with the system's intent to protect user privacy.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'dataNeededForTraining' could be further clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'dataNeededForTraining' could be further clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"9fd4efae1b7540b9a93c350f12f82d9a","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:18.401466","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":103,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule15","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule15\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule15\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule15\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule15 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\n\\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\n\\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 31}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, though the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, though the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, though the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 93.75}, \"ranking_score\": 93.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\nRule15_1 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\nRule15_2 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rules reuse existing concepts clearly and consistently, maintaining specificity and unambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, though the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for rule decomposition is understandable, though the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 93.75}","ranking_score":93.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"9fd4efae1b7540b9a93c350f12f82d9a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:01:18.033335","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":102,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\nRule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 30}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 69.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 51.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the logical structure is somewhat convoluted, making it less clear.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 62.75}, \"ranking_score\": 62.75, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\nRule1_1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\nRule1_2 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 69.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 51.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the logical structure is somewhat convoluted, making it less clear.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is vague, and the changes in actions are not fully explained, which may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 62.75}","ranking_score":62.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:06.857867","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":101,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule1\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule1 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\nRule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 29}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 62.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 40.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, but the logical structure is somewhat convoluted, which may lead to ambiguity in understanding the conditions under which actions are triggered.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 63.12}, \"ranking_score\": 63.12, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\nRule1 when PatientAsleep and (((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate)) or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low))) then TrackVitals unless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 62.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 40.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, but the logical structure is somewhat convoluted, which may lead to ambiguity in understanding the conditions under which actions are triggered.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the changes in logical conditions could confuse the rationale behind caregiver deactivation, requiring additional context for full clarity.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 63.12}","ranking_score":63.12,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:06.518888","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Unsupported new vocabulary: moderate; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 29% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":100,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the patient's discomfort exceeds moderate levels while tracking vitals, a caregiver is called to address the situation.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 30}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": false, \"new_symbols\": [\"moderate\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [\"moderate\"], \"errors\": [\"Unsupported new vocabulary: moderate\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): moderate\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.286, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"patientdiscomfort\", \"trackvitals\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"candeactivate\", \"concern\", \"is\", \"low\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 29% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: candeactivate, concern, is, low, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Unsupported new vocabulary: moderate\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 29% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): moderate\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: candeactivate, concern, is, low, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": false, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// BSN actions\\n\\tevent HideGeographicLocation\\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\\n event AdjustSamplingRate\\n event CalibrateBSN\\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n // Related to contacts and emergency\\n event EmergencyConfirmed\\n event CallAmbulance\\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\\n event MeetingUser\\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n event InformUser\\n event TrackVitals\\t\\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n event CallCaregiver\\n event EnsureEasyStopping\\n event RemoveSensors\\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n // Related to data\\n event DataCollected\\n event DeleteData\\n event AnonymizeData\\n\\n // Patient actions\\n event PatientOutdoors\\n event PatientAsleep\\n event PatientDoingChores\\n event PatientBathing\\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n event UserCanCallEmergency\\n event AdjustSensors\\n event UserWantsTimeout\\n event SystemShutDown\\n event ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\\n measure signsDetached: boolean\\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\\n measure userResponds: boolean\\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\\n measure seeLocation: boolean\\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\\n\\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t// Natural language rule 1\\n\\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\\n\\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\\n\\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 2\\n\\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 3\\n\\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\\n\\t\\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\\n\\n\\t// Natural language rule 4\\n\\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\\n\\t\\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\\n unless {authorizedParties}\\n unless {emergencyDetected}\\n\\n // Natural language rule 5\\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\\n\\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\\n then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 6\\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\\n\\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\\n\\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n\\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\\n\\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\\n\\n\\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\\n\\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\\n\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\\n\\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\\n\\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\\n\\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\\n\\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n\\n\\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\\n\\n\\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\\n\\t otherwise CallCaregiver\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\\n\\t\\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\\n\\n\\n\\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\\n then not RemoveSensors\\n\\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\\n\\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\\n\\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\\n\\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\\n\\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n\\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\\n\\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\\nrule_end\\n\\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\\n\\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\\n\\n\\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\\n\\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n\\n\\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\\n\\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\\n\\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\\n\\n\\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\\n\\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\\n\\n\\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\\n\\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\\n\\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\\n\\n //All the data collected is anonymized\\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\\n\\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\\n\\nconcern_end\\npurpose_start\\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\\n\\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\\n pr14 exists InformUser\\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\\n pr21 exists DataCollected\\n pr22 exists DeleteData\\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\\n\\n\\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\\n\\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\\n\\n\\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\\n\\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\\n\\n\\t// Cultural difference\\n\\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\\n\\n\\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\\n\\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\\n\\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\\n\\n\\t// Protect against threats\\n\\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\\n\\n\\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\\n\\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\\n\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Unsupported new vocabulary: moderate; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 29% of diagnosed context preserved.; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'moderate' discomfort could be better defined.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'TrackVitals' and 'patientDiscomfort', making it clear and specific.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'moderate' discomfort could be better defined.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'moderate' discomfort could be better defined.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// BSN actions\n\tevent HideGeographicLocation\n event ConfirmSensorPlacement\n event ConfirmUsersActivities\n event AdjustServiceTimerate\n event AdjustSamplingRate\n event CalibrateBSN\n event EnsureHardwareCompliance\n // Related to contacts and emergency\n event EmergencyConfirmed\n event CallAmbulance\n event ObtainEmergencyContact\n // Related to BSN and human interactions\n event MeetingUser\n event ObtainUserConsentForData\n event ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n event InformUser\n event TrackVitals\t\t// With assumption that this is being done accurately\n event InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n event CallCaregiver\n event EnsureEasyStopping\n event RemoveSensors\n event CaregiverCanDeactivate\n // Related to data\n event DataCollected\n event DeleteData\n event AnonymizeData\n\n // Patient actions\n event PatientOutdoors\n event PatientAsleep\n event PatientDoingChores\n event PatientBathing\n event UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n event UserCanCallEmergency\n event AdjustSensors\n event UserWantsTimeout\n event SystemShutDown\n event ObtainRiskLevel\n\n measure patientDiscomfort: scale(p_low, p_moderate, p_high)\n measure riskLevel: scale(r_low, r_moderate, r_high)\n measure batteryConsumption: scale(low, moderate, high)\n measure numUsersKnown: boolean\n measure numSampleKnown: boolean\n measure canDeactivate: boolean\n measure patientIsHome: boolean\n measure signsImpaired: boolean\n measure signsDetached: boolean\n measure isWaterproof: boolean\n measure hasFallAlertPendant: boolean\n measure allowsBathroomTracking: boolean\n measure canCommunicateRegularly: boolean\n measure authorizedParties: boolean\n measure emergencyDetected: boolean\n measure messageOnTime: boolean\n measure alternateSensorsDeployed: boolean\n measure timeToFailureKnown: boolean\n measure anomalyDetected: boolean\n measure unusualActivity: boolean\n measure sensorMalfunction: boolean\n measure sensorMisplacement: boolean\n measure userResponds: boolean\n measure caregiverResponds: boolean\n measure dataNeededForTraining: boolean\n measure userWantsToStop: boolean\n measure caregiverConsent: boolean\n measure seeHealthHistory: boolean\n measure seeDemographics: boolean\n measure seeLocation: boolean\n measure accurateHealthComparison: boolean\n\n //WARNING: Defined constant values\n constant autonomyConcern = 20\n constant bufferPeriod = 100\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t// Natural language rule 1\n\t// Track no matter what comfort is, unless it is medium or high and the caregiver can deactivate\n\tRule1 when PatientAsleep and ((({patientDiscomfort} = low) or ({patientDiscomfort} = moderate))\n\t or ({patientDiscomfort} = high)) then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// Natural language rule 2\n\tRule2 when PatientDoingChores and {patientIsHome} then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (({signsImpaired} or {signsDetached}) and {alternateSensorsDeployed})\n\n\t// Natural language rule 3\n\tRule3 when PatientBathing then TrackVitals\n\t\tunless (((not {isWaterproof}) and {hasFallAlertPendant}) or (not {allowsBathroomTracking}))\n\n\t// Natural language rule 4\n\tRule4 when PatientOutdoors and (not {patientIsHome}) then HideGeographicLocation\n\t\tunless {canCommunicateRegularly}\n unless {authorizedParties}\n unless {emergencyDetected}\n\n // Natural language rule 5\n Rule5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then AdjustServiceTimerate\n\n Rule5_1 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown}))\n then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 6\n Rule6 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then AdjustSamplingRate\n\n Rule6_1 when TrackVitals and (((not {timeToFailureKnown}) and (not {numSampleKnown}))\n or ({batteryConsumption} = high)) then not SystemShutDown\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 1\n // Because we can call for help whenever there is an emergency\n Rule7 when EmergencyConfirmed then CallCaregiver\n\n // Natural language rule 7 part 2\n // But only inform caregiver when the risk level is medium or high\n Rule7_1 when EmergencyConfirmed and ({riskLevel} >= moderate) then CallAmbulance\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected ensure that they are not caused by circumstantial conditions.\n // Confirm with user all sensors are properly placed\n Rule8 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmSensorPlacement\n\n // Confirm if the user is not performing any unusual physical activity\n Rule8_1 when TrackVitals and {anomalyDetected} then ConfirmUsersActivities\n\n // If an anomaly in vital signals is detected but not caused by sensor malfunction, misplacement, or unusual activity, inform the user about it.\n Rule9 when TrackVitals and ((({anomalyDetected} and (not {unusualActivity})) and\n (not {sensorMalfunction})) and (not {sensorMisplacement})) then InformUser\n\n\t// If user does not respond to this information in any way, notify their emergency contact.\n Rule9_1 when InformUser and (not {userResponds}) then CallCaregiver\n\n\t// If emergency does not answer, call medical help.\n\tRule9_2 when CallCaregiver and (not {caregiverResponds}) then CallAmbulance\n\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForData\n\t// In first interaction with the user, inform them of the purposes of using this technology.\n\t// inform them that the emergency contact can be contacted if the sensors detect anomalies in their vital signs.\n\t// Inform them about what will happen in case the sensors malfunction and they do not respond\n\tRule11 when MeetingUser then InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n\n\t// Ask them for an emergency contact\n Rule11_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\n\n Rule12 when DataCollected and (not {dataNeededForTraining}) then DeleteData\n unless {dataNeededForTraining} then AnonymizeData\n\n\tRule13 when TrackVitals and {userWantsToStop} then EnsureEasyStopping\n\t otherwise CallCaregiver\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > autonomyConcern)\n\t\t// If risk to user from removal is low, then alert caregiver\n\n\n\t// Do not remove sensors without explicit consent from caregiver to do so\n Rule13_1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent})\n then not RemoveSensors\n\n Rule13_2 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then InformUser\n\n Rule13_3 when UserWantsTimeout then InformUser\n\n // Inform/calibrate BSN signal so that the system doesn\u2019t overly interfere or cause stress\n Rule14 when CalibrateBSN and ((({seeHealthHistory} and {seeDemographics}) and {seeLocation})\n and {accurateHealthComparison}) then TrackVitals\n\n Rule15 when DataCollected then DeleteData within bufferPeriod seconds\n\n // Hardware must not unreasonably interfere with user\u2019s culture and religious acts\n Rule16 when MeetingUser then EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n // Ask user for consent prior to fitting BSN\n Rule16_1 when MeetingUser then ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n\n Rule17 when TrackVitals then UserCanCallEmergency\n\n Rule18 when CalibrateBSN then ObtainRiskLevel\nr_new when TrackVitals and ({patientDiscomfort} > moderate) then CallCaregiver\nrule_end\n\n// Security, autonomy, legal, cultural, privacy, safety.\nconcern_start\n\t// Patient should not be able to remove sensors by himself.\n\tC1 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors and (not {caregiverConsent}) then RemoveSensors\n\n\t// Every time sensors are adjusted, check the patient for their level of comfort.\n\tC2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate\n\n\t// The patient's privacy should be respected as much as possible. Patient should be able to select when they want a time out from the sensors. Patient should always be informed that their health monitoring will be decreased when they do it.\n\tC3 when UserWantsTimeout then not InformUser\n\n\t// If the patient does not want to wear the sensors due to privacy, the system should check in with the patient (via notifications). The system should also inform the user of the risks and tradeoffs between privacy and health as soon as they remove the sensors.\n\tC4 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not InformUser\n\n\t// System should not shut down if there is a flush of information (more than the system can handle).\n\tC5 when TrackVitals and ((not {messageOnTime}) and (not {numUsersKnown})) then SystemShutDown\n\n\t// As soon as system is setup, user and caregiver does not ask about the level of risk of the patient.\n\tC6 when CalibrateBSN then not ObtainRiskLevel\n\n //All the data collected must eventually be deleted in the system.\n\tC7 when DataCollected then not DeleteData eventually\n\n //All the data collected is anonymized\n C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually\n\n //If a user wants to remove sensors, then sensors must be removed (or it raises a concern)\n C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually\n\nconcern_end\npurpose_start\n// The purpose is to monitor a patient's health respecting their autonomy, safety, cultural differences, and privacy while protecting the user against security threats.\n\t// First we ensure every functionality is reachable\n pr1 exists HideGeographicLocation\n pr2 exists ConfirmSensorPlacement\n pr3 exists ConfirmUsersActivities\n pr4 exists AdjustServiceTimerate\n pr5 exists AdjustSamplingRate\n pr6 exists CalibrateBSN\n pr7 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n pr8 exists EmergencyConfirmed\n pr9 exists CallAmbulance\n pr10 exists ObtainEmergencyContact\n pr11 exists MeetingUser\n pr12 exists ObtainUserConsentForData\n pr13 exists ObtainUserConsentForSensors\n pr14 exists InformUser\n pr15 exists TrackVitals\n pr16 exists InformBSNPurposeAndResponseProtocol\n pr17 exists CallCaregiver\n pr18 exists EnsureEasyStopping\n pr19 exists RemoveSensors\n pr20 exists CaregiverCanDeactivate\n pr21 exists DataCollected\n pr22 exists DeleteData\n pr23 exists AnonymizeData\n pr24 exists PatientOutdoors\n pr25 exists PatientAsleep\n pr26 exists PatientDoingChores\n pr27 exists PatientBathing\n pr28 exists UserWantsToRemoveSensors\n pr29 exists UserCanCallEmergency\n pr30 exists AdjustSensors\n pr31 exists UserWantsTimeout\n pr32 exists SystemShutDown\n pr33 exists ObtainRiskLevel\n\n\t// Autonomy - User should be able to not disclose their geographic location while outdoors\n\tP1 exists HideGeographicLocation and (not {patientIsHome})\n\n\t// Safety - BSN should be able to call a caregiver in case of an emergency\n\tP2 exists CallCaregiver while EmergencyConfirmed\n\n\t// Cultural difference\n\tP3 exists EnsureHardwareCompliance\n\n\t// Privacy - BSN should be able to delete data when it is no longer necessary\n\tP4 exists DeleteData and (not {dataNeededForTraining})\n\n // Privacy - BSN should be able to anonymize data when it is being used\n P5 exists AnonymizeData and {dataNeededForTraining}\n\n\t// Protect against threats\n\tP6 exists CallAmbulance and (riskLevel >= moderate)\n\n\t// BSN should be able to inform user when an anomaly is detected while tracking vitals\n\tP7 exists InformUser and {anomalyDetected} while TrackVitals\n\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'TrackVitals' and 'patientDiscomfort', making it clear and specific.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'moderate' discomfort could be better defined.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though the context of 'moderate' discomfort could be better defined.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 3, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 3, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 3, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:3c3126f1dffe055d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C8 when DataCollected then not AnonymizeData eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c3d6297c27de62a9\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C9 when UserWantsToRemoveSensors then not RemoveSensors eventually Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:ce47356cef146bb4\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"C2 when TrackVitals and ({canDeactivate} and ({patientDiscomfort} > low)) then not CaregiverCanDeactivate Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"cc8337a5a1a949cb9276038fdbb6a41a","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T06:00:06.189123","use_case":"BSN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":99,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R2_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R2_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R2_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R2_1 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R2_1 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\n\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule removal is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R2_1 is clearly justified as redundant, using established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule removal is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule removal is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R2_1 is clearly justified as redundant, using established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule removal is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule removal is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing reliance on unstated context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:38.548671","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":98,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\", \"missing_element\": \"MonitorUserAttention\", \"new_event\": \"MonitorUserAttention\", \"new_measure\": \"MonitorUserAttention\", \"new_capability\": \"MonitorUserAttention\", \"new_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to monitor user attention, enhancing the response to ensure alertness.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"MonitorUserAttention\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): MonitorUserAttention\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 1.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"ensurealertness\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): MonitorUserAttention\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\nevent MonitorUserAttention\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\n\\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'MonitorUserAttention' is specific and unambiguous, directly relating to the existing concept of ensuring alertness.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nevent MonitorUserAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertness then MonitorUserAttention\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'MonitorUserAttention' is specific and unambiguous, directly relating to the existing concept of ensuring alertness.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed change enhances clarity but lacks explicit explanation of how 'MonitorUserAttention' improves upon 'TrackMetrics' in the context of ensuring alertness.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:38.180097","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":97,"issue_id":"redundancies_3","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2_1\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_event\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_measure\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_capability\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_rule\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to ensure metrics tracking is contextually relevant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"ensurealertness\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: ensurealertness\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: ensurealertness\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\n\\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which metrics are tracked, though it could benefit from further explanation of the rationale for the specialization.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event 'EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context for tracking metrics.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which metrics are tracked, though it could benefit from further explanation of the rationale for the specialization.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which metrics are tracked, though it could benefit from further explanation of the rationale for the specialization.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 93.75}, \"ranking_score\": 93.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\nR2_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event 'EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context for tracking metrics.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which metrics are tracked, though it could benefit from further explanation of the rationale for the specialization.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the condition under which metrics are tracked, though it could benefit from further explanation of the rationale for the specialization.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 93.75}","ranking_score":93.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"53b28f7921fe49d98f89edb70304e7ce","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:55:37.810986","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":96,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R2 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R2 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R2 is clearly justified as redundant, with no new concepts introduced.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The removal of R2 is clearly justified as redundant, with no new concepts introduced.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:48.664886","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:64:46: Expected 'then' => 'ionLevel} *= high the'","id":95,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"measure_specialization","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize measure\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize measure' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"userAttentionLevel\", \"new_event\": \"userAttentionLevel\", \"new_measure\": \"userAttentionLevel\", \"new_capability\": \"userAttentionLevel\", \"new_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad measure fullAttentionNeeded is refined into a more specific measure userAttentionLevel to better distinguish the context of user attention while driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\nmeasure userAttentionLevel:boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:64:46: Expected 'then' => 'ionLevel} *= high the'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:64:46: Expected 'then' => 'ionLevel} *= high the'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The measure 'userAttentionLevel' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the level of user attention while driving.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nmeasure userAttentionLevel:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {userAttentionLevel} = high then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The measure 'userAttentionLevel' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the level of user attention while driving.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change from 'fullAttentionNeeded' to 'userAttentionLevel' is explained, but the rationale could be clearer regarding how this impacts the overall safety context.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:48.332420","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"","id":94,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"missing_element\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_event\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_measure\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_capability\": \"UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"new_rule\": \"R2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event UserDriving is specialized into UserDrivingWithDistraction to distinguish when alertness is particularly necessary.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"UserDrivingWithDistraction\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): UserDrivingWithDistraction\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": true, \"context_coverage\": 0.5, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"fullattentionneeded\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"userdriving\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: userdriving\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): UserDrivingWithDistraction\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: userdriving\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": true, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": true, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": true, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating a distinct state of user driving that necessitates alertness.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\nevent UserDrivingWithDistraction\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDrivingWithDistraction and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating a distinct state of user driving that necessitates alertness.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of 'UserDrivingWithDistraction' could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:47.976762","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":93,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g3\", \"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_event\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_measure\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_capability\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_rule\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action EnsureAlertness is refined into a more specific action EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to better express the intended behavior in the context of driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 1.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"fullattentionneeded\", \"userdriving\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement of the action maintains stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale, though it could benefit from further context on the implications of the change.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action 'EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context of the alertness requirement.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The refinement of the action maintains stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale, though it could benefit from further context on the implications of the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement of the action maintains stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale, though it could benefit from further context on the implications of the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\nR2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action 'EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context of the alertness requirement.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The refinement of the action maintains stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale, though it could benefit from further context on the implications of the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement of the action maintains stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale, though it could benefit from further context on the implications of the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"da069ec87bb74e2b9b0743f791dbacc2","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:54:47.629611","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":92,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R1_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R1_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R1_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R1_1 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R1_1 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent regarding redundancy.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and uses established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent regarding redundancy.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent regarding redundancy.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and uses established concepts without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent regarding redundancy.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent regarding redundancy.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:39.158297","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":91,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\", \"missing_element\": \"TrackDriverAttention\", \"new_event\": \"TrackDriverAttention\", \"new_measure\": \"TrackDriverAttention\", \"new_capability\": \"TrackDriverAttention\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action TrackMetrics is refined into a more specific capability to track driver attention, enhancing the system's ability to monitor alertness effectively.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"TrackDriverAttention\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): TrackDriverAttention\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 1.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"ensurealertness\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): TrackDriverAttention\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent TrackDriverAttention\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'TrackDriverAttention' is specific and unambiguous, enhancing the clarity of the action compared to the broader 'TrackMetrics'.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent TrackDriverAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackDriverAttention\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'TrackDriverAttention' is specific and unambiguous, enhancing the clarity of the action compared to the broader 'TrackMetrics'.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change improves specificity, the rationale for the shift from 'TrackMetrics' to 'TrackDriverAttention' could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:38.803756","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.","id":90,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_1\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"missing_element\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_event\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_measure\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_capability\": \"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event EnsureAlertness is specialized into EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving to clarify the context in which metrics should be tracked.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.0, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"ensurealertness\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: ensurealertness\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.\", \"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: ensurealertness\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Patch does not preserve the diagnosed context.; Diagnosis alignment too weak: 0% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving is clear and contextually grounded, enhancing the specificity of the original event.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}, \"ranking_score\": 87.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\nevent EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\nR1_1 when EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event EnsureAlertnessWhileUserDriving is clear and contextually grounded, enhancing the specificity of the original event.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change clarifies the context, it may require additional explanation for stakeholders unfamiliar with the distinction between general alertness and alertness while driving.\"], \"total_score\": 87.5}","ranking_score":87.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"4d188b48c3934cbc9f54f949b84c5c26","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:38.460435","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":89,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\n\\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a condition that is specific and grounded in the domain, but the use of 'unless' twice may create ambiguity in understanding the precedence of conditions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 75.75}, \"ranking_score\": 75.75, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\n\tR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\nR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser unless {informationImportant} unless (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low))\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 83.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a condition that is specific and grounded in the domain, but the use of 'unless' twice may create ambiguity in understanding the precedence of conditions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is not fully explained, and the introduction of an additional condition without clear context may confuse stakeholders regarding the intended behavior.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 75.75}","ranking_score":75.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:03.348068","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":88,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R1_2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R1_2\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R1_2 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R1_2 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '{informationImportant}' could be clearer in its implications.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}, \"ranking_score\": 81.25, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser unless {informationImportant}\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts consistently, but the introduction of the condition '{informationImportant}' could be clearer in its implications.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the context of how '{informationImportant}' affects the decision-making process is not fully explained.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}","ranking_score":81.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:03.015447","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 2% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.","id":87,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1_2\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetrics and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"missing_element\": \"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"new_event\": \"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"new_measure\": \"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"new_capability\": \"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event TrackMetrics is specialized into TrackMetricsWithLowAttention to better capture the context of low attention levels.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.019, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"eyemovements\", \"hearratevariability\", \"low\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"at\", \"backward\", \"bcr\", \"be\", \"because\", \"blindspot\", \"blocked_informuser\", \"blocked_not_userdriving\", \"checking\", \"commonlanguage\", \"config\", \"conflict\", \"core\", \"decisionpoint\", \"detect\", \"detected\", \"domain\", \"end\", \"ensurealertness\", \"f0\", \"f108\", \"f109\", \"f11\", \"f111\", \"f129\", \"f130\", \"f136\", \"f146\", \"f163\", \"f215\", \"f235\", \"f236\", \"f237\", \"f238\", \"f239\", \"f240\", \"f241\", \"f242\", \"f243\", \"f244\", \"f245\", \"f246\", \"f247\", \"f248\", \"f249\", \"f250\", \"f251\", \"f252\", \"f253\", \"f254\", \"f255\", \"f256\", \"f278\", \"f380\", \"f381\", \"f382\", \"f383\", \"f384\", \"f385\", \"f386\", \"f387\", \"f388\", \"f389\", \"f390\", \"f391\", \"f392\", \"f393\", \"f394\", \"f397\", \"f398\", \"f41\", \"f42\", \"f424\", \"f425\", \"f426\", \"f427\", \"f428\", \"f429\", \"f43\", \"f430\", \"f431\", \"f432\", \"f433\", \"f434\", \"f435\", \"f436\", \"f437\", \"f438\", \"f44\", \"f449\", \"f45\", \"f450\", \"f451\", \"f453\", \"f454\", \"f455\", \"f46\", \"f462\", \"f465\", \"f51\", \"f52\", \"f53\", \"f7\", \"find\", \"following\", \"for\", \"fullattentionneeded\", \"haslicense\", \"health\", \"highlighted\", \"informationimportant\", \"low1\", \"measure\", \"medium\", \"medium1\", \"merged\", \"min\", \"needsaccomodation\", \"not_informuser\", \"not_userdriving\", \"objectnearby\", \"obtainconsent\", \"of\", \"properlyplaced\", \"restart\", \"rule\", \"rulesfollowed\", \"samecity\", \"sensorsconnect\", \"situation\", \"situational\", \"size\", \"sleec\", \"solving\", \"start\", \"substanceuse\", \"the\", \"time\", \"to\", \"trace\", \"trackmetrics\", \"trackvisionfield\", \"ub\", \"under\", \"unsat\", \"usergivescontrol\", \"userimpaired\", \"usernotice\", \"userunderstands\", \"userwantscontrol\", \"vol\", \"warningsignaloff\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 2% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: at, backward, bcr, be, because, blindspot, blocked_informuser, blocked_not_userdriving, checking, commonlanguage, config, conflict\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": false, \"issue_time_bounds\": [\"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\"], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 2% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: at, backward, bcr, be, because, blindspot, blocked_informuser, blocked_not_userdriving, checking, commonlanguage, config, conflict\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": false, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tevent FindInformation\\n\\tevent DetermineImportance\\n\\tevent UserDriving\\n\\tevent UserWantsControl\\n\\tevent UserEnters\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\tevent PreparingSystem\\n\\tevent SystemDriving\\n\\tevent SystemOn\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertness\\n\\tevent EnsureAccessibility\\n\\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\tevent TrackMetrics\\n\\tevent SensorsConnect\\n\\tevent BaselineDiffers\\n\\tevent ConfirmWithUser\\n\\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\tevent TrackVisionField\\n\\tevent ShowConsentForm\\n\\tevent CreateConsentForm\\n\\tevent TakeControlForSafety\\n\\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\\n measure informationImportant: boolean\\n measure health: boolean\\n measure hasLicense: boolean\\n measure substanceUse: boolean\\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\\n measure sameCity: boolean\\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\\n measure objectNearby: boolean\\n measure userNotice: boolean\\n measure blindSpot: boolean\\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\\n measure userImpaired: boolean\\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\n\\n\\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n\\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n\\t// Drowsiness detected\\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\\n\\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\\n\\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\\n\\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\\n\\t\\tunless {informationImportant}\\n\\n\\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\\n\\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\\n\\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\\n\\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\\n\\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\\n\\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\\n\\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\\n\\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\\n\\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\\n\\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\\n\\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\\n\\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\\n\\n\\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\\n\\n\\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\\n\\n\\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\\n\\n\\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\\n\\n\\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\\n\\t\\tunless {warningSignalOff}\\n\\n\\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {userGivesControl}\\n\\n\\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\\n\\n\\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\\n\\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \\n\\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \\n\\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists InformUser\\n\\tp2 exists RemindUser\\n\\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\\n\\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\\n\\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\\n\\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\\n\\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 2% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'TrackMetricsWithLowAttention' is a specific specialization of an existing event, enhancing clarity about the context of low attention levels.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 82.75}, \"ranking_score\": 82.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tevent FindInformation\n\tevent DetermineImportance\n\tevent UserDriving\n\tevent UserWantsControl\n\tevent UserEnters\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\tevent UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\tevent PreparingSystem\n\tevent SystemDriving\n\tevent SystemOn\n\tevent EnsureAlertness\n\tevent EnsureAccessibility\n\tevent EnsureAlertIndependence\n\tevent TrackMetrics\n\tevent SensorsConnect\n\tevent BaselineDiffers\n\tevent ConfirmWithUser\n\tevent ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\tevent TrackVisionField\n\tevent ShowConsentForm\n\tevent CreateConsentForm\n\tevent TakeControlForSafety\n\n measure hearRateVariability: scale(low, medium, high)\n measure eyeMovements: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n measure fullAttentionNeeded: boolean\n measure properlyPlaced: boolean\n measure informationImportant: boolean\n measure health: boolean\n measure hasLicense: boolean\n measure substanceUse: boolean\n measure commonLanguage: boolean\n measure userUnderstands: boolean\n measure sameCity: boolean\n measure rulesFollowed: boolean\n measure objectNearby: boolean\n measure userNotice: boolean\n measure blindSpot: boolean\n measure obtainConsent: boolean\n measure needsAccomodation: boolean\n measure userImpaired: boolean\n measure warningSignalOff: boolean\n measure userGivesControl: boolean\n measure decisionPoint: boolean\nevent TrackMetricsWithLowAttention\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\n\n\tR1 when UserDriving then EnsureAlertness\n\n\tR1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n\t// Drowsiness detected\nR1_2 when TrackMetricsWithLowAttention and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\n R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness\n\n R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics\n\n R3 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then InformUser\n\n R3_1 when SensorsConnect and (not {properlyPlaced}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR4 when UserDriving then not InformUser\n\t\tunless {informationImportant}\n\n\tR5 when FindInformation then DetermineImportance\n\n R6 when BaselineDiffers then ConfirmWithUser\n\n R7 when UserWantsControl and (({health} and {hasLicense}) and (not {substanceUse})) then UserDriving\n\n R8 when UserEnters and ({commonLanguage} and {userUnderstands})\n then ObtainConsentForUserDrive\n\n R9 when UserEnters and (not {sameCity}) then InformUser\n\n R9_1 when InformUser then RemindUser within 10 minutes\n\n R9_2 when InformUser and (not {rulesFollowed}) then RemindUser\n\n R10 when UserDriving and ({objectNearby} and (not {userNotice})) then InformUser\n\n R11 when UserDriving then TrackVisionField\n\n R11_1 when TrackVisionField and {blindSpot} then InformUser\n\n R12 when UserEnters then ShowConsentForm\n\n R12_1 when ShowConsentForm and (not {obtainConsent}) then not UserDriving\n\n\tR13 when PreparingSystem then CreateConsentForm\n\n\tR14 when UserEnters and {needsAccomodation} then EnsureAccessibility\n\n\tR15 when PreparingSystem then EnsureAlertIndependence\n\n\tR16 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then InformUser\n\n\tR16_1 when UserDriving and {userImpaired} then TakeControlForSafety\n\t\tunless {warningSignalOff}\n\n\tR17 when SystemDriving and {decisionPoint} then UserDriving\n\t\tunless {userGivesControl}\n\n\tR18 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffSystem\n\n\tR18_1 when SystemOn then UserCanTurnOffMonitoring\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\tc1 exists UserDriving and (not {properlyPlaced})\n\tc2 exists UserDriving and (not {obtainConsent}) \n\tc3 exists UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) \n\tc4 exists UserDriving and {substanceUse}\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists InformUser\n\tp2 exists RemindUser\n\t// event GiveInformation - used to be in rule 4, now replaced with inform user\n\tp3 exists TakeControlForSafety\n\tp4 when UserDriving and (({hearRateVariability} = low) and ({eyeMovements} = low)) then InformUser\n\tp6 when UserEnters and {obtainConsent} then not ShowConsentForm\n\tp7 when InformUser and {rulesFollowed} then not RemindUser within 10 minutes\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'TrackMetricsWithLowAttention' is a specific specialization of an existing event, enhancing clarity about the context of low attention levels.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 82.75}","ranking_score":82.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 4, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 4, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 3, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:6c3c5f8995b78f24\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:a0e3d30371c7a0fc\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R2 when UserDriving and {fullAttentionNeeded} then EnsureAlertness ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R2\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cead89a89828152e\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R1_1 when EnsureAlertness then TrackMetrics ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_1\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:930754a3b5c5ec11\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: UserDriving() at time 0: TrackMetrics() at time 0: Measure(hearRateVariability=low, eyeMovements=low1, fullAttentionNeeded=False, properlyPlaced=False, informationImportant=False, health=False, hasLicense=Fa...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R1_2\", \"R3\", \"R3_1\", \"R4\", \"R7\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"2bb2676c41224c3381584f8bcae1f5e0","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R1_2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:53:02.678683","use_case":"SafeSCAD","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":86,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule10 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n // events\\n\\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n\\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\\n\\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\\n\\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\\n\\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\n\\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent FirstMeetingUser\\n\\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\\n\\tevent DiscardInformation\\n\\tevent ChangeSubject\\n\\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\\n\\tevent DesigningAgent\\n\\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\\n\\tevent DeployingAgent\\n\\tevent ReviewInteraction\\n\\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\n\\tevent RecommendOtherwise\\n\\tevent PersonAsksforData\\n\\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\tevent UserSelfMedicates\\n\\tevent LogMedication\\n\\tevent InformCarer\\n\\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\n\\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \\n\\tevent UserInStress\\n\\tevent ShowEmpathy\\t\\n event OfferHelp\\n\\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n\\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\\n\\tevent CloseDoor\\n\\tevent UserSaysStop\\n\\tevent RobotStop\\n\\tevent AskToFinishFirst\\n\\tevent CollectionStarted\\n\\tevent StoreMinInfo\\n\\tevent StopActivity\\n\\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\\n\\tevent ObtainAssent\\n\\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InteractionStarted\\n\\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n\\tevent DressinginClotingX\\n\\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\\n\\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\\n\\tevent CurtainsOpened\\n\\tevent RefuseRequest\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent DressingStarted\\n\\tevent CloseCurtains\\n\\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\\n\\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\n \\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\\n\\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\\t\\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\\n\\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\\n\\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\\n\\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\\n\\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\\n\\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\\n\\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\\n\\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\\n\\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\\n\\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\\n\\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\\n\\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\\n \\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant N = 5\\ndef_end\\n\\n\\nrule_start\\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\\n \\t \\tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\\n \\t \\tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\\n \\t\\t\\tunless (not {userAssent})\\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\\n \\t \\t\\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\\n \\t\\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userAdvices}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {userConfused})\\n \\t\\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\\n \\t\\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n \\t\\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\n \\t\\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t\\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t\\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\n \\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\\n \\t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\\n \\tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\\n \\tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\\n \\t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\\n \\t unless {userAdamant}\\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n \\t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\\n \\t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n// Privacy and data protection\\n\\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\t// Autonomy and agency\\n\\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\\n\\t// Transparency and disclosure\\n\\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\\n\\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\\n\\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\\n\\t// Prevent harm and safety\\n\\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\\t\\nconcern_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 31}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a new condition regarding risk levels that is somewhat clear but could benefit from more explicit definitions of the risk thresholds.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"total_score\": 79.5}, \"ranking_score\": 79.5, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst unless ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a new condition regarding risk levels that is somewhat clear but could benefit from more explicit definitions of the risk thresholds.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the additional condition is not fully explained, which may lead to confusion about the intent behind the change.\"], \"total_score\": 79.5}","ranking_score":79.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:57.137045","use_case":"DressAssist","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":85,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule10 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n // events\\n\\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n\\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\\n\\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\\n\\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\\n\\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\n\\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent FirstMeetingUser\\n\\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\\n\\tevent DiscardInformation\\n\\tevent ChangeSubject\\n\\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\\n\\tevent DesigningAgent\\n\\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\\n\\tevent DeployingAgent\\n\\tevent ReviewInteraction\\n\\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\n\\tevent RecommendOtherwise\\n\\tevent PersonAsksforData\\n\\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\tevent UserSelfMedicates\\n\\tevent LogMedication\\n\\tevent InformCarer\\n\\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\n\\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \\n\\tevent UserInStress\\n\\tevent ShowEmpathy\\t\\n event OfferHelp\\n\\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n\\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\\n\\tevent CloseDoor\\n\\tevent UserSaysStop\\n\\tevent RobotStop\\n\\tevent AskToFinishFirst\\n\\tevent CollectionStarted\\n\\tevent StoreMinInfo\\n\\tevent StopActivity\\n\\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\\n\\tevent ObtainAssent\\n\\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InteractionStarted\\n\\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n\\tevent DressinginClotingX\\n\\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\\n\\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\\n\\tevent CurtainsOpened\\n\\tevent RefuseRequest\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent DressingStarted\\n\\tevent CloseCurtains\\n\\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\\n\\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\n \\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\\n\\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\\t\\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\\n\\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\\n\\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\\n\\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\\n\\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\\n\\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\\n\\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\\n\\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\\n\\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\\n\\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\\n\\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\\n\\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\\n \\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant N = 5\\ndef_end\\n\\n\\nrule_start\\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\\n \\t \\tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\\n \\t \\tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\\n \\t\\t\\tunless (not {userAssent})\\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\\n \\t \\t\\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\\n \\t\\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userAdvices}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {userConfused})\\n \\t\\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\\n \\t\\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n \\t\\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\n \\t\\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t\\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t\\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\n \\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\\n \\t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\\nRule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\\n \\tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\\n \\tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\\n \\t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\\n \\t unless {userAdamant}\\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n \\t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\\n \\t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n// Privacy and data protection\\n\\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\t// Autonomy and agency\\n\\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\\n\\t// Transparency and disclosure\\n\\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\\n\\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\\n\\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\\n\\t// Prevent harm and safety\\n\\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\\t\\nconcern_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 32}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of 'not' in the context of 'StopActivity' may create ambiguity regarding the intended action.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 82.88}, \"ranking_score\": 82.88, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10_1 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule10_2 when UserSaysStop and (not ({riskLevel} < r_moderate)) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 91.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the introduction of 'not' in the context of 'StopActivity' may create ambiguity regarding the intended action.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for splitting the rule is clear, the changes in action conditions could confuse stakeholders without further context.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 82.88}","ranking_score":82.88,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:56.792027","use_case":"DressAssist","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":84,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule10 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n // events\\n\\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n\\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\\n\\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\\n\\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\\n\\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\n\\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent FirstMeetingUser\\n\\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\\n\\tevent DiscardInformation\\n\\tevent ChangeSubject\\n\\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\\n\\tevent DesigningAgent\\n\\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\\n\\tevent DeployingAgent\\n\\tevent ReviewInteraction\\n\\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\n\\tevent RecommendOtherwise\\n\\tevent PersonAsksforData\\n\\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\tevent UserSelfMedicates\\n\\tevent LogMedication\\n\\tevent InformCarer\\n\\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\n\\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \\n\\tevent UserInStress\\n\\tevent ShowEmpathy\\t\\n event OfferHelp\\n\\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n\\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\\n\\tevent CloseDoor\\n\\tevent UserSaysStop\\n\\tevent RobotStop\\n\\tevent AskToFinishFirst\\n\\tevent CollectionStarted\\n\\tevent StoreMinInfo\\n\\tevent StopActivity\\n\\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\\n\\tevent ObtainAssent\\n\\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InteractionStarted\\n\\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n\\tevent DressinginClotingX\\n\\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\\n\\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\\n\\tevent CurtainsOpened\\n\\tevent RefuseRequest\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent DressingStarted\\n\\tevent CloseCurtains\\n\\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\\n\\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\n \\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\\n\\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\\t\\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\\n\\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\\n\\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\\n\\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\\n\\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\\n\\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\\n\\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\\n\\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\\n\\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\\n\\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\\n\\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\\n\\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\\n \\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant N = 5\\ndef_end\\n\\n\\nrule_start\\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\\n \\t \\tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\\n \\t \\tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\\n \\t\\t\\tunless (not {userAssent})\\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\\n \\t \\t\\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\\n \\t\\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userAdvices}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {userConfused})\\n \\t\\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\\n \\t\\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n \\t\\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\n \\t\\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t\\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t\\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\n \\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\\n \\t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\\nRule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\\n \\tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\\n \\tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\\n \\t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\\n \\t unless {userAdamant}\\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n \\t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\\n \\t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n// Privacy and data protection\\n\\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\t// Autonomy and agency\\n\\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\\n\\t// Transparency and disclosure\\n\\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\\n\\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\\n\\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\\n\\t// Prevent harm and safety\\n\\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\\t\\nconcern_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 31}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for stopping the robot based on risk levels.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for stopping the robot based on risk levels.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the introduction of a new condition related to risk levels may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:56.410882","use_case":"DressAssist","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Unsupported new vocabulary: r_moderate; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.","id":83,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the user says stop and the risk level is below moderate, the robot stops its actions, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 32}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": false, \"new_symbols\": [\"r_moderate\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [\"r_moderate\"], \"errors\": [\"Unsupported new vocabulary: r_moderate\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): r_moderate\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.5, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"r_moderate\", \"risklevel\", \"usersaysstop\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"concern\", \"is\", \"raised\"], \"response_aligned\": false, \"errors\": [\"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Unsupported new vocabulary: r_moderate\", \"Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): r_moderate\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: concern, is, raised\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": false, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n // events\\n\\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n\\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\\n\\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\\n\\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\\n\\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\n\\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\\n\\tevent FirstMeetingUser\\n\\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\\n\\tevent DiscardInformation\\n\\tevent ChangeSubject\\n\\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\\n\\tevent DesigningAgent\\n\\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\\n\\tevent DeployingAgent\\n\\tevent ReviewInteraction\\n\\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\n\\tevent RecommendOtherwise\\n\\tevent PersonAsksforData\\n\\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\tevent UserSelfMedicates\\n\\tevent LogMedication\\n\\tevent InformCarer\\n\\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\n\\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \\n\\tevent UserInStress\\n\\tevent ShowEmpathy\\t\\n event OfferHelp\\n\\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n\\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\\n\\tevent CloseDoor\\n\\tevent UserSaysStop\\n\\tevent RobotStop\\n\\tevent AskToFinishFirst\\n\\tevent CollectionStarted\\n\\tevent StoreMinInfo\\n\\tevent StopActivity\\n\\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\\n\\tevent ObtainAssent\\n\\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InteractionStarted\\n\\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n\\tevent DressinginClotingX\\n\\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\\n\\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\\n\\tevent CurtainsOpened\\n\\tevent RefuseRequest\\n\\tevent InformUser\\n\\tevent DressingStarted\\n\\tevent CloseCurtains\\n\\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\\n\\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\n \\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\\n\\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\\t\\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\\n\\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\\n\\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\\n\\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\\n\\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\\n\\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\\n\\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\\n\\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\\n\\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\\n\\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\\n\\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\\n\\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\\n\\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\\n\\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\\n \\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant N = 5\\ndef_end\\n\\n\\nrule_start\\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\\n \\t \\tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\\n \\t \\tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\\n \\t\\t\\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\\n \\t\\t\\tunless (not {userAssent})\\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\\n \\t \\t\\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\\n \\t\\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userAdvices}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\\n \\t\\t\\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {userConfused})\\n \\t\\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\\n \\t\\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n \\t\\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n \\t\\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\\n \\t\\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t\\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t\\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t\\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t\\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\\n \\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n \\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\\n \\t unless {consentGranted}\\n \\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\\n \\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\\n\\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\\n \\t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop\\n \\t unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\\n \\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\\n \\tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\\n \\tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\\n \\t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\\n \\t unless {userAdamant}\\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\\n \\t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\\n \\t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\\nr_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n// Privacy and data protection\\n\\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\\n\\t// Autonomy and agency\\n\\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\\n\\t// Transparency and disclosure\\n\\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\\n\\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\\n\\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\\n\\t// Prevent harm and safety\\n\\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\\t\\nconcern_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Unsupported new vocabulary: r_moderate; Patch does not preserve an implicated response/action.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale provided explains the purpose of the rule well, but the context of 'riskLevel' could be more explicitly defined for full clarity.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'UserSaysStop' and 'riskLevel', making it clear and specific in its intent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale provided explains the purpose of the rule well, but the context of 'riskLevel' could be more explicitly defined for full clarity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale provided explains the purpose of the rule well, but the context of 'riskLevel' could be more explicitly defined for full clarity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n // events\n\tevent EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n\tevent InteractingWithNonPatients\n\tevent DetermineSensitivityLevel\n\tevent DetectUrgentHealthIssue\n\tevent InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\n\tevent ObtainEmergencyContact\n\tevent FirstMeetingUser\n\tevent UserDiscussingPrivateInfo\n\tevent DiscardInformation\n\tevent ChangeSubject\n\tevent InformUserPrivateInformation\n\tevent DesigningAgent\n\tevent InformUserOfLimitations\n\tevent DeployingAgent\n\tevent ReviewInteraction\n\tevent RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\n\tevent RecommendOtherwise\n\tevent PersonAsksforData\n\tevent sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\tevent UserSelfMedicates\n\tevent LogMedication\n\tevent InformCarer\n\tevent KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\n\tevent SuggestPerformingActions \n\tevent UserInStress\n\tevent ShowEmpathy\t\n event OfferHelp\n\tevent CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n\tevent UserExpressDiscomfort\n\tevent CloseDoor\n\tevent UserSaysStop\n\tevent RobotStop\n\tevent AskToFinishFirst\n\tevent CollectionStarted\n\tevent StoreMinInfo\n\tevent StopActivity\n\tevent CheckForandObtainProxy\n\tevent ObtainAssent\n\tevent AdmininisteringMedication\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InteractionStarted\n\tevent InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n\tevent DressinginClotingX\n\tevent EmotionRecognitionDetected\n\tevent CurtainOpenRqt\n\tevent CurtainsOpened\n\tevent RefuseRequest\n\tevent InformUser\n\tevent DressingStarted\n\tevent CloseCurtains\n\tevent UserHasDifferentCulture\n\tevent EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\n \n\t// measures\n\tmeasure userUnderDressed: boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure userDistressed : scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure roomDark:boolean\n\tmeasure notVisible:boolean\n\tmeasure userAssent:boolean\n\tmeasure consentGrantedwithinXmonths:boolean //X needs to be defined.\t\n measure competentIndicatorRequired: boolean\n\tmeasure competentToGrantConsent:boolean\n\tmeasure dressPreferenceTypeA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdvices:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingItemNotFound:boolean\n\tmeasure userConfused:boolean\n\tmeasure buildingFloor:scale(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5,f6,f7,f8,f9,f10) //the building has max 10 floors.\n\tmeasure theUserHasBeenInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure userCompetenceIndicator:numeric\n\tmeasure numTotalInteractions:numeric\n\tmeasure userWantsHumanSubsequently:boolean\n\tmeasure userWantsNoHuman:boolean\n\tmeasure withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm:scale(low,moderate,severe)\n\tmeasure consentGranted:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorRequired:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisWithdrawn:boolean\n\tmeasure consentIndicatorisRevoked:boolean\n\tmeasure userRequiresAdaptiveClothing:boolean\n\tmeasure contextuallyObvious:boolean\n\tmeasure sensitiveInformationX:boolean\n\tmeasure riskLevel:scale(r_low,r_moderate,r_severe)\n\tmeasure unauthorizedPersonInRoom:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationRisk:boolean\n\tmeasure minimumFrequency:boolean\n\tmeasure medicationAdverseEffects:boolean\n\tmeasure irrelevant:boolean\n\tmeasure userAdamant:boolean\n\tmeasure clothingChoiceInappropriate:boolean\n\tmeasure numDaysDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure numHoursDeployed:numeric\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicNecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure anthropomorphicAppearance:boolean\n \n\t// constants\n\tconstant N = 5\ndef_end\n\n\nrule_start\n Rule1 when CurtainOpenRqt then CurtainsOpened\n \t \tunless {userUnderDressed} then RefuseRequest\n \t \tunless ({userDistressed} > medium) then CurtainsOpened\n Rule2 when DressingStarted then CloseCurtains\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless ({buildingFloor} >= f5)\n \t\t\tunless ({roomDark} and {notVisible})\n \t\t\tunless (not {userAssent})\n Rule3 when EmotionRecognitionDetected and ({userDistressed} > medium) then InformUser\n \t \t\t unless {consentGrantedwithinXmonths}\n \t\t unless ((not {competentIndicatorRequired}) or (not {competentToGrantConsent}))\n Rule4 when DressingStarted and ({dressPreferenceTypeA} and {genderTypeB}) then DressinginClotingX\n \t\t\tunless {userAdvices}\n \t\t\tunless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t\tunless {clothingItemNotFound} then InformUser\n \t\t\tunless {userRequiresAdaptiveClothing}\n Rule5 when InteractionStarted then InformUserThisIsAgentnotHuman\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless (not {userConfused})\n \t\t unless {contextuallyObvious}\n \t\t unless ({theUserHasBeenInformed} and (not {userConfused}))\n Rule6 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n \t\t unless (not {informationAvailable}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n \t\t unless {sensitiveInformationX} then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n Rule7 when DressingStarted then ObtainAssent\n \t\t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t\t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t\t unless {consentGranted}\n \t\t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t\t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule7_1 when AdmininisteringMedication then ObtainAssent\n \t unless ({userCompetenceIndicator} = N) then CheckForandObtainProxy\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\n \t unless ({withholdingActivityPhysicalHarm} >= moderate)\n \t unless {consentGranted}\n \t unless (not {consentIndicatorRequired})\n \t unless ({consentIndicatorisWithdrawn} or {consentIndicatorisRevoked}) then StopActivity\n\nRule8 when CollectionStarted then StoreMinInfo\nRule9 when DressingStarted then CloseDoor\n \t unless ({medicalEmergency} or {userAdvices})\nRule10 when UserSaysStop then RobotStop\n \t unless ({riskLevel} > r_low) then AskToFinishFirst\nRule11_1 when UserInStress then ShowEmpathy\nRule11_2 when UserInStress then OfferHelp\nRule12 when DressingStarted then not CautionWhereOrWhenTouching\n \t unless {medicalEmergency}\nRule13 when UserExpressDiscomfort then RobotStop\nRule14 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom})\n \tthen not sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\nRule15 when UserSelfMedicates then LogMedication\n \tunless {medicationRisk} then InformUser\n \t unless {medicationAdverseEffects} then InformCarer within 2 minutes\nRule16 when InteractionStarted then KeepLogOfFrequentActivities\nRule16_1 when KeepLogOfFrequentActivities and (not {minimumFrequency}) then SuggestPerformingActions\nRule17 when InteractingWithNonPatients then DetermineSensitivityLevel\nRule18 when DetectUrgentHealthIssue then InformEmergencyContactAndHealthOrgs\nRule19 when FirstMeetingUser then ObtainEmergencyContact\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo then InformUserPrivateInformation\nRule20_1 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then DiscardInformation\nRule20_2 when InformUserPrivateInformation then ChangeSubject\nRule21 when DesigningAgent and ({anthropomorphicNecessary} or {anthropomorphicAppearance}) then InformUserOfLimitations\nRule22 when DeployingAgent and (({numDaysDeployed} > 3) and ({numHoursDeployed} > 5)) then ReviewInteraction\nRule23 when InteractionStarted then RecordFashionBasedOnOccasion\nRule24 when DressingStarted and {clothingChoiceInappropriate} then RecommendOtherwise\n \t unless {userAdamant}\nRule25 when UserHasDifferentCulture then EnsureDesiredLanguageAvailable\nRule26 when InteractionStarted and ({numTotalInteractions} < 3) then EnsureHumanCarerPresent\n \t unless {userWantsHumanSubsequently}\n \t unless {userWantsNoHuman}\nr_new when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then RobotStop\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n// Privacy and data protection\n\tc1 when PersonAsksforData and ((not {consentGranted}) or {unauthorizedPersonInRoom}) then sharePersonalDataAndInformWhy\n\t// Autonomy and agency\n\t//c2 when DressingStarted then not ObtainAssent\n\t// Transparency and disclosure\n\tc3 when UserDiscussingPrivateInfo and {irrelevant} then not DiscardInformation\n\t// Cultural and social sensitivity\n\t//c4 when DressingStarted and ({buildingFloor} < f5) then not CloseCurtains\n\t// Prevent harm and safety\n\tc5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity\t\nconcern_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'UserSaysStop' and 'riskLevel', making it clear and specific in its intent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale provided explains the purpose of the rule well, but the context of 'riskLevel' could be more explicitly defined for full clarity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale provided explains the purpose of the rule well, but the context of 'riskLevel' could be more explicitly defined for full clarity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 1, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 1, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b9daa53456d8b80\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when UserSaysStop and ({riskLevel} < r_moderate) then not StopActivity Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"1e8efac1ded74761a9b6e38f4c3b28a7","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:49:56.048566","use_case":"DressAssist","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":82,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g3\", \"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"CollectPatientDataWithContext\", \"new_event\": \"CollectPatientDataWithContext\", \"new_measure\": \"CollectPatientDataWithContext\", \"new_capability\": \"CollectPatientDataWithContext\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability CollectPatientData is refined into a more specific capability CollectPatientDataWithContext to better express the intended behavior in the context of relevant data.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\nevent CollectPatientDataWithContext\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The new capability 'CollectPatientDataWithContext' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating a refined action related to data collection.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}, \"ranking_score\": 81.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nevent CollectPatientDataWithContext\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientDataWithContext otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The new capability 'CollectPatientDataWithContext' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating a refined action related to data collection.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed rule maintains the original intent but introduces a new term that may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}","ranking_score":81.25,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:04.931229","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":81,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"measure_specialization","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize measure\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize measure' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"patientDataRelevant\", \"new_event\": \"patientDataRelevant\", \"new_measure\": \"patientDataRelevant\", \"new_capability\": \"patientDataRelevant\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The general data relevance measure is refined into a patient-specific data relevance measure to ensure the collection of only necessary patient data.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\nmeasure patientDataRelevant:boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'patientDataRelevant' is specific and unambiguous, aligning with the context of patient examination.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}, \"ranking_score\": 81.25, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nmeasure patientDataRelevant:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({patientDataRelevant} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'patientDataRelevant' is specific and unambiguous, aligning with the context of patient examination.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The proposed change maintains the original intent but introduces a new measure without clear explanation of its distinction from existing measures.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}","ranking_score":81.25,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:04.596299","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":80,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"missing_element\": \"ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\", \"new_event\": \"ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\", \"new_measure\": \"ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\", \"new_capability\": \"ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event ExaminingPatient is specialized into ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData to ensure data collection is contextually appropriate.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\nevent ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\nRule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData' is specific and unambiguous, enhancing clarity by indicating the context for data collection.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\nevent ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\nRule16 when ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData and (not {dataUnnecessary}) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'ExaminingPatientWithRelevantData' is specific and unambiguous, enhancing clarity by indicating the context for data collection.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The change in terminology may require additional context for stakeholders to fully understand the implications of the specialization.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:04.268052","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:145:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":79,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_Rule16","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_Rule16\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_Rule16\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule16\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule Rule16 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove Rule16 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:145:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:145:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b50e56521d01483dbbba2e3d5c3ebd3a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:45:03.925138","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":78,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"r_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when a patient is being examined and exhibits aggressive behavior, the system refers to a human examiner for safety.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'ExaminingPatient' and 'behaviorAggressive', which are clear and domain-grounded.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nr_new when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'ExaminingPatient' and 'behaviorAggressive', which are clear and domain-grounded.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in action regarding 'RobotStopSession' is not fully explained, leading to potential confusion.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:07.521733","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":77,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule14\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule14\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule14 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\nRule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\nRule14_1 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nRule14_2 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:07.168567","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":76,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule14\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule14\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule14 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\nRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\nRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer unless {behaviorAggressive}\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:06.817898","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":75,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule14","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule14\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule14\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule14\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule14 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\nRule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\nRule14 when ExaminingPatient and ({behaviorAggressive} and {behaviorAggressive}) then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0956ada1bdd5412a8421330ba65559cd","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:43:06.445868","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":74,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"r_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent calling support when meeting a user without training data representation, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 80.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly, but the term 'trainingDataRepresentative' could be more explicitly defined to enhance clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nr_new when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly, but the term 'trainingDataRepresentative' could be more explicitly defined to enhance clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed rule is understandable, but the context of 'not CallSupport' may require further explanation to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:07.121820","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":73,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule10 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\nRule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\nRule10_1 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\nRule10_2 when MeetingUser and (not (not {trainingDataRepresentative})) then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:06.775614","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":72,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule10 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\nRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\nRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState unless (not {trainingDataRepresentative})\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:06.432806","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":71,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule10","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule10\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule10\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule10 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\nRule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\nRule10 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"f023b29e050044c09e8e7cb160fdfe56","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule10","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:42:06.093659","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":70,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"r_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if the patient is not comfortable or if age and consent considerations are not met, a human examiner is referred to handle the situation appropriately.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 90.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 58.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and maintains specificity regarding patient comfort and consent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"total_score\": 74.5}, \"ranking_score\": 74.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nr_new when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvailable}))) then ReferToHumanExaminer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 90.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 58.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and maintains specificity regarding patient comfort and consent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the change in action from 'ExaminingPatient' to 'ReferToHumanExaminer' could benefit from further context.\"], \"total_score\": 74.5}","ranking_score":74.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:07.553107","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":69,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule18\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule18 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:148:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18_1 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\nRule18_2 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:07.193628","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":68,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule18\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule18 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:06.815885","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":67,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule18\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule18 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible})))) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6f3759b46b23491ba98620c6f102d422","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:41:06.447792","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":66,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"r_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that the robot stops the session only when the user has provided consent to end the session.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of user consent could be further clarified to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition for stopping the session, which aligns with the system's intent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of user consent could be further clarified to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of user consent could be further clarified to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nr_new when UserEndSession and {userConsentAvailable} then RobotStopSession\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition for stopping the session, which aligns with the system's intent.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of user consent could be further clarified to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of user consent could be further clarified to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"3fb3f9ec8e39483590c049be0cee107c","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:40:04.805390","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'","id":65,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"r_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"r_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to handle the situation where a user requests information but it is not available or disclosure is not permitted, ensuring appropriate actions are taken.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:147:55: Expected 'then' => 'vailable} *and {infor'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, but the use of placeholders like {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} could be more explicitly defined.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}, \"ranking_score\": 85.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nr_new when UserRequestInfo and {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} then InformUserandReferToHumanCarer\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, but the use of placeholders like {informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted} could be more explicitly defined.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable, but the context of the action changes could be better explained to enhance clarity for stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}","ranking_score":85.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"r_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:54.296171","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved","id":64,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_Rule5\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_Rule5\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule Rule5 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nRule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=7, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted))) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted))) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 18\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F0', 'F56', 'F699', 'F165', 'F24', 'F697', 'F140', 'F399', 'F389', 'F400', 'F405', 'F700', 'F393', 'F386', 'F682', 'F681', 'F680', 'F676', 'F678', 'F679', 'F683', 'F597', 'F690', 'F44', 'F23', 'F167', 'F702', 'F53', 'F391', 'F686', 'F394', 'F390', 'F388', 'F693', 'F50', 'F160', 'F49', 'F47', 'F43', 'F706', 'F397', 'F707', 'F387', 'F402', 'F692', 'F411', 'F48', 'F694', 'F161', 'F392', 'F396', 'F395', 'F142', 'F684', 'F691', 'F410', 'F685', 'F703', 'F677', 'F223', 'F403', 'F404', 'F401', 'F698', 'F139', 'F398', 'F55', 'F701']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1103, 1123]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1129, 1149]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1154, 1176]\\nExaminingPatient : [1183, 1199]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1568, 1586]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1656, 1674]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1623, 1645]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=7, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 16\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F40', 'F0', 'F699', 'F24', 'F41', 'F519', 'F465', 'F651', 'F635', 'F647', 'F642', 'F44', 'F23', 'F53', 'F630', 'F637', 'F624', 'F463', 'F625', 'F158', 'F50', 'F450', 'F47', 'F631', 'F645', 'F643', 'F636', 'F650', 'F455', 'F162', 'F457', 'F451', 'F137', 'F644', 'F52', 'F633', 'F634', 'F136', 'F449', 'F448', 'F452', 'F446', 'F459', 'F447', 'F632', 'F179', 'F157', 'F629', 'F453', 'F464', 'F646', 'F458', 'F461', 'F462', 'F628', 'F267', 'F456', 'F638', 'F623', 'F698', 'F626', 'F45', 'F46', 'F454', 'F139', 'F460', 'F627', 'F641']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=9, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=7, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3358, 3378]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3384, 3404]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3438, 3454]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2899, 2917]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2987, 3005]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2954, 2976]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5_1\", \"text\": \"Rule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5_2\", \"text\": \"Rule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule20\", \"text\": \"Rule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:7ead682518457ce3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\nRule5_1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\nRule5_2 when UserRequestInfo and (not ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:7ead682518457ce3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:53.929923","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved","id":63,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule5\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_Rule5\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule5 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted))) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (not (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted))) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 19\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F708', 'F707', 'F162', 'F499', 'F718', 'F781', 'F715', 'F46', 'F0', 'F724', 'F164', 'F414', 'F432', 'F425', 'F423', 'F693', 'F428', 'F48', 'F780', 'F54', 'F717', 'F47', 'F49', 'F699', 'F714', 'F419', 'F429', 'F716', 'F136', 'F698', 'F137', 'F696', 'F723', 'F431', 'F420', 'F710', 'F711', 'F23', 'F424', 'F42', 'F416', 'F695', 'F52', 'F720', 'F243', 'F157', 'F139', 'F709', 'F158', 'F703', 'F413', 'F417', 'F415', 'F22', 'F418', 'F719', 'F700', 'F697', 'F422', 'F426', 'F430', 'F694', 'F427', 'F55', 'F702', 'F421', 'F43', 'F701']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1083, 1103]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1109, 1129]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1134, 1156]\\nExaminingPatient : [1163, 1179]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1548, 1566]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1636, 1654]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1603, 1625]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\ndomain size 15\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F685', 'F658', 'F176', 'F453', 'F465', 'F458', 'F657', 'F466', 'F46', 'F459', 'F445', 'F0', 'F447', 'F452', 'F456', 'F668', 'F448', 'F677', 'F134', 'F45', 'F680', 'F460', 'F154', 'F443', 'F454', 'F661', 'F451', 'F462', 'F664', 'F51', 'F159', 'F455', 'F671', 'F49', 'F684', 'F660', 'F675', 'F659', 'F136', 'F133', 'F681', 'F264', 'F461', 'F446', 'F23', 'F449', 'F444', 'F450', 'F553', 'F52', 'F457', 'F672', 'F670', 'F44', 'F665', 'F667', 'F676', 'F663', 'F40', 'F22', 'F679', 'F678', 'F666', 'F662', 'F669', 'F39', 'F155', 'F43']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3338, 3358]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3364, 3384]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3389, 3411]\\nExaminingPatient : [3418, 3434]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2879, 2897]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2967, 2985]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2934, 2956]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule20\", \"text\": \"Rule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:7bcb186725c612d3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, sev...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\nRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer unless ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:7bcb186725c612d3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, sev...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:53.574115","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved","id":62,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_Rule5","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule5\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_Rule5\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule5\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule Rule5 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nRule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=True, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted) and ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) and (informationAvailable and informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=True, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 18\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F708', 'F707', 'F162', 'F499', 'F718', 'F715', 'F46', 'F0', 'F724', 'F164', 'F414', 'F432', 'F425', 'F423', 'F518', 'F693', 'F428', 'F48', 'F54', 'F717', 'F47', 'F49', 'F699', 'F714', 'F419', 'F429', 'F716', 'F136', 'F698', 'F137', 'F696', 'F723', 'F431', 'F420', 'F710', 'F711', 'F23', 'F424', 'F42', 'F517', 'F416', 'F695', 'F52', 'F720', 'F243', 'F157', 'F139', 'F709', 'F158', 'F703', 'F413', 'F417', 'F415', 'F22', 'F418', 'F719', 'F700', 'F697', 'F422', 'F426', 'F430', 'F694', 'F427', 'F55', 'F702', 'F421', 'F43', 'F701']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=True, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1081, 1101]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1107, 1127]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1132, 1154]\\nExaminingPatient : [1161, 1177]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1546, 1564]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1634, 1652]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1601, 1623]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F708', 'F176', 'F453', 'F707', 'F706', 'F705', 'F465', 'F712', 'F704', 'F458', 'F466', 'F715', 'F46', 'F459', 'F445', 'F0', 'F724', 'F447', 'F452', 'F456', 'F721', 'F448', 'F722', 'F134', 'F45', 'F460', 'F154', 'F443', 'F733', 'F454', 'F451', 'F462', 'F51', 'F159', 'F455', 'F713', 'F49', 'F714', 'F716', 'F136', 'F133', 'F723', 'F264', 'F461', 'F446', 'F710', 'F711', 'F23', 'F449', 'F444', 'F450', 'F553', 'F52', 'F720', 'F457', 'F709', 'F44', 'F703', 'F40', 'F22', 'F719', 'F39', 'F732', 'F155', 'F702', 'F43', 'F725', 'F701']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=True, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=True, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=True, languagePreferenceAvailable=True, directlyToUser=True, userConsentAvalaible=True, guardianConsentAvalaible=True, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=True, genderTypeB=True, userNameUnknown=True, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=True, behaviorAggressive=True, dataNoiseConsidered=True, dataRelevantToContext=True, dataUnnecessary=True, trainingDataRepresentative=True, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=True, UserUnableToConsent=True)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=5, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3336, 3356]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3362, 3382]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3387, 3409]\\nExaminingPatient : [3416, 3432]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2877, 2895]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2965, 2983]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2932, 2954]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule20\", \"text\": \"Rule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:3d1748f30e548f1f\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, sev...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\nRule5 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:3d1748f30e548f1f\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=True, userDataInformed=True, userSensoryNeedsMet=True, urgentNeed=True, sev...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"339f1dd6f99749a0bd5c4a7c6c103e36","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule5","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:38:53.257401","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":61,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"trigger_refinement","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule19\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Narrow trigger context\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch narrows when rule Rule19 applies, so the rule fires only in the context relevant to the issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\n\\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 78.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 70.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the addition of the condition 'not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})' could introduce ambiguity regarding the specific circumstances under which 'not ExaminingPatient' applies.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 69.5}, \"ranking_score\": 69.5, \"rank\": 5}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\n\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\nRule19 when MeetingUser and ({patientXReligion} and (not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}))) then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 78.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 70.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the addition of the condition 'not ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})' could introduce ambiguity regarding the specific circumstances under which 'not ExaminingPatient' applies.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the proposed change is vague and does not clearly explain how the refinement addresses the situational conflict, making it harder for stakeholders to understand the intent.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 69.5}","ranking_score":69.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:14.254633","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":60,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"trigger_refinement","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Narrow trigger context\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch narrows when rule Rule18 applies, so the rule fires only in the context relevant to the issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 76.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a condition involving {patientXReligion} which is clear but may not be fully explained in the context of the existing rules.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 75.25}, \"ranking_score\": 75.25, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and (({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {patientXReligion})) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 76.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a condition involving {patientXReligion} which is clear but may not be fully explained in the context of the existing rules.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the change is vague and does not sufficiently clarify how the new condition affects the existing rules.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 75.25}","ranking_score":75.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:13.923724","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":59,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule19\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule19 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\n\\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 82.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces additional conditions that are specific and relevant to the context, enhancing clarity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 81.0}, \"ranking_score\": 81.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\n\tRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise} unless {medicalEmergency} unless ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered})\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 82.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces additional conditions that are specific and relevant to the context, enhancing clarity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the introduction of multiple conditions may require additional context for full understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 81.0}","ranking_score":81.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:13.572350","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":58,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d1\", \"patch_id\": \"d1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule18 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a clear condition that is consistent with existing concepts, enhancing specificity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 84.0}, \"ranking_score\": 84.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {patientXReligion}\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a clear condition that is consistent with existing concepts, enhancing specificity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the defeater is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the condition may require additional context for full stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 84.0}","ranking_score":84.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 6, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:13.240039","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint., target issue not fixed, introduced related issue on edited rule, introduced new WFI during regression","id":57,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"missing_element\": \"MeetingUserWithChild\", \"new_event\": \"MeetingUserWithChild\", \"new_measure\": \"MeetingUserWithChild\", \"new_capability\": \"MeetingUserWithChild\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event MeetingUser is specialized into MeetingUserWithChild to distinguish the context of examining a child patient.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": {\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F649', 'F48', 'F390', 'F593', 'F578', 'F577', 'F595', 'F397', 'F594', 'F591', 'F583', 'F581', 'F574', 'F579', 'F392', 'F407', 'F385', 'F401', 'F655', 'F164', 'F52', 'F162', 'F596', 'F49', 'F402', 'F136', 'F389', 'F388', 'F158', 'F387', 'F400', 'F592', 'F394', 'F391', 'F395', 'F386', 'F157', 'F0', 'F46', 'F47', 'F220', 'F587', 'F384', 'F408', 'F383', 'F597', 'F393', 'F23', 'F573', 'F399', 'F626', 'F396', 'F582', 'F576', 'F139', 'F648', 'F54', 'F580', 'F137', 'F398', 'F650', 'F22', 'F43', 'F588', 'F654', 'F575', 'F42', 'F55']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1103, 1123]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1129, 1149]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1154, 1176]\\nExaminingPatient : [1183, 1199]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1568, 1586]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1656, 1674]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1623, 1645]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F450', 'F445', 'F458', 'F456', 'F449', 'F448', 'F452', 'F462', 'F155', 'F45', 'F733', 'F712', 'F133', 'F711', 'F457', 'F455', 'F710', 'F713', 'F705', 'F706', 'F447', 'F716', 'F719', 'F461', 'F703', 'F721', 'F454', 'F52', 'F732', 'F49', 'F136', 'F465', 'F553', 'F0', 'F134', 'F46', 'F453', 'F443', 'F725', 'F176', 'F723', 'F51', 'F264', 'F39', 'F44', 'F23', 'F459', 'F707', 'F466', 'F451', 'F709', 'F704', 'F720', 'F446', 'F724', 'F708', 'F159', 'F701', 'F22', 'F715', 'F460', 'F43', 'F444', 'F40', 'F714', 'F702', 'F722', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3358, 3378]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3384, 3404]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3438, 3454]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2899, 2917]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2987, 3005]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2954, 2976]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F649', 'F48', 'F390', 'F593', 'F578', 'F577', 'F595', 'F397', 'F594', 'F591', 'F583', 'F581', 'F574', 'F579', 'F392', 'F407', 'F385', 'F401', 'F655', 'F164', 'F52', 'F162', 'F596', 'F49', 'F402', 'F136', 'F389', 'F388', 'F158', 'F387', 'F400', 'F592', 'F394', 'F391', 'F395', 'F386', 'F157', 'F0', 'F46', 'F47', 'F220', 'F587', 'F384', 'F408', 'F383', 'F597', 'F393', 'F23', 'F573', 'F399', 'F626', 'F396', 'F582', 'F576', 'F139', 'F648', 'F54', 'F580', 'F137', 'F398', 'F650', 'F22', 'F43', 'F588', 'F654', 'F575', 'F42', 'F55']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1103, 1123]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1129, 1149]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1154, 1176]\\nExaminingPatient : [1183, 1199]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1568, 1586]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1656, 1674]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1623, 1645]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F450', 'F445', 'F458', 'F456', 'F449', 'F448', 'F452', 'F462', 'F155', 'F45', 'F733', 'F712', 'F133', 'F711', 'F457', 'F455', 'F710', 'F713', 'F705', 'F706', 'F447', 'F716', 'F719', 'F461', 'F703', 'F721', 'F454', 'F52', 'F732', 'F49', 'F136', 'F465', 'F553', 'F0', 'F134', 'F46', 'F453', 'F443', 'F725', 'F176', 'F723', 'F51', 'F264', 'F39', 'F44', 'F23', 'F459', 'F707', 'F466', 'F451', 'F709', 'F704', 'F720', 'F446', 'F724', 'F708', 'F159', 'F701', 'F22', 'F715', 'F460', 'F43', 'F444', 'F40', 'F714', 'F702', 'F722', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3358, 3378]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3384, 3404]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3438, 3454]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2899, 2917]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2987, 3005]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2954, 2976]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule20\", \"text\": \"Rule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule4\", \"text\": \"Rule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\nunless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"MeetingUserWithChild\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): MeetingUserWithChild\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.009, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"patientageconsidered\", \"patientcomfortable\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"addresssirormadam\", \"addressusername\", \"askrepresentativeforconsent\", \"at\", \"backward\", \"bcr\", \"be\", \"because\", \"behavioraggressive\", \"blocked_examiningpatient\", \"blocked_not_examiningpatient\", \"bodypartinvolvedinexam\", \"callsupport\", \"cancallhuman\", \"canendsession\", \"checking\", \"checkunderstanding\", \"collectingtrainingdata\", \"collectpatientdata\", \"config\", \"confirmconsent\", \"conflict\", \"core\", \"culturalindicatora\", \"datanoiseconsidered\", \"datarelevanttocontext\", \"dataunnecessary\", \"detect\", \"detected\", \"determinethreshold\", \"directlytouser\", \"domain\", \"end\", \"ensurelegalpresence\", \"ensureprivatespace\", \"eventx\", \"examinationcontinuable\", \"examinestate\", \"f0\", \"f1039\", \"f1066\", \"f1067\", \"f1068\", \"f129\", \"f130\", \"f132\", \"f133\", \"f135\", \"f148\", \"f149\", \"f151\", \"f152\", \"f153\", \"f156\", \"f170\", \"f173\", \"f22\", \"f23\", \"f258\", \"f261\", \"f39\", \"f40\", \"f42\", \"f43\", \"f44\", \"f456\", \"f457\", \"f458\", \"f459\", \"f46\", \"f460\", \"f461\", \"f462\", \"f463\", \"f464\", \"f465\", \"f466\", \"f467\", \"f468\", \"f469\", \"f47\", \"f470\", \"f471\", \"f472\", \"f473\", \"f474\", \"f475\", \"f476\", \"f477\", \"f484\", \"f485\", \"f49\", \"f50\", \"f52\", \"f546\", \"f656\", \"f657\", \"f658\", \"f659\", \"f660\", \"f661\", \"f662\", \"f663\", \"f664\", \"f665\", \"f666\", \"f667\", \"f668\", \"f669\", \"f670\", \"f671\", \"f674\", \"f675\", \"f676\", \"f677\", \"f678\", \"f679\", \"f680\", \"f705\", \"f706\", \"f709\", \"f710\", \"f716\", \"f754\", \"f755\", \"f756\", \"f757\", \"f758\", \"f759\", \"f760\", \"f761\", \"f762\", \"f763\", \"f764\", \"f768\", \"f769\", \"f772\", \"f773\", \"f774\", \"f775\", \"f776\", \"f777\", \"f778\", \"f815\", \"f816\", \"f819\", \"f820\", \"f830\", \"find\", \"following\", \"for\", \"gendertypeb\", \"guardianconsentavalaible\", \"highlighted\", \"identifydaisytrust\", \"informationavailable\", \"informationdisclosurenotpermitted\", \"informdaisyabilities\", \"informuserandandrefertohumancarer\", \"instructionfail\", \"instructionrepeat\", \"languagepreferenceavailable\", \"measure\", \"medicalemergency\", \"meetinguser\", \"merged\", \"min\", \"not_approachpatient\", \"not_collectpatientdata\", \"not_examiningpatient\", \"notdisclosepersonalinformation\", \"nottouchunnecessarily\", \"obtainconsent\", \"of\", \"otherwise\", \"patientxreligion\", \"preparingexamination\", \"preparingtasks\", \"presentingreport\", \"provideconfidencelevel\", \"provideinfo\", \"refertohumanexaminer\", \"repeatinstruction\", \"requesthumanagent\", \"restart\", \"rule\", \"selectdaisyprotocol\", \"severityofstate\", \"situation\", \"situational\", \"size\", \"sleec\", \"solving\", \"speaking\", \"stablephysicalstate\", \"stablepsychologicalstate\", \"start\", \"the\", \"time\", \"timeelapsed\", \"to\", \"trace\", \"traindaisy\", \"trainingdatarepresentative\", \"ub\", \"under\", \"unsat\", \"urgentneed\", \"usechoicenlanguage\", \"usedefaultasenglish\", \"usepreferredname\", \"userage\", \"userconsentavalaible\", \"userdatainformed\", \"userdirectsotherwise\", \"usernameunknown\", \"userpayingattention\", \"userrequestinfo\", \"usersensoryneedsmet\", \"userunabletoconsent\", \"userunderstands\", \"vol\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: addresssirormadam, addressusername, askrepresentativeforconsent, at, backward, bcr, be, because, behavioraggressive, blocked_examiningpatient, blocked_not_examiningpatient, bodypartinvolvedinexam\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": false, \"issue_time_bounds\": [\"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\"], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): MeetingUserWithChild\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: addresssirormadam, addressusername, askrepresentativeforconsent, at, backward, bcr, be, because, behavioraggressive, blocked_examiningpatient, blocked_not_examiningpatient, bodypartinvolvedinexam\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": false, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint., target issue not fixed, introduced related issue on edited rule, introduced new WFI during regression\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'MeetingUserWithChild' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context of the interaction.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}, \"ranking_score\": 85.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\nevent MeetingUserWithChild\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 92.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'MeetingUserWithChild' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context of the interaction.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent but introduces a new event without sufficient context for its implications.\"], \"total_score\": 85.5}","ranking_score":85.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:8c06d8f1649689c3\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: MeetingUserWithChild() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"{\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUserWithChild then ( ((patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F649', 'F48', 'F390', 'F593', 'F578', 'F577', 'F595', 'F397', 'F594', 'F591', 'F583', 'F581', 'F574', 'F579', 'F392', 'F407', 'F385', 'F401', 'F655', 'F164', 'F52', 'F162', 'F596', 'F49', 'F402', 'F136', 'F389', 'F388', 'F158', 'F387', 'F400', 'F592', 'F394', 'F391', 'F395', 'F386', 'F157', 'F0', 'F46', 'F47', 'F220', 'F587', 'F384', 'F408', 'F383', 'F597', 'F393', 'F23', 'F573', 'F399', 'F626', 'F396', 'F582', 'F576', 'F139', 'F648', 'F54', 'F580', 'F137', 'F398', 'F650', 'F22', 'F43', 'F588', 'F654', 'F575', 'F42', 'F55']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [1103, 1123]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1129, 1149]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1154, 1176]\\nExaminingPatient : [1183, 1199]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1568, 1586]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1656, 1674]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1623, 1645]\\n : [-1, -1]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 8\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F450', 'F445', 'F458', 'F456', 'F449', 'F448', 'F452', 'F462', 'F155', 'F45', 'F733', 'F712', 'F133', 'F711', 'F457', 'F455', 'F710', 'F713', 'F705', 'F706', 'F447', 'F716', 'F719', 'F461', 'F703', 'F721', 'F454', 'F52', 'F732', 'F49', 'F136', 'F465', 'F553', 'F0', 'F134', 'F46', 'F453', 'F443', 'F725', 'F176', 'F723', 'F51', 'F264', 'F39', 'F44', 'F23', 'F459', 'F707', 'F466', 'F451', 'F709', 'F704', 'F720', 'F446', 'F724', 'F708', 'F159', 'F701', 'F22', 'F715', 'F460', 'F43', 'F444', 'F40', 'F714', 'F702', 'F722', 'F154']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=4, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=6, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=5, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: MeetingUserWithChild()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=7, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUserWithChild and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\nMeetingUserWithChild : [3358, 3378]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3384, 3404]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3438, 3454]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2899, 2917]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2987, 3005]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2954, 2976]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:12.884328","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved","id":56,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule19\", \"Rule18\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule18 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\", \"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": {\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 18\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F481', 'F700', 'F475', 'F722', 'F717', 'F705', 'F704', 'F703', 'F737', 'F706', 'F707', 'F696', 'F714', 'F709', 'F713', 'F553', 'F698', 'F719', 'F723', 'F468', 'F467', 'F50', 'F482', 'F797', 'F490', 'F42', 'F483', 'F796', 'F151', 'F699', 'F46', 'F736', 'F0', 'F478', 'F733', 'F708', 'F23', 'F133', 'F152', 'F718', 'F491', 'F489', 'F720', 'F472', 'F732', 'F135', 'F487', 'F701', 'F485', 'F261', 'F52', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F741', 'F697', 'F470', 'F721', 'F702', 'F156', 'F479', 'F173', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1086, 1106]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1111, 1133]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1164, 1182]\\nExaminingPatient : [1140, 1156]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1551, 1569]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1639, 1657]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1606, 1628]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F493', 'F465', 'F475', 'F788', 'F771', 'F774', 'F789', 'F786', 'F787', 'F778', 'F779', 'F777', 'F776', 'F772', 'F783', 'F784', 'F775', 'F826', 'F827', 'F830', 'F468', 'F780', 'F467', 'F40', 'F831', 'F482', 'F148', 'F768', 'F773', 'F484', 'F483', 'F769', 'F785', 'F767', 'F765', 'F766', 'F463', 'F153', 'F604', 'F44', 'F0', 'F478', 'F49', 'F23', 'F39', 'F170', 'F494', 'F472', 'F770', 'F487', 'F485', 'F130', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F470', 'F129', 'F464', 'F841', 'F479', 'F258', 'F149', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3325, 3345]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3350, 3372]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [3403, 3421]\\nExaminingPatient : [3379, 3395]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2849, 2867]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2937, 2955]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2904, 2926]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 18\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F481', 'F700', 'F475', 'F722', 'F717', 'F705', 'F704', 'F703', 'F737', 'F706', 'F707', 'F696', 'F714', 'F709', 'F713', 'F553', 'F698', 'F719', 'F723', 'F468', 'F467', 'F50', 'F482', 'F797', 'F490', 'F42', 'F483', 'F796', 'F151', 'F699', 'F46', 'F736', 'F0', 'F478', 'F733', 'F708', 'F23', 'F133', 'F152', 'F718', 'F491', 'F489', 'F720', 'F472', 'F732', 'F135', 'F487', 'F701', 'F485', 'F261', 'F52', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F741', 'F697', 'F470', 'F721', 'F702', 'F156', 'F479', 'F173', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1086, 1106]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1111, 1133]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1164, 1182]\\nExaminingPatient : [1140, 1156]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1551, 1569]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1639, 1657]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1606, 1628]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F493', 'F465', 'F475', 'F788', 'F771', 'F774', 'F789', 'F786', 'F787', 'F778', 'F779', 'F777', 'F776', 'F772', 'F783', 'F784', 'F775', 'F826', 'F827', 'F830', 'F468', 'F780', 'F467', 'F40', 'F831', 'F482', 'F148', 'F768', 'F773', 'F484', 'F483', 'F769', 'F785', 'F767', 'F765', 'F766', 'F463', 'F153', 'F604', 'F44', 'F0', 'F478', 'F49', 'F23', 'F39', 'F170', 'F494', 'F472', 'F770', 'F487', 'F485', 'F130', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F470', 'F129', 'F464', 'F841', 'F479', 'F258', 'F149', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3325, 3345]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3350, 3372]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [3403, 3421]\\nExaminingPatient : [3379, 3395]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2849, 2867]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2937, 2955]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2904, 2926]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 7}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:9b9d4c1a6202f4ea\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsycholo...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:9b9d4c1a6202f4ea\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsycholo...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"{\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not medicalEmergency) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 18\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F481', 'F700', 'F475', 'F722', 'F717', 'F705', 'F704', 'F703', 'F737', 'F706', 'F707', 'F696', 'F714', 'F709', 'F713', 'F553', 'F698', 'F719', 'F723', 'F468', 'F467', 'F50', 'F482', 'F797', 'F490', 'F42', 'F483', 'F796', 'F151', 'F699', 'F46', 'F736', 'F0', 'F478', 'F733', 'F708', 'F23', 'F133', 'F152', 'F718', 'F491', 'F489', 'F720', 'F472', 'F732', 'F135', 'F487', 'F701', 'F485', 'F261', 'F52', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F741', 'F697', 'F470', 'F721', 'F702', 'F156', 'F479', 'F173', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1086, 1106]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1111, 1133]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1164, 1182]\\nExaminingPatient : [1140, 1156]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1551, 1569]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1639, 1657]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1606, 1628]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F477', 'F476', 'F473', 'F474', 'F480', 'F469', 'F471', 'F486', 'F466', 'F493', 'F465', 'F475', 'F788', 'F771', 'F774', 'F789', 'F786', 'F787', 'F778', 'F779', 'F777', 'F776', 'F772', 'F783', 'F784', 'F775', 'F826', 'F827', 'F830', 'F468', 'F780', 'F467', 'F40', 'F831', 'F482', 'F148', 'F768', 'F773', 'F484', 'F483', 'F769', 'F785', 'F767', 'F765', 'F766', 'F463', 'F153', 'F604', 'F44', 'F0', 'F478', 'F49', 'F23', 'F39', 'F170', 'F494', 'F472', 'F770', 'F487', 'F485', 'F130', 'F132', 'F43', 'F488', 'F470', 'F129', 'F464', 'F841', 'F479', 'F258', 'F149', 'F22', 'F47']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=6, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=7, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=10, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=8, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3325, 3345]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3350, 3372]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [3403, 3421]\\nExaminingPatient : [3379, 3395]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2849, 2867]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2937, 2955]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2904, 2926]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:12.519013","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved","id":55,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_Rule19_to_Rule18\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule19\", \"Rule18\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"Rule18\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule Rule18 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient\", \"proposed_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from Rule19 onto Rule18 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": {\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F788', 'F830', 'F792', 'F790', 'F789', 'F787', 'F773', 'F771', 'F769', 'F777', 'F775', 'F776', 'F779', 'F774', 'F772', 'F778', 'F782', 'F770', 'F783', 'F479', 'F473', 'F133', 'F151', 'F152', 'F483', 'F486', 'F607', 'F135', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F52', 'F467', 'F781', 'F469', 'F43', 'F42', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F482', 'F472', 'F496', 'F481', 'F497', 'F491', 'F485', 'F23', 'F488', 'F490', 'F489', 'F22', 'F468', 'F50', 'F477', 'F46', 'F0', 'F480', 'F470', 'F261', 'F844', 'F829', 'F780', 'F791', 'F834', 'F173', 'F833', 'F475', 'F768', 'F156', 'F786']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1087, 1107]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1112, 1134]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1165, 1187]\\nExaminingPatient : [1141, 1157]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1556, 1574]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1644, 1662]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1611, 1633]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 16\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F773', 'F769', 'F774', 'F782', 'F717', 'F735', 'F727', 'F732', 'F721', 'F726', 'F715', 'F729', 'F770', 'F724', 'F728', 'F479', 'F473', 'F463', 'F483', 'F486', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F467', 'F464', 'F469', 'F43', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F44', 'F482', 'F472', 'F493', 'F485', 'F23', 'F49', 'F488', 'F718', 'F22', 'F468', 'F604', 'F484', 'F494', 'F130', 'F733', 'F720', 'F39', 'F149', 'F734', 'F737', 'F477', 'F40', 'F465', 'F738', 'F0', 'F736', 'F480', 'F470', 'F725', 'F258', 'F723', 'F129', 'F719', 'F170', 'F153', 'F714', 'F475', 'F716', 'F722', 'F148']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3331, 3351]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3356, 3378]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3385, 3401]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2855, 2873]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2943, 2961]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2910, 2932]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events\\n\\tevent MeetingPatient\\n\\tevent RobotStopSession\\n\\tevent UserEndSession\\n\\tevent AddressUserName\\n\\tevent UsePreferredName\\n\\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \\n\\tevent RequestHumanAgent\\n\\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\\n\\tevent Speaking\\n\\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\tevent InstructionFail\\n\\tevent RepeatInstruction\\n\\tevent CallSupport\\n\\tevent UserRequestInfo\\n\\tevent ProvideInfo\\n\\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingExamination\\n\\tevent ObtainConsent\\n\\tevent ConfirmConsent\\n\\tevent PreparingTasks\\n\\tevent CheckUnderstanding\\n\\tevent UserUnderstands\\n\\tevent MeetingUser\\n\\tevent ExamineState\\n\\tevent ExaminingPatient\\n\\tevent ExaminationContinuable \\n\\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \\n\\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tevent determineThreshold\\n\\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\tevent PresentingReport\\n\\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tevent CollectPatientData\\n\\tevent TrainDaisy\\n\\tevent CollectingTrainingData\\n\\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\\n\\tevent CanEndSession\\n\\tevent CanCallHuman\\n\\tevent ApproachPatient\\n\\n\\t// measures\\n\\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\\n\\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\\n\\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\\n\\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\\n\\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\\n\\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\\n\\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\\n\\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\\n\\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\\n\\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\\n\\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\\n\\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\\n\\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\\n\\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\\n\\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\\n\\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\\n\\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\\n\\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\\n\\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\\n\\n\\t// constants\\n\\tconstant legalAge = 18\\n\\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\\n\\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\n\\t\\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\n\\t\\t unless {directlyToUser}\\n\\t\\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\\n\\t\\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\\n\\n\\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\\n\\t\\t\\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\\n\\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\\n\\t\\t\\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\\n\\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\\n\\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \\n\\t\\t\\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\\n\\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\\n\\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\\n\\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\\n\\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\\n\\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {urgentNeed}\\n\\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\\n\\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\\n\\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\t then ExaminationContinuable\\n\\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\\n\\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\\n\\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\\n\\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\\n\\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\\n\\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\\n\\n\\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\\n\\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n\\n\\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n\\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\\n\\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\\n\\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\\n\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// privacy\\n\\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\n\\t// avoiding harm\\n\\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\n\\t// autonomy\\n\\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\n\\t// agency\\n\\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\\n\\t// safety (accuracy)\\n\\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\n\\t// safety\\n\\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\\n\\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\\n\\tp3 exists PresentingReport \\n\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\\n\\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\\n\\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\\n\\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\\n\\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\\n\\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\\n\\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \\n\\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\\n\\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [\"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\\nConcern is raised\", \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\", \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\\nConcern is raised\", \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\\nConcern is raised\", \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\\nConcern is raised\"], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\n\\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\"], \"situational_conflicts\": [\":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F788', 'F830', 'F792', 'F790', 'F789', 'F787', 'F773', 'F771', 'F769', 'F777', 'F775', 'F776', 'F779', 'F774', 'F772', 'F778', 'F782', 'F770', 'F783', 'F479', 'F473', 'F133', 'F151', 'F152', 'F483', 'F486', 'F607', 'F135', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F52', 'F467', 'F781', 'F469', 'F43', 'F42', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F482', 'F472', 'F496', 'F481', 'F497', 'F491', 'F485', 'F23', 'F488', 'F490', 'F489', 'F22', 'F468', 'F50', 'F477', 'F46', 'F0', 'F480', 'F470', 'F261', 'F844', 'F829', 'F780', 'F791', 'F834', 'F173', 'F833', 'F475', 'F768', 'F156', 'F786']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1087, 1107]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1112, 1134]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1165, 1187]\\nExaminingPatient : [1141, 1157]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1556, 1574]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1644, 1662]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1611, 1633]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 16\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F773', 'F769', 'F774', 'F782', 'F717', 'F735', 'F727', 'F732', 'F721', 'F726', 'F715', 'F729', 'F770', 'F724', 'F728', 'F479', 'F473', 'F463', 'F483', 'F486', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F467', 'F464', 'F469', 'F43', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F44', 'F482', 'F472', 'F493', 'F485', 'F23', 'F49', 'F488', 'F718', 'F22', 'F468', 'F604', 'F484', 'F494', 'F130', 'F733', 'F720', 'F39', 'F149', 'F734', 'F737', 'F477', 'F40', 'F465', 'F738', 'F0', 'F736', 'F480', 'F470', 'F725', 'F258', 'F723', 'F129', 'F719', 'F170', 'F153', 'F714', 'F475', 'F716', 'F722', 'F148']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3331, 3351]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3356, 3378]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3385, 3401]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2855, 2873]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2943, 2961]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2910, 2932]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\"], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[\"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"], [], [\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\"], [\"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\"], [\"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[\"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[\"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"]]}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c1\", \"text\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c2\", \"text\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c3\", \"text\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c5\", \"text\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\"}], [{\"role\": \"violated_concern\", \"kind\": \"concern\", \"id\": \"c6\", \"text\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\"}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[]]}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[], [], [], [], []], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\"}]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\"}, {\"role\": \"referenced\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\"}]]}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule5\", \"text\": \"Rule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\\nunless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted})\\nthen InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\", \"score\": 4}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule2\", \"text\": \"Rule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\\nunless {directlyToUser}\\nunless {userConsentAvalaible}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 3}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule10\", \"text\": \"Rule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule13\", \"text\": \"Rule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule17\", \"text\": \"Rule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}], [{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 2}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule18\", \"text\": \"Rule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 1}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule19\", \"text\": \"Rule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 1}]], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [[]], \"situational_conflicts\": [[{\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule3\", \"text\": \"Rule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\\nunless {medicalEmergency}\", \"score\": 9}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule16\", \"text\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\\nthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\", \"score\": 7}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule1\", \"text\": \"Rule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\\nunless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\\nunless {userDirectsOtherwise}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule12\", \"text\": \"Rule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\\nunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\", \"score\": 5}, {\"role\": \"inferred\", \"kind\": \"rule\", \"id\": \"Rule14\", \"text\": \"Rule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\", \"score\": 5}]]}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 26}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:c2d1d5bef25563d9\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsycholo...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"Target not fixed or related issue unresolved\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events\n\tevent MeetingPatient\n\tevent RobotStopSession\n\tevent UserEndSession\n\tevent AddressUserName\n\tevent UsePreferredName\n\tevent AddressSirOrMadam\n\tevent NotDisclosePersonalInformation \n\tevent RequestHumanAgent\n\tevent EventX // please specify an event that initiates the case.\n\tevent Speaking\n\tevent UseChoicenLanguage\n\tevent UseDefaultasEnglish\n\tevent InstructionFail\n\tevent RepeatInstruction\n\tevent CallSupport\n\tevent UserRequestInfo\n\tevent ProvideInfo\n\tevent InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\tevent AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tevent PreparingExamination\n\tevent ObtainConsent\n\tevent ConfirmConsent\n\tevent PreparingTasks\n\tevent CheckUnderstanding\n\tevent UserUnderstands\n\tevent MeetingUser\n\tevent ExamineState\n\tevent ExaminingPatient\n\tevent ExaminationContinuable \n\tevent EnsurePrivateSpace\n\tevent EnsureLegalPresence \n\tevent NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\tevent IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tevent determineThreshold\n\tevent selectDAISYProtocol\n\tevent ReferToHumanExaminer\n\tevent PresentingReport\n\tevent ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tevent CollectPatientData\n\tevent TrainDaisy\n\tevent CollectingTrainingData\n\tevent informDaisyAbilities // What Daisy can and cannot do\n\tevent CanEndSession\n\tevent CanCallHuman\n\tevent ApproachPatient\n\n\t// measures\n\tmeasure UserAge:numeric\n\tmeasure userPayingAttention:boolean\n\tmeasure userDataInformed:boolean\n\tmeasure userSensoryNeedsMet:boolean\n\tmeasure urgentNeed:boolean\n\tmeasure severityOfState:numeric\n\tmeasure stablePsychologicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure timeElapsed:numeric //minutes\n\tmeasure informationAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure informationDisclosureNotPermitted:boolean\n\tmeasure languagePreferenceAvailable:boolean\n\tmeasure directlyToUser:boolean\n\tmeasure userConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure guardianConsentAvalaible:boolean\n\tmeasure medicalEmergency:boolean\n\tmeasure culturalIndicatorA:boolean\n\tmeasure genderTypeB:boolean\n\tmeasure userNameUnknown:boolean\n\tmeasure userDirectsOtherwise:boolean\n\tmeasure instructionRepeat:numeric\n\tmeasure bodyPartInvolvedInExam:boolean\n\tmeasure behaviorAggressive:boolean\n\tmeasure dataNoiseConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure dataRelevantToContext:boolean\n\tmeasure dataUnnecessary:boolean\n\tmeasure trainingDataRepresentative:boolean\n\tmeasure patientComfortable:boolean\n\tmeasure patientAgeConsidered:boolean\n\tmeasure patientXReligion:boolean\n\tmeasure stablePhysicalState:boolean\n\tmeasure UserUnableToConsent:boolean\n\n\t// constants\n\tconstant legalAge = 18\n\tconstant StateThreshold = 100\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\t//address the user by their preferred name according to cultural type\n\tRule1 when AddressUserName then UsePreferredName\n\t\t unless {userNameUnknown} then AddressSirOrMadam\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule2 when ProvideInfo then NotDisclosePersonalInformation\n\t\t unless {directlyToUser}\n\t\t unless {userConsentAvalaible}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule3 when EventX and ({culturalIndicatorA} and {genderTypeB}) then RequestHumanAgent\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise} //here the user directs the otherwise for this specific case. should we have the same measures for this?\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule4 when Speaking then UseChoicenLanguage\n\t\t unless (not {languagePreferenceAvailable}) then UseDefaultasEnglish\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule5 when UserRequestInfo then ProvideInfo\n\t\t\t unless ((not {informationAvailable}) or {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) \n\t\t\t\t\t\t then InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer\n\n\tRule6 when InstructionFail then RepeatInstruction\n\t\t\t unless (({instructionRepeat} >= 3) or ({timeElapsed} > 20)) then CallSupport\n\tRule7 when PreparingExamination then ObtainConsent\n\t\t\t unless ((not {UserUnableToConsent}) or ({UserAge} < legalAge)) then AskRepresentativeForConsent\n\tRule8 when PreparingTasks then ConfirmConsent\n\tRule9 when CheckUnderstanding and (({userPayingAttention} and {userDataInformed}) \n\t\t\t and {userSensoryNeedsMet}) then UserUnderstands\n\t// Identify the user's physical and psychological states. Examine the severity of those states.\n\tRule10 when MeetingUser then ExamineState\n\t// If severity surpasses a certain threshold, avoid approaching them.\n\t// Ensure that they have no urgent medical needs that need to be taken care of\n\tRule10_1 when ExamineState and ({severityOfState} > StateThreshold) then not ApproachPatient\n\t\t unless {urgentNeed}\n\t// Examine if those states do not hinder the ability to consent and the reliability of the examination.\n\t// Ensure that they are in a psychological state that does not compromise data collection\n\tRule10_2 when ExamineState and ({stablePsychologicalState} and {stablePhysicalState}) \n\t\t\t\t\t then ExaminationContinuable\n\tRule11 when PreparingExamination then EnsurePrivateSpace\n\t\t\t\tunless ({UserAge} < legalAge) then EnsureLegalPresence\n\tRule12 when ExaminingPatient then NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t\t\t\tunless {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}\n\tRule13 when MeetingUser then IdentifyDAISYTrust\n\tRule13_1 when IdentifyDAISYTrust then determineThreshold\n\tRule13_2 when determineThreshold then selectDAISYProtocol\n\tRule14 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then ReferToHumanExaminer\n\n\tRule15 when PresentingReport and {dataNoiseConsidered} then ProvideConfidenceLevel\n\tRule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary}))\n\tthen CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData\n\n\tRule17 when CollectingTrainingData and {trainingDataRepresentative} then TrainDaisy\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\tRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\n\t\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\n\t\t unless {medicalEmergency}\n\tRule20 when MeetingUser then informDaisyAbilities\n\tRule21 when ExaminingPatient then CanEndSession\n\tRule21_1 when ExaminingPatient then CanCallHuman\n\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// privacy\n\tc1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo\n\t// avoiding harm\n\tc2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession\n\t// autonomy\n\tc3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient\n\t// agency\n\tc4 when ExaminingPatient and (not {bodyPartInvolvedInExam}) then not NotTouchUnnecessarily\n\t// safety (accuracy)\n\tc5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport\n\t// safety\n\tc6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\t// Daisy must be able to approach children.\n\tp1 exists ApproachPatient and (not {patientAgeConsidered})\n\t// Daisy must be able to refer a patient to a human examiner.\n p2 exists ReferToHumanExaminer and (not {stablePsychologicalState})\n\t// Daisy must be able to present a diagnostic report.\n\tp3 exists PresentingReport \n\n\t// Daisy must be able to call for support when facing an emergency.\n\tp4_1 exists CallSupport and {urgentNeed}\n\tp4_2 exists CallSupport and {medicalEmergency}\n\t// Daisy must be able to provide information to the patient.\n\tp5 exists ProvideInfo and {informationAvailable}\n\t// Daisy must be able to examine the patient.\n\tp6 exists ExaminingPatient \n\t// Daisy must be able to select the right protocol.\n\tp7 exists selectDAISYProtocol \n\t// Daisy must be able to collect patient data.\n\tp8 exists CollectPatientData and (not {dataUnnecessary})\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": false, \"new_issues_introduced\": true, \"regression_passed\": false, \"before_issue_count\": 7, \"after_issue_count\": 7, \"new_issue_count\": 1, \"resolved_issue_count\": 1, \"remaining_issue_count\": 6, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 5, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"new_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:c2d1d5bef25563d9\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsycholo...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:951c2b2df9a0ea95\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: MeetingUser() at time 0: informDaisyAbilities() at time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychol...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule18\", \"Rule19\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40d371fcea7507a1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when MeetingUser and (not {trainingDataRepresentative}) then not CallSupport Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:5b2a44c8026f6606\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c3 when MeetingPatient and ((not {patientComfortable}) or ((not {patientAgeConsidered}) and (not {guardianConsentAvalaible}))) then ExaminingPatient Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:82dc76df424d9328\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when ExaminingPatient and {behaviorAggressive} then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:c252e2e4ec60f518\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when UserRequestInfo and ({informationAvailable} and {informationDisclosureNotPermitted}) then ProvideInfo Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:eee36fd2fc0e5a5d\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when UserEndSession then not RobotStopSession Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:cdf5f54e2efa3d1d\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"Rule16 when ExaminingPatient and ({dataRelevantToContext} and (not {dataUnnecessary})) then CollectPatientData otherwise not CollectPatientData ----------------------------------------------------------------------------...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"Rule16\"]}]}","related_issue_json":"{\"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"issue\": \":\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nwhen IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nwhen determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nwhen CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nwhen MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nwhen ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and userNameUnknown) => AddressSirOrMadam within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when AddressUserName then ( (((not userNameUnknown) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UsePreferredName within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ProvideInfo then ( (((not directlyToUser) and ((not userConsentAvalaible) and (not medicalEmergency))) => NotDisclosePersonalInformation within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when EventX then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and (culturalIndicatorA and genderTypeB))) => RequestHumanAgent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) => UseDefaultasEnglish within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when Speaking then ( (((not (not languagePreferenceAvailable)) and (not userDirectsOtherwise)) => UseChoicenLanguage within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( (((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted) => InformUserandandReferToHumanCarer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when UserRequestInfo then ( ((not ((not informationAvailable) or informationDisclosureNotPermitted)) => ProvideInfo within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( (((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20)) => CallSupport within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when InstructionFail then ( ((not ((instructionRepeat >= 3) or (timeElapsed > 20))) => RepeatInstruction within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( (((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18)) => AskRepresentativeForConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not ((not UserUnableToConsent) or (UserAge < 18))) => ObtainConsent within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingTasks then ( ConfirmConsent within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when CheckUnderstanding then ( (((userPayingAttention and userDataInformed) and userSensoryNeedsMet) => UserUnderstands within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( ExamineState within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( (((not urgentNeed) and (severityOfState > 100)) => not_ApproachPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExamineState then ( ((stablePsychologicalState and stablePhysicalState) => ExaminationContinuable within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((UserAge < 18) => EnsureLegalPresence within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PreparingExamination then ( ((not (UserAge < 18)) => EnsurePrivateSpace within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((not bodyPartInvolvedInExam) => NotTouchUnnecessarily within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( IdentifyDAISYTrust within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when IdentifyDAISYTrust then ( determineThreshold within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when determineThreshold then ( selectDAISYProtocol within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( (behaviorAggressive => ReferToHumanExaminer within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when PresentingReport then ( (dataNoiseConsidered => ProvideConfidenceLevel within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( ((dataRelevantToContext and (not dataUnnecessary)) => CollectPatientData within 0 seconds) otherwise not_CollectPatientData within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 5\\nunsat\\nchecking when CollectingTrainingData then ( (trainingDataRepresentative => TrainDaisy within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and (patientComfortable and patientAgeConsidered)) => ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 17\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F788', 'F830', 'F792', 'F790', 'F789', 'F787', 'F773', 'F771', 'F769', 'F777', 'F775', 'F776', 'F779', 'F774', 'F772', 'F778', 'F782', 'F770', 'F783', 'F479', 'F473', 'F133', 'F151', 'F152', 'F483', 'F486', 'F607', 'F135', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F52', 'F467', 'F781', 'F469', 'F43', 'F42', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F482', 'F472', 'F496', 'F481', 'F497', 'F491', 'F485', 'F23', 'F488', 'F490', 'F489', 'F22', 'F468', 'F50', 'F477', 'F46', 'F0', 'F480', 'F470', 'F261', 'F844', 'F829', 'F780', 'F791', 'F834', 'F173', 'F833', 'F475', 'F768', 'F156', 'F786']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [1087, 1107]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [1112, 1134]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1165, 1187]\\nExaminingPatient : [1141, 1157]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [1556, 1574]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [1644, 1662]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [1611, 1633]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( (((not userDirectsOtherwise) and ((not medicalEmergency) and patientXReligion)) => not_ExaminingPatient within 0 seconds) )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nfind trace\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\nvol: 7\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\nmerged\\nmerged\\ndomain size 16\\nunsat\\ndetect conflict, and start backward checking\\n['F773', 'F769', 'F774', 'F782', 'F717', 'F735', 'F727', 'F732', 'F721', 'F726', 'F715', 'F729', 'F770', 'F724', 'F728', 'F479', 'F473', 'F463', 'F483', 'F486', 'F487', 'F471', 'F132', 'F466', 'F474', 'F467', 'F464', 'F469', 'F43', 'F476', 'F47', 'F478', 'F44', 'F482', 'F472', 'F493', 'F485', 'F23', 'F49', 'F488', 'F718', 'F22', 'F468', 'F604', 'F484', 'F494', 'F130', 'F733', 'F720', 'F39', 'F149', 'F734', 'F737', 'F477', 'F40', 'F465', 'F738', 'F0', 'F736', 'F480', 'F470', 'F725', 'F258', 'F723', 'F129', 'F719', 'F170', 'F153', 'F714', 'F475', 'F716', 'F722', 'F148']\\nConflict detected, start backward checking\\nUNSAT CORE\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=8, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nSituational conflict under situation :\\nat time 0: MeetingUser()\\nat time 0: informDaisyAbilities()\\nat time 0: Measure(UserAge=11, userPayingAttention=False, userDataInformed=False, userSensoryNeedsMet=False, urgentNeed=False, severityOfState=0, stablePsychologicalState=False, timeElapsed=10, informationAvailable=False, informationDisclosureNotPermitted=False, languagePreferenceAvailable=False, directlyToUser=False, userConsentAvalaible=False, guardianConsentAvalaible=False, medicalEmergency=False, culturalIndicatorA=False, genderTypeB=False, userNameUnknown=False, userDirectsOtherwise=False, instructionRepeat=9, bodyPartInvolvedInExam=False, behaviorAggressive=False, dataNoiseConsidered=False, dataRelevantToContext=False, dataUnnecessary=False, trainingDataRepresentative=False, patientComfortable=True, patientAgeConsidered=True, patientXReligion=True, stablePhysicalState=False, UserUnableToConsent=False)\\nat time 0: blocked_not_ExaminingPatient(end=0)\\nat time 1: ExamineState()\\nat time 1: ExaminingPatient()\\nat time 1: IdentifyDAISYTrust()\\n\\nFor rule:\\nRule19 when MeetingUser and {patientXReligion} then not ExaminingPatient\\n\\t\\t unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n\\t\\t unless {medicalEmergency}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nBecause of the following SLEEC rule:\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\nRule18 when MeetingUser and ({patientComfortable} and {patientAgeConsidered}) then ExaminingPatient unless {userDirectsOtherwise}\\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\\nTO BE HIGHLIGHTED\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientComfortable} : [3331, 3351]\\n{patientAgeConsidered} : [3356, 3378]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [3409, 3431]\\nExaminingPatient : [3385, 3401]\\n : [-1, -1]\\n{patientXReligion} : [2855, 2873]\\n{medicalEmergency} : [2943, 2961]\\n{userDirectsOtherwise} : [2910, 2932]\\nchecking when MeetingUser then ( informDaisyAbilities within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanEndSession within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\\nchecking when ExaminingPatient then ( CanCallHuman within 0 seconds )\\nsolving under config: restart False, bcr False, ub False, min False\\ndomain size 3\\nunsat\", \"related_rule\": \"Rule18\"}","run_id":"c5fe9c87e32840129bde22f76255b387","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"Rule18","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:35:12.124434","use_case":"DAISY","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":54,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R23","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R23\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R23\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R23 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R23 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 35}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and directly addresses redundancy without introducing new concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and directly addresses redundancy without introducing new concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:41.552629","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'; LLM syntax repair failed: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 1 column 12867 (char 12866)","id":53,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\", \"new_event\": \"not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\", \"new_measure\": \"not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\", \"new_capability\": \"not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\", \"new_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly states the reason for not recording, which is the lack of consent.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\nevent not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\nR23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'; LLM syntax repair failed: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 1 column 12867 (char 12866)\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses a specific term 'RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent' which clarifies the reason for not recording, aligning with existing concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}, \"ranking_score\": 86.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses a specific term 'RecordPeopleDueToLackOfConsent' which clarifies the reason for not recording, aligning with existing concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the context of how this refinement affects other rules is not fully explained, which may lead to ambiguity.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}","ranking_score":86.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:41.201960","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"","id":52,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"new_event\": \"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"new_measure\": \"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"new_capability\": \"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"new_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithNoConsent to clarify the context in which recording people is not allowed.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 36}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"SystemReadyWithNoConsent\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): SystemReadyWithNoConsent\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": true, \"context_coverage\": 0.5, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"peopleconsentobtained\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"systemready\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: systemready\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): SystemReadyWithNoConsent\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: systemready\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": true, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": true, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\nevent SystemReadyWithNoConsent\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\nR23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": true, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The new event 'SystemReadyWithNoConsent' is specific and unambiguous, clarifying the context for not recording people.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}, \"ranking_score\": 86.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent SystemReadyWithNoConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReadyWithNoConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The new event 'SystemReadyWithNoConsent' is specific and unambiguous, clarifying the context for not recording people.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the relationship between the new event and the original rule could be more explicitly stated to enhance understanding.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}","ranking_score":86.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:40.877321","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":51,"issue_id":"redundancies_2","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"defeater_propagation","patch_id":"d_propagate_R23","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_propagate_R23\", \"patch_id\": \"d_propagate_R23\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R23\", \"operation\": \"defeater_propagation\", \"operation_label\": \"Carry exception forward\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R23 by carrying an existing exception into the repaired rule so the same priority condition is preserved.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the defeater of R23 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\nR23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 36}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the action change could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining consistency with domain meanings.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the action change could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the action change could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR23 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining consistency with domain meanings.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the action change could be more explicitly stated.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the action change could be more explicitly stated.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"86306f831adf499da5d4afd0bbf7d5e1","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R23","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:26:40.536015","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":50,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R22\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R22 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R22 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 35}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 100.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and directly addresses redundancy without introducing new concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}, \"ranking_score\": 50.0, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 0, \"logical_simplicity\": 0, \"semantic_clarity\": 100.0, \"interpretability\": 100.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule removal is clear and directly addresses redundancy without introducing new concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for removing the rule is straightforward and aligns with stakeholder intent, minimizing ambiguity.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 50.0}","ranking_score":50.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:25.450768","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'; LLM syntax repair failed: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 1 column 12199 (char 12198)","id":49,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\", \"new_event\": \"not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\", \"new_measure\": \"not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\", \"new_capability\": \"not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\", \"new_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad capability of not recording people is refined into a more specific capability that explicitly requires user consent to avoid redundancy in the rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\nevent not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'; LLM syntax repair failed: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 1 column 12199 (char 12198)\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:76:11: Expected 'event' or 'measure' or 'constant' or 'def_end' => 'event not *RecordPeop'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the requirement for user consent, enhancing clarity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}, \"ranking_score\": 86.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the requirement for user consent, enhancing clarity without introducing ambiguity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is provided, the phrase 'not RecordPeopleUnlessUserConsents' could be misinterpreted without explicit context on how user consent is obtained.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}","ranking_score":86.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:25.111962","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"","id":48,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"new_event\": \"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"new_measure\": \"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"new_capability\": \"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"new_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event SystemReady is specialized into SystemReadyWithUserConsent to ensure that recording people only occurs when user consent is explicitly obtained.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 36}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"SystemReadyWithUserConsent\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): SystemReadyWithUserConsent\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": true, \"context_coverage\": 0.5, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"peopleconsentobtained\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"systemready\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: systemready\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"issue_time_bounds\": [], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): SystemReadyWithUserConsent\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: systemready\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": true, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": true, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\nevent SystemReadyWithUserConsent\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": true, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'SystemReadyWithUserConsent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the condition under which recording people is permitted.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}, \"ranking_score\": 86.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\nevent SystemReadyWithUserConsent\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReadyWithUserConsent then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The term 'SystemReadyWithUserConsent' is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the condition under which recording people is permitted.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the change reflects stakeholder intent regarding user consent, the rationale could be clearer about the implications of this new condition.\"], \"total_score\": 86.0}","ranking_score":86.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:24.778506","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":47,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"defeater_propagation","patch_id":"d_propagate_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_propagate_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_propagate_R22\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"defeater_propagation\", \"operation_label\": \"Carry exception forward\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R22 by carrying an existing exception into the repaired rule so the same priority condition is preserved.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the defeater of R22 into its trigger so the rule is explicit about when it applies.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 36}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the explicit context of the action change could be better clarified.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining consistency with domain meanings.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the explicit context of the action change could be better clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the explicit context of the action change could be better clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining consistency with domain meanings.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the explicit context of the action change could be better clarified.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the explicit context of the action change could be better clarified.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"65b3ece53e344617abbc68816c392819","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:25:24.437570","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":46,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the car is driving and consent from people is not obtained, the system records the people present.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 80.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 90.0}, \"ranking_score\": 90.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 80.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of 'peopleConsentObtained' could be more explicitly linked to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 90.0}","ranking_score":90.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"3447fe0a973d4619850c563dfb05b818","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:21.166002","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":45,"issue_id":"concerns_7","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R_new","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R_new\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R_new\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R_new into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 36}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of the concern regarding 'ChangeSpeed' could be more explicitly linked to the proposed rules.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity in the context of the autonomous driving system.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of the concern regarding 'ChangeSpeed' could be more explicitly linked to the proposed rules.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of the concern regarding 'ChangeSpeed' could be more explicitly linked to the proposed rules.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new_1 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new_2 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, maintaining specificity and unambiguity in the context of the autonomous driving system.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of the concern regarding 'ChangeSpeed' could be more explicitly linked to the proposed rules.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule decomposition is understandable, but the context of the concern regarding 'ChangeSpeed' could be more explicitly linked to the proposed rules.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"3447fe0a973d4619850c563dfb05b818","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:24:20.828430","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":44,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they have not confirmed their readiness to drive, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and addresses a specific user readiness concern.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and addresses a specific user readiness concern.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the context of user readiness could be more explicitly linked to the overall driving safety framework.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"4a65aae7f15846e8bff542fff56e0b4b","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:21:39.429313","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":43,"issue_id":"concerns_6","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors R1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\nR1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\nR1_1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\nR1_2 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"4a65aae7f15846e8bff542fff56e0b4b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:21:39.074514","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'; LLM syntax repair failed: Invalid control character at: line 1 column 9884 (char 9883)","id":42,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that people are recorded when the car is driving and consent has not been obtained, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'; LLM syntax repair failed: Invalid control character at: line 1 column 9884 (char 9883)\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of recording people.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, ensuring that the intent to record people when consent is not obtained is well-defined.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of recording people.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of recording people.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, ensuring that the intent to record people when consent is not obtained is well-defined.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of recording people.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder concerns, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of recording people.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:28.909511","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":41,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R22\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R22 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22_1 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR22_2 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:28.552767","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":40,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R22\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R22 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} unless (not {peopleConsentObtained})\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:28.210330","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":39,"issue_id":"concerns_5","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R22","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R22\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R22\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R22\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R22 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\nR22 when SystemReady and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"8323371309c2439f93de5d849eacac9b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R22","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:16:27.844018","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":38,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user if they are not ready to drive when the system is ready, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and addresses a specific user readiness scenario.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {userSaysYes}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and addresses a specific user readiness scenario.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the change in context from multiple conditions to a single user response may confuse stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:28.646961","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":37,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R19","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R19\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R19\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R19 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\nR19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\nR19_1 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\nR19_2 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not (not {userSaysYes}))) then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:28.281732","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":36,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R19","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R19\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R19\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R19 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\nR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\nR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving unless (not {userSaysYes})\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:27.908707","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":35,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R19","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R19\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R19\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R19\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R19 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\nR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\nR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and ({userSaysYes} and (not {userSaysYes})) then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"0b37ecd80b3b43dfad6a3652e3722ba6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R19","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:15:27.556349","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":34,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, ensuring user awareness before driving.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the change.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and unambiguously, focusing on critical safety conditions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 88.75}, \"ranking_score\": 88.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts clearly and unambiguously, focusing on critical safety conditions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 88.75}","ranking_score":88.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:54.809935","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":33,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R17 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:54.469022","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":32,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R17 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:54.096038","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":31,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R17 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:135:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"844b621d3490444380e06b0bc744517a","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:10:53.735995","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'; LLM syntax repair failed: Invalid control character at: line 1 column 9638 (char 9637)","id":30,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent changing the current driving state when the system is ready but the action is not legal.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'; LLM syntax repair failed: Invalid control character at: line 1 column 9638 (char 9637)\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'SystemReady' and 'actionIsLegal', making it clear and specific in its intent to prevent illegal actions when the system is ready.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 90.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts like 'SystemReady' and 'actionIsLegal', making it clear and specific in its intent to prevent illegal actions when the system is ready.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is generally understandable, the context of what constitutes 'not legal' could benefit from further clarification to ensure stakeholder intent is fully preserved.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:58.183034","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":29,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R2 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\nR2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:137:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\nR2_1 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\nR2_2 when SystemReady and (not (not {actionIsLegal})) then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:57.816599","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":28,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R2 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\nR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\nR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:57.440312","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":27,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R2\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R2 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\nR2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\nR2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"26944940928a440eaa3867ba537ade64","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R2","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:08:57.049932","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":26,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R17 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 28}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 50.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 69.25, \"logical_simplicity\": 5.25, \"semantic_clarity\": 60.0, \"interpretability\": 50.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces complex logical conditions that may confuse the intended meaning, particularly with the nested negations.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 46.12}, \"ranking_score\": 46.12, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17_1 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\nR17_2 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and (not ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 69.25, \"logical_simplicity\": 5.25, \"semantic_clarity\": 60.0, \"interpretability\": 50.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces complex logical conditions that may confuse the intended meaning, particularly with the nested negations.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Adds structural complexity that should be reviewed.\", \"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is vague, and the context of the new conditions is not clearly explained, making it difficult to understand stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 46.12}","ranking_score":46.12,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:01.846646","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":25,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R17 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 72.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 10.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the specific triggering circumstances.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 53.25}, \"ranking_score\": 53.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and ((not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 72.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 10.5, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, but the nested conditions may introduce ambiguity regarding the specific triggering circumstances.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The rationale for the changes is not fully explained, making it difficult to understand the intent behind the additional conditions.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 53.25}","ranking_score":53.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:01.472863","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":24,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R17","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R17\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R17 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\nR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 27}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 60.0, \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 71.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 22.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the introduction of the condition involving 'userSaysYes' could lead to ambiguity regarding user intent and system response.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 55.88}, \"ranking_score\": 55.88, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\nR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists})) then DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive unless ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists})))\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 71.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 22.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 70.0, \"interpretability\": 60.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule reuses existing concepts effectively, but the introduction of the condition involving 'userSaysYes' could lead to ambiguity regarding user intent and system response.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\", \"interpretability_passed\": false, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Uses a more complex condition with several logical parts.\", \"May contain a concept that needs clearer domain wording.\", \"The addition of the 'unless' clause introduces complexity that may obscure the original intent of the rule, making it less clear how the system should respond in certain scenarios.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 55.88}","ranking_score":55.88,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 9, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 9, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 7, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 2, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:08083e8ab7598a37\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:33299d30c978a526\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:40a6b2b259f00be6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:61f7d0d0e8536b5f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:d6279cfd6866e42f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dbefba1743157fc7\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:dff3efe83e13023f\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:522b6d5cd1e346ad\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R23\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:ea5c195529574ca1\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople unless {peopleConsentObtained} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R22\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:01.103839","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'","id":23,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R_new\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review priority-sensitive emergency behavior.\", \"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to alert the user when the system is ready but critical safety conditions are not met, specifically when the door is not closed and the seatbelt is not on.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n\\t// Events before driving starts\\n\\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\\n\\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\\n\\tevent TurnOnSensors\\n\\tevent TurnOffSensors\\n\\tevent CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tevent SystemReady\\n\\tevent TakeUserInput\\n\\tevent CalculateShortestPath\\n\\tevent ReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\tevent DisplayCarInformation\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tevent CarDriving\\n\\tevent SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n\\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n\\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n\\tevent ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n\\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n\\tevent DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n\\tevent DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n\\tevent DisplayRoute\\n\\tevent ChangeSpeed\\n\\tevent ChangeLanes\\n\\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tevent TakeNewInput\\n\\tevent TakeShortestPath\\n\\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tevent StayCenteredinLane\\n\\tevent SeeTrafficLight\\n\\tevent WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tevent RecordPeople\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\tevent UserChangeRoute\\n\\tevent UserCancelPath\\n\\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\\n\\tevent AskForClarification\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\\n\\tevent MakeSpace\\t\\t\\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\\n\\n\\t// Measures before driving starts\\n\\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\\n\\t// Events during driving\\n\\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\\t\\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\\n\\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\\t\\t// Moving thing in front\\n\\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\\n\\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\\n\\t// User requests related\\n\\n\\t// Priority vehicle related\\n\\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\\n\\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\\n\\n\\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\\n\\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\\n\\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\\t\\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\\n\\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\\n\\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\\n\\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\\n\\tmeasure redLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\\n\\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\\n\\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\\n\\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\\n\\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\\n\\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\\n\\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\\n\\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\\n\\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\\n\\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\n\\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\\n\\t\\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\\n\\t\\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\n\\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\\n\\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\\n\\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\\n\\t//invalid rules\\n\\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\\n then ChangeLanes\\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\\n\\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\\n\\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\\n\\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\\n\\t\\tthen ChangeLanes\\n\\t\\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\\n\\t\\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t\\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\\n\\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\t\\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\\n\\t\\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\\n\\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\\n\\t\\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\\n\\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\\n\\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\\n\\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\\n\\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\\n\\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n\\n\\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\\n\\n\\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\\n\\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \\n\\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\\n\\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\\n\\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\\n\\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\\n\\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n\\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\\n\\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\\n\\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\\n\\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\\n\\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\\n\\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\\n\\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\n\\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\\n\\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\\n\\t// Emergency vehicle related\\n\\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\\n\\n\\n\\n\\n\\t//autonomy\\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\\n\\n //privacy\\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\\nconcern_end\\n\\npurpose_start\\n\\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\\n pr6 exists SystemReady\\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\\n // Events during driving\\n pr13 exists CarDriving\\n pr14 exists SlowDown\\t\\t\\t// But not stop completely\\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\\t\\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\\t\\t// On road shoulder or parking area\\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\\n pr18 exists DisplayError\\t\\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \\t\\t// Alert is external, includes information\\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\\n // User requests related\\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\\n // Priority vehicle related\\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\\n\\n // Safely transport user from A to B\\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\\n // Maintain user autonomy\\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\\n // Enable user freedom of movement\\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:136:46: Expected ')' => 'orClosed} *and not {s'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the alert.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions for alerting the user, making it unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the alert.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the alert.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 88.75}, \"ranking_score\": 88.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n\t// Events before driving starts\n\tevent UserTurnOnSystem\n\tevent UserTurnOffSystem\n\tevent TurnOnSensors\n\tevent TurnOffSensors\n\tevent CheckSystemComponents\n\tevent SystemReady\n\tevent TakeUserInput\n\tevent CalculateShortestPath\n\tevent ReadyToDrive\n\tevent GetReadyToDrive\n\tevent AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\tevent DisplayCarInformation\n\t// Events during driving\n\tevent CarDriving\n\tevent SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n\tevent TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n\tevent TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n\tevent ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n\t// Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n\tevent DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n\tevent DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n\tevent DisplayRoute\n\tevent ChangeSpeed\n\tevent ChangeLanes\n\tevent ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tevent TakeNewInput\n\tevent TakeShortestPath\n\tevent MaintainEqualDistance\n\tevent StayCenteredinLane\n\tevent SeeTrafficLight\n\tevent WaitUntilChanges\n\tevent RecordPeople\n\t// User requests related\n\tevent UserChangeRoute\n\tevent UserCancelPath\n\tevent UserRequestSpeedChange\n\tevent AskForClarification\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tevent PriorityVehicleNearby\n\tevent MakeSpace\t\t\t// Such as emergency corridor or use the shoulder\n\n\t// Measures before driving starts\n\tmeasure destinationExists: boolean\n\tmeasure pathExists: boolean\n\t// Events during driving\n\tmeasure objectInPath: boolean\t\t// Sth in front of car, i.e pedestrian, animal, stationary vehicle\n\tmeasure carsInFront: boolean\t\t// Moving thing in front\n\tmeasure carsBehind: boolean\n\tmeasure actionIsLegal: boolean\n\t// User requests related\n\n\t// Priority vehicle related\n\tmeasure userRequestedLaneChange: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceBehindCar: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceOnOppositeSide: boolean\n\tmeasure ambulanceNextToCar: boolean\n\n\tmeasure environmentClear: boolean\t// Other moving vehicles on road, either next to, in front, behind\n\tmeasure riskLevel: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure withinLane: boolean\n\tmeasure multipleLanes: boolean\t\t// Whether 1 lane or multiple\n\tmeasure commandClear: boolean\n\tmeasure laneExists: boolean\n\tmeasure userTurnedOffSystem: boolean\n\tmeasure recognizeInput: boolean\n\tmeasure redLight: boolean\n\tmeasure yellowLight: boolean\n\tmeasure greenLight: boolean\n\tmeasure previousLight: scale(red, yellow, green)\n\tmeasure doorClosed: boolean\n\tmeasure seatBeltOn: boolean\n\tmeasure userSaysYes: boolean\n\tmeasure peopleConsentObtained: boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOnSensors\n\tR1_cont when TurnOnSensors then CheckSystemComponents\n\tR2 when SystemReady then TakeUserInput\n\tR3 when TakeUserInput then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then DisplayError\n\tR3_cont when CalculateShortestPath then DisplayRoute\n\tR4 when UserRequestSpeedChange and {environmentClear} then ChangeSpeed\n unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\n\tR5 when UserChangeRoute then CalculateShortestPath\n\t\tunless (not {commandClear}) then AskForClarification\n\t\totherwise not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\n\tR6 when UserCancelPath then ParkVehicle\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR7 when CarDriving and ({carsInFront} and {carsBehind}) then MaintainEqualDistance\n\tR8 when CarDriving and {objectInPath} then TemporarilyStopCar\n\tunless ({riskLevel} > low) then ChangeLanes\n\tunless (not {multipleLanes}) then TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop\n unless (not {objectInPath}) then CarDriving\n\t//invalid rules\n\tR9 when CarDriving and {withinLane} then StayCenteredinLane\n unless ({userRequestedLaneChange} and ({environmentClear} and ({riskLevel} = low)))\n then ChangeLanes\n unless ((not {withinLane}) or (not {laneExists})) then DisplayAlert\n\tR10 when UserTurnOffSystem then ParkVehicle\n\tR10_1 when ParkVehicle and {userTurnedOffSystem} then TurnOffSensors\n\tR11 when PriorityVehicleNearby then DisplayAlert\n\tR12 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and (not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}))\n\t\tthen ChangeLanes\n\t\tunless ({ambulanceNextToCar} or (not {multipleLanes})) then MakeSpace\n\t\tunless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\tR13 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then TemporarilyStopCar\n\t\tunless (not {redLight}) then TakeNewInput // unless is being used as an \u2018until\u2019 here\n\tR14 when SeeTrafficLight and ({yellowLight} and {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\t\tunless (not {yellowLight}) then TakeNewInput\n\t\tunless ({previousLight} = red) then GetReadyToDrive\n\tR15 when SeeTrafficLight and ({greenLight} and {recognizeInput}) then CarDriving\n\t\tunless {objectInPath} then WaitUntilChanges\n\tR16 when SeeTrafficLight and (not {recognizeInput}) then SlowDown\n\tR16_cont when SlowDown and {environmentClear} then CarDriving\n\t// Rules 17 and 18 combined\n\tR17 when SystemReady and (not (({doorClosed} or {seatBeltOn}) or {destinationExists}))\n\tthen DisplayAlert otherwise AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n\n\tR19 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and {userSaysYes} then CarDriving\n\n\tR20 when SystemReady then DisplayCarInformation\n\tR26 when UserTurnOffSystem then TurnOffSensors eventually \n\tR21 when CalculateShortestPath then TakeShortestPath\n\t unless ({riskLevel} > low)\n\t unless (not {actionIsLegal})\n\tR22 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\n R23 when SystemReady then not RecordPeople\n\t unless {peopleConsentObtained}\nR_new when SystemReady and (not {doorClosed} and not {seatBeltOn}) then DisplayAlert\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n\t// Safety of the driver and of others in the environment\n\tc1 when SystemReady and ((not {userSaysYes}) and (((not {doorClosed}) or (not{seatBeltOn})) or (not {destinationExists}))) then CarDriving\n\t// Legal - road rules must be followed\n\tc2 when SystemReady and (not {actionIsLegal}) then not ChangeCurrentDriving\n\tc3 when SeeTrafficLight and ({redLight} and {recognizeInput}) then not TemporarilyStopCar\n\t// Autonomy - user must remain in control as much as possible\n\tc4 when SystemReady and ({doorClosed} and (({seatBeltOn} and {destinationExists}) and (not {userSaysYes}))) then not AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n c5 when AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (not {userSaysYes}) then CarDriving\n\t// Privacy - use of cameras attached to car\n c6 when CarDriving and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\n\t// Accuracy - for deciding routes and destinations\n\tc7 when TakeUserInput and ((not {destinationExists}) or (not {pathExists})) then not DisplayError\n\t// Emergency vehicle related\n\tc8 when PriorityVehicleNearby and ({ambulanceBehindCar} and ((not {ambulanceOnOppositeSide}) and ((not {ambulanceNextToCar}) and ( {multipleLanes} and ({riskLevel} < medium) )))) then not ChangeLanes\n\n\n\n\n\t//autonomy\n c9 when ReadyToDrive then not ReadyToDrive eventually\n c10 when UserTurnOnSystem then TurnOffSensors\n c11 when UserTurnOffSystem then not TurnOffSensors eventually\n\n //privacy\n c12 when ChangeSpeed and (not {peopleConsentObtained}) then RecordPeople\nconcern_end\n\npurpose_start\n\tpr1 exists UserTurnOnSystem\n pr2 exists UserTurnOffSystem\n pr3 exists TurnOnSensors\n pr4 exists TurnOffSensors\n pr5 exists CheckSystemComponents\n pr6 exists SystemReady\n pr7 exists TakeUserInput\n pr8 exists CalculateShortestPath\n pr9 exists ReadyToDrive\n pr10 exists GetReadyToDrive\n pr11 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive\n pr12 exists DisplayCarInformation\n // Events during driving\n pr13 exists CarDriving\n pr14 exists SlowDown\t\t\t// But not stop completely\n pr15 exists TurnOnHazardsAndTemporarilyStop // Different than temporarily stopping just by hazards, i.e. situation is dangerous and we\u2019re not just temporarily stopping for lights\n pr16 exists TemporarilyStopCar\t\t// Different than parking, system not turned off\n pr17 exists ParkVehicle\t\t// On road shoulder or parking area\n // Parking also implies stopping car and turning of system\n pr18 exists DisplayError\t\t// Error is internal, i.e car systems not properly working\n pr19 exists DisplayAlert \t\t// Alert is external, includes information\n pr20 exists DisplayRoute\n pr21 exists ChangeSpeed\n pr22 exists ChangeLanes\n pr23 exists ChangeCurrentDriving\n pr24 exists TakeNewInput\n pr25 exists TakeShortestPath\n pr26 exists MaintainEqualDistance\n pr27 exists StayCenteredinLane\n pr28 exists SeeTrafficLight\n pr29 exists WaitUntilChanges\n pr30 exists RecordPeople\n // User requests related\n pr31 exists UserChangeRoute\n pr32 exists UserCancelPath\n pr33 exists UserRequestSpeedChange\n pr35 exists AskForClarification\n // Priority vehicle related\n pr36 exists PriorityVehicleNearby\n pr37 exists MakeSpace\n\n // Safely transport user from A to B\n P1 exists CarDriving and (({riskLevel} > low) and {actionIsLegal}) while TakeShortestPath\n // Maintain user autonomy\n P2 exists AskIfUserReadyToDrive and (({doorClosed} and {seatBeltOn}) and {destinationExists})\n P3 exists DisplayCarInformation while SystemReady\n // Ensure emergency vehicles are able to carry out their function without unreasonable impediment\n P4 exists MakeSpace while PriorityVehicleNearby\n // Enable user freedom of movement\n P5 exists UserChangeRoute while CarDriving\n P6 exists UserCancelPath while CarDriving\n P7 exists UserRequestSpeedChange while CarDriving\n P8 exists CarDriving and {userRequestedLaneChange}\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions for alerting the user, making it unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the alert.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the new rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the alert.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 88.75}","ranking_score":88.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"6d7669ddb9e2497bb17b8840188ebaf8","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R_new","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:07:00.742376","use_case":"AutoCAR","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":22,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\", \"new_event\": \"DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\", \"new_measure\": \"DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\", \"new_capability\": \"DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\", \"new_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event DeployDrone is specialized into DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages to ensure the inform action is only triggered in the context of critical damages.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\nevent DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\nR14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 90.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the conditions under which the inform action occurs, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 90.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the inform action should be triggered.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the conditions under which the inform action occurs, with a clear rationale provided.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the conditions under which the inform action occurs, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.5}, \"ranking_score\": 92.5, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 100.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 90.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the context in which the inform action should be triggered.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the conditions under which the inform action occurs, with a clear rationale provided.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed rule maintains stakeholder intent by clarifying the conditions under which the inform action occurs, with a clear rationale provided.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.5}","ranking_score":92.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:40.799490","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":21,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"capability_refinement","patch_id":"g3","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g3\", \"patch_id\": \"g3\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"operation\": \"capability_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Refine capability\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Refine capability' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"missing_element\": \"NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"new_event\": \"NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"new_measure\": \"NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"new_capability\": \"NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"new_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad action InformKeeper is refined into a more specific action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage to clarify the response to drone damage.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 1, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\nevent NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\nR14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:106:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement from InformKeeper to NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage preserves stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale for the action taken in response to drone damage.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the nature of the notification related to drone damage.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The refinement from InformKeeper to NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage preserves stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale for the action taken in response to drone damage.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement from InformKeeper to NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage preserves stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale for the action taken in response to drone damage.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed action NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage is specific and unambiguous, clearly indicating the nature of the notification related to drone damage.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The refinement from InformKeeper to NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage preserves stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale for the action taken in response to drone damage.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The refinement from InformKeeper to NotifyKeeperOfDroneDamage preserves stakeholder intent and provides a clearer rationale for the action taken in response to drone damage.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:40.440241","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:46:9: Expected ID => ' measure *{structura'","id":20,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"measure_specialization","patch_id":"g2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g2\", \"patch_id\": \"g2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancy\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"operation\": \"measure_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize measure\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize measure' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"{structuralDamages}\", \"new_event\": \"{structuralDamages}\", \"new_measure\": \"{structuralDamages}\", \"new_capability\": \"{structuralDamages}\", \"new_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad measure 'damages' is refined into a more specific measure 'structuralDamages' to better distinguish the context of the rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\nmeasure {structuralDamages}:boolean\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\nR14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:46:9: Expected ID => ' measure *{structura'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:46:9: Expected ID => ' measure *{structura'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent of the rule while improving specificity, though the rationale could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder needs.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The measure 'structuralDamages' is a specific refinement of 'damages', enhancing clarity by providing a more precise context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change maintains the original intent of the rule while improving specificity, though the rationale could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder needs.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent of the rule while improving specificity, though the rationale could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder needs.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nmeasure {structuralDamages}:boolean\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\nR14 when DeployDrone and {structuralDamages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The measure 'structuralDamages' is a specific refinement of 'damages', enhancing clarity by providing a more precise context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The proposed change maintains the original intent of the rule while improving specificity, though the rationale could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder needs.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The proposed change maintains the original intent of the rule while improving specificity, though the rationale could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder needs.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:40.067274","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:104:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":19,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"rule_removal","patch_id":"d_remove_R14","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_remove_R14\", \"patch_id\": \"d_remove_R14\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14\", \"operation\": \"rule_removal\", \"operation_label\": \"Remove redundant rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch removes rule R14 because it appears redundant with another rule.\", \"review_flags\": [], \"original_rule\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Remove R14 because it is redundant.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:104:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:104:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b6d50ce93dd84dd68c1241de63a157ba","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R14","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:22:39.704320","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":18,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R17\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that if a compliance check fails, the system will not ensure compliance, addressing the identified concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nR17 when ImplementASPEN and {complianceCheckFailed} then not EnsureCompliance\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action change lacks detailed context on implications for stakeholders.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"cafd58aa8fda4d77ba37f7b3d42b5848","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R17","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:50.634197","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":17,"issue_id":"concerns_4","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R8_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R8_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R8_1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\nR8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\nR8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"cafd58aa8fda4d77ba37f7b3d42b5848","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R8_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:20:50.307723","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":16,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R16\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the carbon footprint is high during drone deployment, the keeper is informed to address potential environmental concerns.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 1, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly defines the condition and action related to carbon footprint during drone deployment.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nR16 when DeployDrone and {carbonFootprint} > high then InformKeeper\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly defines the condition and action related to carbon footprint during drone deployment.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale is understandable, the context of 'InformKeeper' could benefit from further clarification on the implications of this action.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"c5d5ab900bc44a22ab2d918c74874edf","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R16","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:51.105784","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":15,"issue_id":"concerns_3","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R8_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R8_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R8_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R8_1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": false, \"target_fixed\": false, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\nR8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"regression_report\": {}, \"regression_passed\": false, \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"attempt\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\nR8_1_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\nR8_1_2 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium)) then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{}","ranking_score":0.0,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"c5d5ab900bc44a22ab2d918c74874edf","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R8_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:19:50.760418","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":0},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":14,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R4 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 86.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for deploying the drone, though the introduction of 'flightCondition' could be more explicitly defined in the context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 79.12}, \"ranking_score\": 79.12, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4_1 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\nR4_2 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not ({flightCondition} = dangerous))) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 86.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines conditions for deploying the drone, though the introduction of 'flightCondition' could be more explicitly defined in the context.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"The rationale for splitting the rule is understandable, but the changes in action based on flight conditions may require additional context for full clarity on stakeholder intent.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 79.12}","ranking_score":79.12,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:29.288838","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":13,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R4 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions for deploying the drone, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}, \"ranking_score\": 81.25, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and ({flightCondition} = dangerous)) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions for deploying the drone, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the change could be more explicitly connected to the context of the concern.\", \"Adds context to the trigger instead of changing the response.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}","ranking_score":81.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:28.952066","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":12,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R4","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R4\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and adds a specific condition regarding flight safety, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 83.5}, \"ranking_score\": 83.5, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous)\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and adds a specific condition regarding flight safety, enhancing clarity.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the new condition could benefit from further explanation to ensure stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 83.5}","ranking_score":83.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:28.601998","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'","id":11,"issue_id":"concerns_2","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R15\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to prevent deploying the drone when the flight condition is dangerous during the preparation phase.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:47: Expected 'then' => 'ondition} *= dangerou'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the condition under which the drone should not be deployed, making it unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}, \"ranking_score\": 92.75, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nR15 when PreparingDrone and {flightCondition} = dangerous then not DeployDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses established concepts and clearly specifies the condition under which the drone should not be deployed, making it unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the rule is understandable and aligns with stakeholder intent, though it could benefit from more context on the implications of the action change.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 92.75}","ranking_score":92.75,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"b6bf1dbc2c054218b3afc1426e32e5f6","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:18:28.253003","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":10,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"rule_decomposition","patch_id":"d_decompose_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_decompose_R14_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_decompose_R14_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"decomposition\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"operation\": \"rule_decomposition\", \"operation_label\": \"Split rule into cases\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch splits rule R14_1 into clearer cases so each condition and response can be inspected separately.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the split cases still cover the original rule.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Split the related rule into context-specific branches for the concern.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 24}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 85.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and specifies conditions clearly, enhancing understanding.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 80.38}, \"ranking_score\": 80.38, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nR14_1_2 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and (not ({battery} = low))) then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 85.5, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and specifies conditions clearly, enhancing understanding.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for rule decomposition is clear, the context of the concern could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Splits the repair into explicit cases for inspection.\"], \"total_score\": 80.38}","ranking_score":80.38,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:25.037001","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:36: Expected 'then' => '{battery} *= low then'","id":9,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"new_rule_generation","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"concern\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R15\", \"operation\": \"new_rule_generation\", \"operation_label\": \"Add new rule\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Add new rule' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"A new rule is introduced to ensure that when the drone is deployed and the battery is low, it must not ground the drone within 5 minutes, addressing the concern raised in the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 1, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nR15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"failure_reason\": \"SLEEC syntax invalid: None:105:36: Expected 'then' => '{battery} *= low then'\", \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"error\": \"None:105:36: Expected 'then' => '{battery} *= low then'\"}, \"syntax_valid\": false, \"formally_verified\": false, \"regression_passed\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions and actions unambiguously.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}, \"ranking_score\": 86.5, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nR15 when DeployDrone and {battery} = low then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 100, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies conditions and actions unambiguously.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale is understandable, but the action of not grounding the drone within 5 minutes could benefit from further context on its implications.\"], \"total_score\": 86.5}","ranking_score":86.5,"regression_passed":0,"regression_report_json":"{}","related_issue_json":"{}","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"llm","target_fixed":0,"target_rule_id":"R15","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:24.401931","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":8,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"trigger_strengthening","patch_id":"d_strengthen_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_strengthen_R14_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_strengthen_R14_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"operation\": \"trigger_strengthening\", \"operation_label\": \"Add trigger condition\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch adds a contextual trigger condition to rule R14_1 to avoid the problematic case.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Strengthen the rule trigger using the concern context identified by the diagnosis.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition of low battery, which is relevant and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 89.0}, \"ranking_score\": 89.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and ({damages} and ({battery} = low)) then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 86.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and specifies the condition of low battery, which is relevant and unambiguous.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for strengthening the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for strengthening the rule is understandable, but the context of the concern could be more explicitly linked to the proposed changes.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 89.0}","ranking_score":89.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:24.062591","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":7,"issue_id":"concerns_1","issue_type":"concerns","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_concern_defeater_R14_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R14_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_concern_defeater_R14_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R14_1\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R14_1 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Add the concern context as an explicit exception to the related rule.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the battery condition could be more explicitly linked to user intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the battery condition could be more explicitly linked to user intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the battery condition could be more explicitly linked to user intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\nR14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone unless ({battery} = low)\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts clearly and unambiguously, maintaining domain relevance.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the battery condition could be more explicitly linked to user intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the battery condition could be more explicitly linked to user intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 0, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 0, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"646713c6cf16459991874378568dd65b","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R14_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:17:23.708531","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":6,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"trigger_refinement","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Narrow trigger context\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch narrows when rule R4 applies, so the rule fires only in the context relevant to the issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The trigger is refined using the other conflicting rule's context.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, enhancing clarity regarding conditions for deploying the drone.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 79.75}, \"ranking_score\": 79.75, \"rank\": 6}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and ({onIndigenousLand} and (not {privateTerritory})) then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 89.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, enhancing clarity regarding conditions for deploying the drone.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rationale for the changes is somewhat clear, the context of situational conflicts could be better explained to enhance understanding.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 79.75}","ranking_score":79.75,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:49.351214","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":5,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"trigger_refinement","patch_id":"d_trigger_refine_2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"patch_id\": \"d_trigger_refine_2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"operation\": \"trigger_refinement\", \"operation_label\": \"Narrow trigger context\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch narrows when rule R7_1 applies, so the rule fires only in the context relevant to the issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the narrowed trigger does not exclude required behavior.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite trigger is refined using the first rule's context.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, enhancing understanding of the conditions under which the drone should not be deployed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}, \"ranking_score\": 81.25, \"rank\": 5}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and ({privateTerritory} and (not {onIndigenousLand})) then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 95.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 80.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly, enhancing understanding of the conditions under which the drone should not be deployed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"While the rule maintains stakeholder intent, the rationale for the refinement could be more explicitly connected to the situational context.\", \"Narrows the rule trigger to avoid the issue.\"], \"total_score\": 81.25}","ranking_score":81.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:48.993403","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":4,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d1\", \"patch_id\": \"d1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R4 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The conflicting context is converted into an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, enhancing clarity regarding the conditions under which the drone should not be deployed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 83.5}, \"ranking_score\": 83.5, \"rank\": 4}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone unless {privateTerritory}\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 88.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently, enhancing clarity regarding the conditions under which the drone should not be deployed.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for introducing the new condition is somewhat clear, the context of its necessity could be better explained to enhance stakeholder understanding.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 83.5}","ranking_score":83.5,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:48.672018","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":5,"failure_reason":"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.","id":3,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"event_specialization","patch_id":"g1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"g1\", \"patch_id\": \"g1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"llm\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflict\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R4\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"operation_label\": \"Specialize event\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch applies 'Specialize event' to address the selected well-formedness issue.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Review any newly introduced domain concept.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"missing_element\": \"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"new_event\": \"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"new_measure\": \"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"new_capability\": \"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"new_rule\": \"R4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The broad event PreparingDrone is specialized into PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty to clarify the context in which the drone deployment is restricted.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 1, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"semantic_validation\": {\"valid\": false, \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"operation\": \"event_specialization\", \"vocabulary_grounding\": {\"passed\": true, \"new_symbols\": [\"PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\"], \"unsupported_new_symbols\": [], \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\"]}, \"diagnosis_alignment\": {\"passed\": false, \"context_coverage\": 0.01, \"shared_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"landtreatyinplace\", \"onindigenousland\"], \"missing_diagnosis_symbols\": [\"anonymizehuman\", \"at\", \"avoidinterference\", \"backup\", \"backward\", \"battery\", \"bcr\", \"be\", \"because\", \"benefits\", \"blocked_deploydrone\", \"blocked_not_deploydrone\", \"carbonfootprint\", \"checking\", \"collectsample\", \"config\", \"conflict\", \"core\", \"damages\", \"dangerous\", \"deletepictures\", \"detect\", \"detected\", \"domain\", \"encounterhuman\", \"encounterwildlife\", \"end\", \"ensurecompliance\", \"environmentdangerous\", \"exitarea\", \"f0\", \"f10\", \"f100\", \"f102\", \"f103\", \"f104\", \"f106\", \"f118\", \"f119\", \"f122\", \"f123\", \"f127\", \"f130\", \"f134\", \"f154\", \"f155\", \"f156\", \"f157\", \"f158\", \"f159\", \"f160\", \"f161\", \"f162\", \"f163\", \"f164\", \"f165\", \"f166\", \"f167\", \"f168\", \"f169\", \"f170\", \"f171\", \"f172\", \"f175\", \"f177\", \"f178\", \"f179\", \"f180\", \"f181\", \"f182\", \"f183\", \"f184\", \"f185\", \"f186\", \"f189\", \"f190\", \"f206\", \"f210\", \"f213\", \"f217\", \"f354\", \"f355\", \"f356\", \"f357\", \"f358\", \"f359\", \"f36\", \"f360\", \"f361\", \"f362\", \"f363\", \"f364\", \"f365\", \"f366\", \"f367\", \"f37\", \"f374\", \"f375\", \"f378\", \"f379\", \"f383\", \"f397\", \"f398\", \"f399\", \"f40\", \"f400\", \"f401\", \"f402\", \"f403\", \"f404\", \"f405\", \"f406\", \"f407\", \"f408\", \"f409\", \"f41\", \"f410\", \"f411\", \"f412\", \"f413\", \"f414\", \"f419\", \"f420\", \"f423\", \"f424\", \"f427\", \"f428\", \"f430\", \"f434\", \"f44\", \"f45\", \"f46\", \"f48\", \"f5\", \"f50\", \"f99\", \"find\", \"flightcondition\", \"following\", \"for\", \"grounddrone\", \"highlighted\", \"humanidentified\", \"humannearby\", \"humanunderstands\", \"identifyactivity\", \"implementaspen\", \"informhuman\", \"informkeeper\", \"low\", \"low1\", \"measure\", \"medium2\", \"medium3\", \"merged\", \"min\", \"monitorcarbon\", \"monitorland\", \"not_deploydrone\", \"not_storedata\", \"of\", \"preparingdrone\", \"privateterritory\", \"relevantland\", \"restart\", \"returnhome\", \"rule\", \"samelanguage\", \"situation\", \"situational\", \"size\", \"sleec\", \"solving\", \"start\", \"store\", \"takepictures\", \"the\", \"time\", \"to\", \"trace\", \"ub\", \"under\", \"unknownobject\", \"unrelatedactivity\", \"unsafe\", \"unsat\", \"updateterritories\", \"vol\", \"wildlifedisturbed\", \"wildlifeinteractswithdrone\"], \"response_aligned\": true, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\"], \"warnings\": [\"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: anonymizehuman, at, avoidinterference, backup, backward, battery, bcr, be, because, benefits, blocked_deploydrone, blocked_not_deploydrone\"]}, \"operator_validation\": {\"passed\": true, \"errors\": [], \"warnings\": []}, \"temporal_validation\": {\"passed\": false, \"issue_time_bounds\": [\"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 60 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 60 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\", \"within 0 seconds\"], \"original_time_bounds\": [], \"proposed_time_bounds\": [], \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": []}, \"errors\": [\"Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.\", \"Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\"], \"warnings\": [\"New semantic concept(s): PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\", \"Diagnosed context not represented in patch: anonymizehuman, at, avoidinterference, backup, backward, battery, bcr, be, because, benefits, blocked_deploydrone, blocked_not_deploydrone\"]}, \"semantic_validation_passed\": false, \"vocabulary_grounded\": true, \"diagnosis_aligned\": false, \"operator_valid\": true, \"temporal_alignment\": false, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\nevent PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\nR4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"syntax_valid\": true, \"formally_verified\": false, \"requires_social_scientist_review\": true, \"failure_reason\": \"Surfaced for review; semantic validation failed: Diagnosis alignment too weak: 1% of diagnosed context preserved.; Diagnosis contains a temporal constraint, but the proposed repair has no temporal constraint.\", \"attempt\": 5, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event 'PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty' is clear and unambiguous, directly relating to the context of drone deployment restrictions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 3}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\nevent PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\nR4 when PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\n R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The specialized event 'PreparingDroneOnIndigenousLandWithTreaty' is clear and unambiguous, directly relating to the context of drone deployment restrictions.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"While the rationale for the change is understandable, the context of the situational conflicts could be more explicitly connected to stakeholder intent.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"llm","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R4","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:48.339571","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":2,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d2","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d2\", \"patch_id\": \"d2\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R7_1 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"The opposite rule context is given an explicit defeater.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 70.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a clear condition with 'unless {onIndigenousLand}', which is specific and aligns with existing concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}, \"ranking_score\": 85.0, \"rank\": 2}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {onIndigenousLand}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 80.0, \"interpretability\": 70.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule introduces a clear condition with 'unless {onIndigenousLand}', which is specific and aligns with existing concepts.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"The rationale for the change is somewhat clear, but the introduction of the defeater could confuse stakeholders unfamiliar with the context.\", \"Adds an exception while preserving the main rule.\"], \"total_score\": 85.0}","ranking_score":85.0,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:48.000958","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1},{"attempt":1,"failure_reason":"","id":1,"issue_id":"situational_conflicts_1","issue_type":"situational_conflicts","operation":"defeater_introduction","patch_id":"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1","patch_json":"{\"id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1\", \"patch_id\": \"d_cross_defeater_R4_to_R7_1\", \"result_id\": \"\", \"source\": \"deterministic\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R4\", \"R7_1\"], \"target_rule_id\": \"R7_1\", \"operation\": \"defeater_introduction\", \"operation_label\": \"Add exception\", \"stakeholder_summary\": \"This patch updates rule R7_1 by adding an explicit exception instead of changing the main obligation.\", \"review_flags\": [\"Check that the added exception matches stakeholder intent.\"], \"original_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone\", \"proposed_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\", \"missing_element\": \"\", \"new_event\": \"\", \"new_measure\": \"\", \"new_capability\": \"\", \"new_rule\": \"R7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\", \"applicability\": {}, \"natural_language_explanation\": \"Propagate the existing exception from R4 onto R7_1 so the same priority condition is respected by both conflicting rules.\", \"modification_cost\": 1, \"new_events_added\": 0, \"new_measures_added\": 0, \"new_capabilities_added\": 0, \"new_rules_added\": 0, \"defeaters_added\": 0, \"verified\": true, \"target_fixed\": true, \"related_issue\": null, \"patched_sleec\": \"def_start\\n event EncounterHuman\\n event HumanNearby\\n event IdentifyActivity\\n event InformHuman\\n event InformKeeper\\n\\tevent BackUp\\n\\tevent ExitArea\\n\\tevent PreparingDrone\\n\\tevent DeployDrone\\n\\tevent GroundDrone\\n\\tevent ReturnHome\\n\\tevent MonitorLand\\n\\tevent MonitorCarbon\\n\\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tevent AvoidInterference\\n\\tevent EncounterWildlife\\n\\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tevent DeletePictures\\n\\tevent TakePictures\\n\\tevent StoreData\\n\\tevent AnonymizeHuman\\n\\tevent ImplementASPEN\\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\\n\\n\\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\\n\\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\\n\\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\\n\\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\\n\\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\\n\\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\\n\\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\\n\\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\\n\\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\\n\\tmeasure damages: boolean\\n\\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\\n\\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\\n\\ndef_end\\n\\nrule_start\\n\\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\\n then InformHuman\\n\\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\\n\\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\\n\\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\\n\\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\\n\\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\\n\\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\\n\\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\\n\\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\\n\\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\\n\\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\\n\\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\\n\\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\\n then InformKeeper\\n\\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\\n\\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\\n\\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\\n\\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\\n\\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\\n\\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\\n\\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\\n then not DeployDrone\\n\\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\\n\\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\\nrule_end\\n\\nconcern_start\\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\\nconcern_end\\n\\n\\npurpose_start\\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\\n\\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\\n\\tp3 exists DeletePictures\\n\\n\\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\\npurpose_end\", \"validation_result\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": [], \"original_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"wfi_artifacts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"rule_references_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}, \"related_rules_by_type\": {\"concerns\": [], \"conflicts\": [], \"purpose_blocking\": [], \"redundancies\": [], \"situational_conflicts\": []}}, \"verification_depth\": 0, \"syntax_validation\": {\"valid\": true, \"error\": \"\", \"rule_count\": 23}, \"regression_report\": {\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}, \"regression_passed\": true, \"attempt\": 1, \"interpretability_score\": 85.0, \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the situational conflict could be clearer for stakeholders.\"], \"ranking_rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"ranking\": {\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines the condition under which the action is modified.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the situational conflict could be clearer for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the situational conflict could be clearer for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}, \"ranking_score\": 91.25, \"rank\": 1}","patched_sleec":"def_start\n event EncounterHuman\n event HumanNearby\n event IdentifyActivity\n event InformHuman\n event InformKeeper\n\tevent BackUp\n\tevent ExitArea\n\tevent PreparingDrone\n\tevent DeployDrone\n\tevent GroundDrone\n\tevent ReturnHome\n\tevent MonitorLand\n\tevent MonitorCarbon\n\n event CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tevent AvoidInterference\n\tevent EncounterWildlife\n\tevent UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tevent DeletePictures\n\tevent TakePictures\n\tevent StoreData\n\tevent AnonymizeHuman\n\tevent ImplementASPEN\nevent EnsureCompliance // Does not interfere or contradict with pre-existing jurisdictional protections\n\n\tmeasure sameLanguage: boolean\n\tmeasure humanUnderstands: boolean\n\tmeasure unrelatedActivity: boolean\n\tmeasure environmentDangerous: boolean // Bad weather, dangerous terrain ahead, etc\n\tmeasure onIndigenousLand: boolean\n\tmeasure landTreatyInPlace: boolean\n measure relevantLand: boolean // In relevant food & shelter priorities for local humans and animals\n measure privateTerritory: boolean\n measure humanIdentified: boolean\n measure carbonFootprint: scale(low, medium, high)\n\tmeasure benefits: scale(low1, medium1, high1)\n\tmeasure flightCondition: scale(dangerous, unsafe, safe, ideal)\n\tmeasure wildlifeDisturbed: boolean\n\tmeasure wildlifeInteractswithDrone: boolean\n\tmeasure unKnownObject: boolean\n\tmeasure damages: boolean\n\tmeasure battery: scale(low2, medium2, high2)\n\tmeasure store: scale(low3, medium3, high3)\n\ndef_end\n\nrule_start\n\tR1 when EncounterHuman and ({sameLanguage} and {humanUnderstands})\n then InformHuman\n\n R2 when EncounterHuman then IdentifyActivity\n\n R2_1 when IdentifyActivity and {unrelatedActivity} then not StoreData\n\n R3 when HumanNearby and {environmentDangerous} then InformHuman\n\n R4 when PreparingDrone and {onIndigenousLand} then not DeployDrone\n unless {landTreatyInPlace} then DeployDrone\n\n R5 when DeployDrone and {relevantLand} then MonitorLand\n\n R6 when CollectSample then AvoidInterference\n\n R6_1 when DeployDrone then AvoidInterference\n\n // Prior to deploying the drone, ensure territory jurisdictions updated\n R7 when PreparingDrone then UpdateTerritories\n\n // If area is private territory, then don\u2019t deploy drone\nR7_1 when PreparingDrone and {privateTerritory} then not DeployDrone unless {landTreatyInPlace}\n\n // If drone somehow still stumbles onto private territory\n R7_2 when DeployDrone and {privateTerritory} then ExitArea\n\n R8 when DeployDrone then MonitorCarbon\n\n R8_1 when DeployDrone and (({carbonFootprint} > low) and ({benefits} < medium))\n then InformKeeper\n\n R9 when TakePictures and {humanIdentified} then AnonymizeHuman\n unless {unrelatedActivity} then DeletePictures\n\n R10 when ImplementASPEN then EnsureCompliance\n\n R11 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} < safe) then ReturnHome\n unless ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then GroundDrone\n\n R11_cont when ReturnHome then InformKeeper\n\n R11_cont_1 when GroundDrone then InformKeeper\n\n R12 when EncounterWildlife then AvoidInterference\n unless {wildlifeDisturbed} then BackUp\n unless {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then ExitArea within 1 minutes\n\n R12_1 when EncounterWildlife and {wildlifeInteractswithDrone} then InformKeeper\n\n R13 when PreparingDrone and ((({battery} = low) or ({store} = low)) or {damages})\n then not DeployDrone\n\n R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper\n\n R14_1 when DeployDrone and {damages} then GroundDrone\nrule_end\n\nconcern_start\n c1 when PreparingDrone and {damages} then DeployDrone\n c2 when PreparingDrone and ({battery} = low) then DeployDrone\n c3 when DeployDrone and {damages} then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone\n c6 when DeployDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes\n c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\n c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes\nconcern_end\n\n\npurpose_start\n p1 exists CollectSample // Separate event from DeployDrone because not all deployments may result in sample collection\n\tp2 exists UpdateTerritories // Data must include land delineations as well as airfields\n\tp3 exists DeletePictures\n\n\tp4 exists PreparingDrone and {damages} while DeployDrone eventually\npurpose_end","ranking_json":"{\"structural_simplicity\": 94.0, \"logical_simplicity\": 96.0, \"semantic_clarity\": 90.0, \"interpretability\": 85.0, \"semantic_assessment_source\": \"llm\", \"semantic_clarity_reason\": \"The proposed rule uses existing concepts consistently and clearly defines the condition under which the action is modified.\", \"interpretability_reason\": \"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the situational conflict could be clearer for stakeholders.\", \"interpretability_passed\": true, \"interpretability_issues\": [\"The rationale for the change is understandable, but the context of the situational conflict could be clearer for stakeholders.\"], \"rationale\": [\"Keeps the repaired rule structurally compact.\", \"Uses a relatively simple logical condition.\", \"Avoids vague placeholder concepts.\", \"The rule change is easy to interpret from the explanation.\"], \"total_score\": 91.25}","ranking_score":91.25,"regression_passed":1,"regression_report_json":"{\"selected_issue_fixed\": true, \"new_issues_introduced\": false, \"regression_passed\": true, \"before_issue_count\": 6, \"after_issue_count\": 0, \"new_issue_count\": 0, \"resolved_issue_count\": 6, \"remaining_issue_count\": 0, \"before_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 4, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 1, \"situational_conflicts\": 1}, \"after_counts_by_type\": {\"concerns\": 0, \"conflicts\": 0, \"purpose_blocking\": 0, \"redundancies\": 0, \"situational_conflicts\": 0}, \"new_issues\": [], \"resolved_issues\": [{\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:2fdfdbf53cc1e7b8\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c7 when DeletePictures then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:6d5aece4d49b34b1\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c5 when PreparingDrone and ({flightCondition} = dangerous) then DeployDrone Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:72fd94c131e0acc6\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c4 when DeployDrone and ({battery} = low) then not GroundDrone within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"concerns:80e72f67e9690f11\", \"issue_type\": \"concerns\", \"summary\": \"c8 when EnsureCompliance then not InformKeeper within 5 minutes Concern is raised\", \"rule_ids\": []}, {\"fingerprint\": \"redundancies:82f82188f52b6762\", \"issue_type\": \"redundancies\", \"summary\": \"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R14\"]}, {\"fingerprint\": \"situational_conflicts:0a44380c067afdef\", \"issue_type\": \"situational_conflicts\", \"summary\": \": at time 0: PreparingDrone() at time 0: UpdateTerritories() at time 0: Measure(sameLanguage=True, humanUnderstands=True, unrelatedActivity=True, environmentDangerous=True, onIndigenousLand=True, landTreatyInPlace=True,...\", \"rule_ids\": [\"R13\", \"R4\", \"R7_1\"]}], \"remaining_issues\": []}","related_issue_json":"null","run_id":"122b21cca45942168d7361007604c174","source":"deterministic","target_fixed":1,"target_rule_id":"R7_1","timestamp":"2026-09-13T04:15:47.638825","use_case":"ASPEN","verification_depth":0,"verified":1}],"include_patched_sleec":true,"persistence":{"backend":"postgres","database_url_configured":true,"database_url_required":true,"latest_patch_timestamp":"2026-09-18T00:53:26.046406","llm_patch_rows":58,"pending_llm_review_rows":58,"sqlite_path":"","total_patch_rows":122,"verified_llm_rows":58},"philosopher_review_metrics":{"by_operation":{"capability_refinement":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":9,"rejected":0,"total":9},"event_specialization":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":14,"rejected":0,"total":14},"measure_specialization":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":3,"rejected":0,"total":3},"new_rule_generation":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":32,"rejected":0,"total":32}},"by_use_case":{"ALMI":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":3,"rejected":0,"total":3},"ASPEN":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":8,"rejected":0,"total":8},"AutoCAR":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":11,"rejected":0,"total":11},"BSN":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":3,"rejected":0,"total":3},"CSICobot":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":11,"rejected":0,"total":11},"DAISY":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":9,"rejected":0,"total":9},"DPA":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":3,"rejected":0,"total":3},"DressAssist":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":1,"rejected":0,"total":1},"SafeSCAD":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":9,"rejected":0,"total":9}},"overall":{"acceptance_rate":0,"accepted":0,"pending":58,"rejected":0,"total":58}},"philosopher_review_summary":{"acceptance_rate":1.0,"accepted":1,"by_operation":{"event_specialization":{"acceptance_rate":1.0,"accepted":1,"rejected":0,"total":1}},"rejected":0,"total_reviews":1},"philosopher_reviews":[{"comment":"","decision":"accept","explanation":"The broad event DeployDrone is specialized into DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages to ensure the inform action is only triggered in the context of critical damages.","id":1,"issue_id":"redundancies_1","issue_type":"redundancies","operation":"event_specialization","original_rule":"R14 when DeployDrone and {damages} then InformKeeper","patch_id":"g1","proposed_rule":"R14 when DeployDroneWithCriticalDamages then InformKeeper","reviewer":"Philosopher","timestamp":"2026-09-13T05:03:08.715173","use_case":"ASPEN"}],"report_metrics":{"avg_attempts":5.0,"avg_total_time_seconds":26.46,"by_issue_type":{"concerns":74,"redundancies":29,"situational_conflicts":19},"by_operation":{"capability_refinement":9,"defeater_introduction":21,"defeater_propagation":2,"event_specialization":14,"measure_specialization":3,"new_rule_generation":32,"rule_decomposition":18,"rule_removal":6,"trigger_refinement":4,"trigger_strengthening":13},"by_source":{"deterministic":64,"llm":58},"by_use_case":{"ALMI":7,"ASPEN":19,"AutoCAR":19,"BSN":7,"CSICobot":28,"DAISY":13,"DPA":9,"DressAssist":4,"SafeSCAD":16},"deterministic_patch_rows":64,"llm_patch_rows":58,"philosopher_reviewed_rows":0,"social_review_required_rows":58,"total_patch_rows":122,"verified_patch_rows":122},"status":"OK","use_case":"ALL"}